Are you going to let Sam Altman’s crypto project scan your eyeballs or not?

Chain Reaction
174 Episodes • Last Episode: March 29, 2024

Welcome back to Chain Reaction.

To get a roundup of TechCrunch’s biggest and most important crypto stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday at 12 p.m. PT, subscribe here.

Earlier this week, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman’s audacious eyeball-scanning crypto startup Tools for Humanity started the global rollout of its Worldcoin product. The company wants to help build a reliable solution for “distinguishing humans from AI online,” enable “global democratic processes” and “drastically increase economic opportunity” the company said in a release.

The startup, which raised about $250 million altogether from backers like Andreessen Horowitz, Khosla Ventures and Reid Hoffman, said it’s rolling out its identity technology as well as its token internationally.

The project gives eligible participants 25 Worldcoin (WLD) tokens, currently worth about $55, for onboarding. During its trial phase, more than 2 million people signed up and scanned their eyes for the startup’s biometric database.

With that said, not everyone is excited about this endeavor and find the 25 tokens a nominal tradeoff for some of their biological data. Some people are also arguing that Worldcoin is exploitative for initially recruiting participants through poorer countries.

In an interview with MIT Technology Review, Worldcoin CEO Alex Blania acknowledged there was some “friction,” with the startup, but attributed it to the fact that the company was still in its early phases.

The “Orb tour” began in Tokyo in April 2023 and has spread to other locations across North America, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.

Although the Worldcoin token is not available to U.S. citizens due to regulatory restrictions, that hasn’t stopped the startup from advertising appointments to get your eyeballs scanned in major American cities like Miami, New York City and San Francisco. I even spotted a few advertisements this week as I walked through mid and lower Manhattan, but did not make an appointment.

Individuals who participate must consent to the startup’s biometric data collection. The consent form has three options: don’t agree to anything (no data collected and no scan happens), agree to Orb scan but opt out of data custody (data collected, but temporarily stored) or agree to Orb scan and full data custody.

Worldcoin’s services are also not eligible to people in 11 other countries, including Ukraine, Russia, Iran and Cuba, according to its user terms and conditions.

If Worldcoin succeeds, there’s potential for the startup to have one of the largest databases of human biometrics, which could come with security risks if the information is not protected properly. In turn, that data could help prove who is real online — and on the blockchain — a non-trivial problem to solve.

On the other hand, if the startup doesn’t gain mass adoption, it could leave investors with a big hole in their pockets, and could make those who signed up susceptible to their personal information being sold to others (which is apparently already happening).

With all that said, would you sign up?

This week in web3

  1. Wormhole digs out of its hole with new security measures to move on from $320M hack
  2. Avalanche Foundation to invest $50M in asset tokenization on its blockchain
  3. After federal court win, Ripple’s legal head still expects the battle for regulatory clarity to drag on
  4. a16z-backed Eco unveils Beam, a P2P crypto transfer service aiming to be a ‘global Venmo’
  5. Crypto wallet Zengo launches pro subscription with additional security features

The latest pod


For this week’s episode, Jacquelyn interviewed Deana Burke and Natasha Hoskins, the co-founders of Boys Club.

Boys Club is a social decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) for the “crypto curious.” Originally designed to get women and non-binary people into the web3 world, it now aims to be an open space for anyone looking to get into the space.

Although it’s a social DAO, Boys Club has a handful of other ventures, like their newsletter and podcast, which I was a guest on, as well as events like crypto conference parties and trivia nights.

Before Boys Club, Deana and Natasha were co-founders of a recently acquired travel platform Allcall. Deana was also a communications partner for the blockchain-based Celo Foundation and Natasha previously worked at Fora Travel as a general manager.

We discussed the origin story for Boys Club, what trends Deana and Natasha are following and how they’ve seen the industry evolve since launching their group.

We also talked about:

  • EthCC 2023 vibe check
  • Inclusivity in web3
  • Diversifying the industry
  • Advice for the crypto newbies

The bonus pod

This week we also have a bonus episode. Jacquelyn interviewed Stu Alderoty, chief legal officer of Ripple Labs.

