How We Hate NBC’s Olympics Coverage: A Statistical Breakdown
Erick Schonfeld
Feb 28, 2010

The coverage of the Winter Olympics on NBC has been painful to watch. In addition to the tape delays which ruined the outcomes for anyone paying attention to any other news, sports or social media outlet other than NBC, there are a lot of other complaints. In between the hard-hitting reports of polar bears in the Canadian North and life among the lumberjacks, NBC did manage to squeeze in some actual Winter games, which were matched in quantity by the constant loop of the same handful of commercials on heavy rotation for McDonald’s, Visa, AT&T, Diet Coke, and NBC’s upcoming shows Parenthood and the Marriage Ref. (Thank goodness for DVRs).

We already know that NBC’s handling of its Olympics coverage sucks, if only because everyone on Twitter says so. Right now, Twitter Sentiment shows that 73 percent of Tweets about “NBC Olympics” are negative. But what are they complaining about exactly, and is it just Twitter? Some new data from Crimson Hexagon, another sentiment analysis service for brands, shows the breakdown of hate:

Tape Delay Horrible: 19%
NBC Is Awful In General: 13%
Commentators Are Lacking: 9%
Not Enough Sports: 20%
Mobile/Web Lousy: 12%
Other Complaints: 12%
Happily Watching: 15%

These numbers come from an analysis of nearly 20,000 Tweets and 5,700 blog posts and forum comments. On Twitter alone, the biggest complaint by far (25 percent) is the tape delay. But that’s what you’d expect from a bunch of realtime addicts. Overall when you count blogs and forums that complaint ranked second, barely nudged out by the lack of enough actual sports coverage. Notably, only 15 of people on the Web were happy with NBC’s coverage.

Perhaps people just go to the Web to complain, and happy viewers had no reason to log on because they were enthralled by those polar bears. But something tells me the Web’s view reflects the general one. How do you rate NBC’s coverage?

Advertisement
Advertisement
  • genomecop

    Well, while we are on the subject, how about they get some YOUNG talent to host the show…get rid of these old farts making ridiculous comments about the color of someones outfit..get a f…ing life.

  • Patrick Dukes

    I get annoyed by the commercials. You forgot to mention Nationwide’s Worlds Greatest Spokesperson in the World and all the GE medical commercials.

    Also, if we’re going to have tape delays anyway, why can’t they organize it better. Say I want to watch bobsled. Why do I have to watch two teams sled, then watch a half our of figure skating, and then get more teams sledding. Let’s just show an hour of bobsled and then an hour of figure skating. The bait and switch tactics have been horrible.

  • silverlightsucks

    Silverlight sucks, I don’t get why they couldn’t use flash or streaming video formats themselves instead of a program nobody uses that hardly works.

  • Chad

    I do think that NBC has a long way to go with its coverage, but as we know, gauging sentiment on the Internet suffers from selection bias.

    The TC community is unique in that it keeps up with every single little headline. I highly doubt that the majority of Americans know who the winner of an event is by the time they sit down and watch the event at night (unless they see it on Sportscenter or the evening news).

    Furthermore, I think people like to complain about knowing the results beforehand based solely on principle. OK, I get that. But does it really affect your viewing experience? Other than, say, hockey, almost all Olympic sports are judged iteratively, so you can gauge the likely outcome well in advance of every contestant having gone. And anyways, it just seems like a petty thing to complain about–you know its going to be in the news, so just do not read it!

  • Stevie

    NBC just sucks. There were like 37 steps to be able to watch online, and even after all that digital hoop jumping the video never would load. At least during the Beijing games you could watch all events live online. Bob Costas is a total tool and Mary Carillo just needs to go away. There was far too little sports and far too much fluff. With USA, NBC, MSNBC, CNBC, and Universal Sports channels coverage should have been great. Is anyone really watching MSNBC and CNBC? These two channels should have been all Olympics all the time. The ratings sure show the lack of viewers on those two channels.