Stu spent most of his career working for traditional financial institutions in legal roles at firms like CIT Group, American Express and HSBC and left that world in 2019 to join Ripple.

Ripple has been around since 2012, but has been making headlines lately for the recent federal court ruling that stated the XRP token, which is linked to Ripple, is not a security when sold to the general public but can be treated as a security for past XRP sales to institutional clients.

We broke down the nitty gritty details of the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York federal court ruling for Ripple and what it means for the company, XRP token and crypto ecosystem.

We also talked about:

  • Securities versus commodities
  • Ripple’s SEC lawsuit
  • Future regulation and clarity
  • Advice for other startups

Need to catch up before you listen? Read these for a quick overview:

Subscribe to Chain Reaction on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or your favorite pod platform to keep up with the latest episodes, and please leave us a review if you like what you hear!

Follow the money

  1. Flashbots raised $60 million in a Series B to help improve Ethereum-based infrastructure
  2. Web3 gaming developer Delabs Games raised $4.7 million in a seed round
  3. Decentralized cloud infrastructure provider Aethir raised about $9 million at $150 million valuation
  4. EthStorage raised $7 million in a seed round at a $100 million valuation to scale Ethereum through its layer-2 solution
  5. Side Protocol raised $1.5 million through a SAFT to grow its cross-chain liquidity network

This list was compiled with information from Messari as well as TechCrunch’s own reporting.

What else we’re reading

Want to branch out from the world of web3? Here are some articles on TechCrunch that caught our attention this week.

  1. Microsoft’s and Alphabet’s results indicate the AI game is more of a long-term strategy
  2. 5 founders discuss why SAFEs are better for early-stage and bridge rounds
  3. Finding CEO: It’s the new ‘Finding Nemo’
  4. Hackers are infecting Call of Duty players with a self-spreading malware
  5. Don’t fall into the toxic workplace trap

Follow me on Twitter @Jacqmelinek for breaking crypto news, memes and more.

Chain Reaction

Hosts

Author Avatar
Jacquelyn Melinek

Senior Reporter, Crypto

Latest

Chain Reaction

Episodes

As AI proliferates and things on the internet are easier to manipulate, there’s a need more than ever to make sure data and brands are…

The AI world needs more data transparency and web3 startup Space and Time says it can help

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto, formerly known as Chain Reaction. This is the last edition of this newsletter. I want to personally thank each of you…

SBF sentenced, Worldcoin hit with another ban order and big web3 pre-seed rounds are back

Many of the people building web3 feel like the traditional web ecosystem has taken advantage of users and their data. While it benefits a number…

A new web3 network is being built right now that wants to end Big Tech’s control of your data

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto. This week, Starbucks killed its Odyssey NFT program, Solana continued to see memecoin momentum and India faces more challenges with the…

Solana memecoin hype continues, Backpack’s beta phase was a success and Starbucks axes its NFT program

Starbucks launched Starbucks Odyssey in 2022 as its initial foray into the web3 world.

Starbucks ditches its Odyssey NFT program

Two months ago, media giant Fox Corp. partnered with Polygon Labs, the team behind the Ethereum-focused layer-2 blockchain, to tackle deepfake distrust. Fox and Polygon…

Blockchain tech could be the answer to uncovering deepfakes and validating content

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto, formerly known as Chain Reaction — it was an eventful week in the crypto world.

Bitcoin hits new high, Solana price jumps as memecoins mania rises and Worldcoin faces heat in Spain

Zora, an NFT-based social network platform, is continuing its expansion beyond the crypto-sphere into the hot artificial intelligence market, Dee Goens, the startups’ co-founder, said…

NFT platform Zora is offering a novel way for AI model makers to earn money

Welcome back to TechCrunch Crypto. It was an eventful week: bitcoin’s price hit a new high, Spain’s data protection authority banned Worldcoin and Binance raised…

Bitcoin hits highs, Binance launches a crypto perfume and Coachella partners with OpenSea

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto. Here’s the biggest news this week: bitcoin’s price jumped and Coinbase’s app crashed, Telegram rolled out a plan to pay out…

Bitcoin jumped and Coinbase’s app crashed, while Aptos eyes Hong Kong and Telegram rolls out rewards with TON

NFTs don’t always get taken very seriously, particularly now that AI and content creators are hogging the spotlight, but not everyone is so quick to…

Animoca Brands’ Yat Siu sees NFTs as a way to protect ownership in the age of AI

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto, formerly known as Chain Reaction. This is our fifth edition with of course, regularly scheduled news bits, but also some recurring…

Crypto VC exits were low in Q4 2023, Phantom MAU’s reach new highs and spot bitcoin ETF volumes are still rising

Hello and welcome back to the fourth edition of the new and improved TechCrunch Crypto newsletter. Let’s get into the big headlines.