  • Joelm

    Question: while watching the speed skating it was very obvious that there are other better camera positions around the track. Same is true at the bobsled venue. You can see motorized cameras following the action on rails. But after watching the entire event, no shots from those positions ever show up in the NBC coverage. SO, who is getting this better coverage? And how can I get a look at it? And why didn’t NBC buy into those feeds??

  • http://hcokim.com Harold

    this graph is a complete surprise to me – talking to most of the people on campus here at Carnegie Mellon, they love the olympics and haven’t even mentioned anything about the broadcasts at all. i don’t think NBC’s coverage is bad enough to warrant any serious negative sentiments, or i’d be hearing more about those than the excitement i hear about short track or figure skating. id be confident in saying the vast, vast majority of olympics viewers are NOT on twitter or – more realistically – voicing their opinions on a social media site, and these results don’t do much to reflect the real opinions of the public.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1498411521 Michael Boyd

    So change the channel and quit complaining.

    What a pointless post.

  • tpp

    To me the biggest problem is the never ending stream of “human interest stories”. Hell, it’s a SPORTING event. Show the sports.

  • tcrowns

    CTV/Global in Canada bought the television rights to the games and as such had the best shots.

  • http://area224.com Dave Van de Walle

    See “Leno vs. Conan.” That would be the real reason NBC would politely nod to your comments and move on to showing what appeals to the mass audience.

    Found it interesting that the number one reason was “Not Enough Sports.” Sounds like a Winter vs. Summer Olympics problem more than anything.

    Also, for every person that complains about not enough coverage of sports themselves — is it me or was the cable coverage dominated by curling?

  • http://www.dailyplunge.com mdhenshaw

    Add they forced Conan O’brien to leave the Tonight Show to the list.

  • Andrew

    In Canada, CTV has done a really great job broadcasting the Olympics to the masses. They have different events playing on different channels (SD&HD) at all times, you don’t need to pay a premium to watch any of the games on specialty channels, and there is free online HD streaming of every event, including HD replays and clips.

    Hopefully NBC broadcasts the hockey game this afternoon on NBC and doesn’t opt for MSNBC again. The Olympics are for everybody, there shouldn’t be any hoops to jump through.

    Go Canada!

  • http://matchesmalone.wordpress.com Matches Malone

    NBC/Universal exposed a massive #fail in their philosophy going with ads for new shows. They should’ve promoted existing shows that still have an audience, with viewers chomping at the bit to come back for them. Of course, that’s only really two or three shows right now, as NBC has decided that fifth place is a good place to be as a network, based on their recent dealings with Conan.

  • Andrew

    It’s CTV in Canada. Maybe you can check it out, all the clips are in HD.

    http://www.ctvolympics.ca/video/index.html

    If you can’t…well, at least you get Hulu.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=500420440 Brad Nickel

    Until I read this post, I didn’t know I had something to complain about. I watch the sports I want to when they are on and don’t watch the rest. I also happen to like learning about the people behind the sports, so don’t hate the profiles.

    Love the “Go World” spots by Visa.

  • Mark

    Thank goodness we have amazing, almost 24/7 coverage by CTV in Canada. Great coverage of not just Canadian teams and athletes, but of competitors from all around the world. What a great games, what a great time.

  • Jos

    Stupid silverligth

  • Victoria

    Haven’t wanted to put the hate in my Twitter feed but I second these comments! The Costas/Carillo show has been a big #fail in my opinion!

  • Bob

    Oh, cry me a river. I agree with you about everything, but I’m not sure we can find a way to solve your problems for one simple reason: cost. The Olympics are expensive and they get most of their money from TV rights. If you want to pay for the games with ads, it means we’re going to see a bunch of them. I wish they could film some different ads because they seem stuck on some tight cycle, but I don’t think the companies can afford lots of fancy ads and lots of fancy sports.

    There’s another side effect: you can’t just advertise to the men because the men never buy anything except cars and beer. So you’ve got to expand the appeal of the games to women and that means more stories. I know there are some women out there who like the competition, but the fattest part of the demographic like a nice mixture of light documentary and some competition.

    So we’re stuck with this and I submit it’s what we want. There’s no reason why the biathalon and curling championships can’t stream 100% competition during the off years, but the folks grousing about the Olympics aren’t stepping up to pay for these 100% competition streaming broadcasts.

    I think some people just aren’t happy with anything and they’re not willing to think through their complaints to figure out whether the fix is feasible. As far as I can tell, the fix for these complaints means charging for viewing and I don’t detect the interest.

  • Arun

    TC just hates Silverlight. They would sound dumb if they mentioned Silverlight in the post. They are trying all other methods. Am so sure we wouldn’t have seen so many complaints if it were being broadcast in Flash.

  • Mr. Mike

    There was just too much of it. It seems NBC interwove Olympics coverage into every news broadcast, which got really old by the second week. I’d have been fine with an hour a day of highlights and some of the human interest stories, with additional coverage during regular news/sports broadcasting. It felt like the entire network was hijacked by the Olympic coverage team. They have to realize that not everyone finds several hours a day of watching other people slide around riveting.

    Also, I found their fixation with medal count by country tacky. It should be about the achievements of the athletes, not their countries.

  • Mark J

    Absolutley horrible coverage. There must have been 40 minutes of commercials per hour. So frustrating watching an even like skiing where the would show 2 runs, then cut to comercials for 3 minutes, then 2 more runs, then more commercials. Terrible.

    The event jumping was also horrible. 5 minutes of skating, then 7 minutes of bobsled, then 12 minutes of skiing, then 6 minutes of skating again. Completely unwatchable. Stick with an even and see it through!

    The camera work was equally terrible. Note to NBC video producers. Extreme closeups don’t work for capturing action. They were always way to close to get any perspective on the movement of the sport. Pan OUT a bit for the love of God!

  • http://sco.tt Scott Yates

    So you like using the DVR but you are upset about the tape delay? Isn’t a DVR a tape delay?

    Tweets are realtime, so it makes sense that super-tweeters would be complaining about the lack of real time.

    For the other 99 percent of the world, the tape delay is no big deal. NBC is getting the best ratings ever for winter games.

  • Katie

    sigh, everyone hates Silverlight.

  • Magnuson

    No sh*t the author of this useless post hasn’t been watching the Olympics. Vancouver is a stunning and sophisticated city. If you want snow and lumberjacks go to Wisconsin or Northern Michigan, that is where your stereotypical view of Canadians actually are, and ah hem, they are Americans.

  • EG

    Didn’t need to watch NBC. I was perfectly happy with all the LIVE sports coverage here in Canada from CTV and the other Olympic Consortium stations. :)

  • a dude

    this is the internet. it is not linear. you should be able to navigate through all tiers of all the sports that have been recorded so far and watch any of it on demand. and just like in starship troopers where they have that “would you like to know more?” they could do the same about athlete’s back stories.

  • JD

    You know Tape Delay was bad enough then now something that NBC is doing better and you all blame a Television. Here is a good thought NBC is the only local NBC station in some areas and how about if you do hate NBC then please block your NBC channel if you hate it so much. How about FOX news during the Bush Administration and Democrats complain about that network being embedded with the Bush Administration. Does anyone complain that the Networks are too British including ABC,NBC,CBS, and FOX hell no. People complain that the Media is complain by Obama, Bush, and the Israeli Lobby.

  • Jim

    The coverage on the local side was over-saturated, too much repeating and re-hashing of what was already said. Guessing this was to reach the people who weren’t watching, but it felt like too much.

    Their on-demand coverage was really awful IMHO… you couldn’t watch any actual event… just a lot of gimmicky interactive stuff, and a bunch of stories, highlights and other non-sports edited content.

    The mobile app was really good for iPhone, but sucked for other platforms. 0ne very interesting thing about the iPhone mobile app was how it actually utilized the athletes twitter feeds, and encouraged social networking.

    I never went to the website, but for the record I don’t hate silverlight.