Farcaster hype grows, Bluesky opens to the public and SEC’s Hester Peirce is open to new token proposals

a16z’s Chris Dixon thinks it’s time to focus on blockchains’ use cases, not speculation

“I’m not anti-speculation, but I think it’s a question of priorities… It’s putting the cart before the horse.”

a16z’s Chris Dixon thinks it’s time to focus on blockchains’ use cases, not speculation

Hello and welcome back to the third edition of the new and improved TechCrunch Crypto newsletter.

Tether had ‘record-breaking’ net profits in Q4, Polygon Labs does layoffs and hackers steal $112M of XRP

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto, formerly known as Chain Reaction. To get a roundup of TechCrunch’s biggest and most important crypto stories delivered to your inbox…

Bitcoin and Ethereum decline on the week, Worldcoin to launch a new Orb and Terraform Labs files for bankruptcy

Distinct from the Ripple network and protocol, the XRP Ledger is a decentralized public ledger with an open-source code base that anyone can contribute to…

After 12 years, Ripple’s president sees its payment and enterprise businesses evolving further

Welcome to TechCrunch Crypto, formerly known as Chain Reaction. Alongside our regularly scheduled news bits, I’ll be testing out some recurring segments and features —…

Bitcoin spot ETF volume rose, Coinbase went to court, Solana Mobile announces new device and Google cuts crypto apps in India

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. This past week has been all about U.S. spot bitcoin ETFs in the crypto world.

US spot bitcoin ETFs begin trading, Circle files for IPO and India continues crypto pullback

It’s been a long road for spot bitcoin ETF filers — and today the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission finally approved all 11 standing applications from…

Grayscale CEO sees spot bitcoin ETF as first step toward ‘normalizing’ crypto

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. Wouldn’t a bitcoin spot ETF approval be nice?

Talks of bitcoin spot ETF approval circulate as India blocks exchange sites and crypto is seeing more optimism

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. To get a roundup of TechCrunch’s biggest and most important crypto stories delivered to your inbox every Thursday at 12…

Dog-themed memecoins are pawing their way back into investors’ hearts

Warden thinks one of the biggest avenues for real world use cases is tokenization of assets and areas that aren’t even tradable yet.

Why tokenization of assets can be a key driver of growth in crypto

Robinhood is on a quest to dive deeper into crypto

The platform might not be as highly technical as one that’s crypto-focused, but Robinhood is doing research to understand what customers want and are missing.

Robinhood is on a quest to dive deeper into crypto

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. Even though it’s the season to feel jolly, that’s not stopping hackers from acting out.

Crypto hacks and chaos aren’t halting this holiday season

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. In general, the total crypto market cap steadily rose 14% in the past week as more capital enters the crypto…

Bitcoin continues climbing, Block releases hardware wallet, Robinhood expands to EU and VCs may see some relief soon

The crypto industry is facing the same macroeconomic headwinds as others, with the added bonus of regulatory uncertainty.

The venture landscape may be on the ‘cusp’ of explosive growth after years of macro strain

We didn’t publish a Chain Reaction newsletter last week because of Thanksgiving. But we’re back — and saying goodbye to November after a month filled…

Crypto saw lots of chaos, charges and price changes in November

The goal is to help users forget which chain developers are building on, because it ultimately won’t matter.

Optimism execs are optimistic for Ethereum’s future amid its ongoing scaling battle

Welcome back to Chain Reaction. The crypto market and overall ecosystem may be showing signs of recovery after a prolonged bear market.

Crypto market showing signs of recovery as prices, NFT sales rise on the month