    Overall, I liked the coverage, though the delay was a bit confusing… I was receiving updates on my iphone for certain events before they were aired on TV. I ended up just watching the medal count on my phone in the end… missed a lot of the events I’d have liked to see like Snowboard Cross, etc…. because I just wasn’t around, and/or wasn’t invested.

    DVRs are great, but DVRing the Olympics means setting aside hours and hours when what i really wanted was just to watch a specific event, and not all the other stuff. I really wish the on-demand content had been an organized list of each sport/event, allowing me to watch that event, in it’s entirety. Maybe that was what they had on their website – dunno.

  • http://www.mybloglog.com/buzz/members/RHiebert/ R. Hiebert

    I’ll bet these cameras on rails are for making the DVDs where supposed to buy.

  • Lou Lange

    Since NBC has the contract for the 2012 and 2014 Olympics, it might be wise for them to think about partnering with the BBC (2012-London) and whatever broadcast network will be used in Russia (2014-Sochi) to provide DECENT over-the-air and internet coverage. It would provide a wide range of broadcasting talent and improved coverage all around.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=624316777 James Hicks

    I dislike what NBC is doing as well – with the social web providing real-time results it’s a shame that it takes days before we can see the actual event on TV.

    I’ve decided to get all my news (sports, news, whatever) from INFOtainment News: http://www.infotainmentnews.net

  • Jim

    Too many commercials is just not a valid excuse for not liking the coverage. It’s not cheap to own the exclusive airtime rights for the Olympics. You aren’t willing to pay for it, so advertisers are.

    If you want less commercials on TV – then start buying more products, cause the more you ignore ads or skip over them in your DVR, the less money advertisers are willing to pay, and the more inventory broadcasters have to sell to stay in business.

    Personally, I’d have preferred a $10 paid on-demand option, with less/no commercials and a full lineup of every sport and every event… watch what you want, when you want. Maybe next time.

  • Amy D

    I’m glad I’m not the only one disgusted with the coverage. Yet, I’m not one to only complain, so – an idea… IF the world believes in the power and contribution of noble sports competition for the betterment of the world, and IF countries believe in supporting their athletes (not just the professional ones donning Olympic garb), and IF we believe the Olympics can be a truly unifying purpose around the world in connecting humanity and that which is good – THEN why not have each nation contribute some part of GNP to an Olympics “fund” to offer fair balanced, sports-centric coverage? Clearly the ad model does not work let alone serve the purpose of providing true, GOOD if not great, coverage in terms of Live events. There could be a decent aftermarket for advertisers a la a “pay per view/pay as you go” offering; but for the real-time, true competition in ALL sports by ALL athletes from ALL countries, it needs to be coverage that is global-neutral and digitally-centric.

    Anyway, it’s an idea. I remember when coverage was pretty darn good – even without the digital capabilities,etc. The camera shots were great; there was a breadth of sports coverage, and athletes; and for goodness’ sake, there were not “color”stories. This is a SPORTS global event. All the content should be that, not the ridiculous travel & leisure stuff.

    So who’s watching the hockey game later today?

  • Tony

    Your comments about Silverlight reek of ignorance. It is no wonder you “don’t get why”.

  • Rich

    Yeah. BBC has done a great job of covering the Winter Olympics with up to 5 screens of live coverage around the clock on TV and online.

    …and no ads AT ALL…ever.

  • Patrick

    I don’t see why anyone can complain about tape delay. How would it EVER make sense to show live coverage all day long? Its quite obvious that some events deserve more airtime than others (or better placed airtime, at least).

    ***The world doesn’t revolve around what us Americans want out of our TV.*** Remember, the Olympics are watched around the globe and if we aired all of the events WE wanted to watch during prime time live then we leave someone else in the same rut.

    Its time to get over your instant gratification lifestyle and start 1) thinking about others and 2) think through the reality of resolving all your complaints (i.e. money, time, etc.)

  • JD

    It even goes for CNBC and MSNBC and block them as well.

  • JD

    Because Tape Delay isn’t the same as it being live.

  • JD

    Maybe if people hate NBC so much should consider buying a cable business and cancelling all NBC Channels and putting in the CBC. The problem with American Media is this they have a monopoly on everything even through local stations. My local 1 out of 2 NBC stations sucks. But what NBC is doing for the olympics is great. Live coverage all day untill midnight with a few news breaks and ads.

  • Toy Needle

    I hate the Olympics. I watched NBC’s coverage ever single night, so I am able to tell you in excrutiating detail how much I hated every moment of NBC’s coverage. But NBC doesn’t give a conan if I *liked* it–just that I watched it. So quit yer bellyachin’.

  • Jason

    Has there ever been an olympics where people liked the coverage? It seems like this is a theme every two years. I’m not a big fan and watch very little so it seems that most of what I hear is headline wins and “coverage sucks”. Is good coverage actually possible, where ‘good’ means ‘rated as good by al least 50% of people’?

  • http://www.plasticsurgeryinhouston.net plasticsurgeryinhouston

    When they didn’t show the Canada-USA hockey game on NBC…that was it for me.

  • Pay Attention

    After spending some time reviewing articles like this I have come to the conclusion that all the complaining is about complaining, having a voice, and having absolutely no critical thinking skills. The pie chart proves it. There is no smoking gun here. A good analysis would state that the remarkable even distribution of dissatisfaction suggests that nothing is wrong.
    1. Tape delay. Can most people watch at work? If live how do you handle the live down time? This article bashes the delay and then suggests DVR use in the same paragraph.
    2. If not NBC who? CBS, ABC, FOX, PBS. Still, 13% will complain about the network.
    3.Comentators. O.K. who do we want? Justin Kutcher, Ashton Kutcher, who? Maybe some guy named Quinlan.
    4. More sports. Do we just number the athletes and treat it like a dog race? Sports junkies won’t admit it but it’s all human interest. They follow their favorites.
    The internet exposes what I think may be unprecedented negativity as a mass cultural phenomenon, extreme selfishness, basic ignorance, general stupidity, and the need to express it.
    Think for one minute. If you were a network executive, how would you do a better job on a budget? Yes a budget. You need sponsors so there will be ads. The sponsors won’t pay unless their ad is seen so there will be tape delays. You want to appeal to all the demographics so there is all types of human interest. Show live stuff that won’t make prime time… You see…. It really can’t get much better because coverage is market driven.

    For the record I think I’ve seen more events than ever. I know what companies were willing to sponsor the coverage. Costas et. al. are good at what they do. I know who the athletes are… Oh crap! I’m happy.

  • norah

    Everyone I knew of, even the ones who like to do payperview hates the whole coverage of NBC olympics, and as usual they didn’t even gave a chance for viewers outside US to catch a glimpse of the whole event.. And guess what? They monopolize the whole olympics by disallowing 3rd party streaming website and filtered out youtube to stream this one…

    I must say this one is one of the worst!

  • Angela

    I was lucky to be in Canada during the Olympics and was able to see some of the CTV coverage. In just comparing what I saw there and what NBC has done, NBC was sorely lacking. And I won’t even talk about the internet coverage. And don’t think that CTV’s coverage is great this year because the Olympics are in Canada. We had this same issue 2 years ago with the Summer Olympics. CBC had the coverage and they were superior to NBC even then. The Canadians know how to cover the Olympics. NBC needs to learn from them. The Canadian coverage always gets Gold, and NBC isn’t even in metal contention.

  • Angela

    Actually, NBC DOESN’T have the rights to the 2014 Olympics.

  • Smith

    “NBC is awful in general General” Way to bride the gap between unbiased and biased media.

  • http://www.greenhoof.com/2010/02/28/nbcs-olympic-studio-furnished-with-reclaimed-wood/ Greenhoof » Blog Archive » NBC’s Olympic Studio Furnished with Reclaimed Wood

    [...] coverage of the 2010 Olympic Winter Games has drawn comments from the sidelines, ranging from How We Hate NBC’s Olympics Coverage: A Statistical Breakdown to NBC delivers the goods in Winter Games coverage. We will stay out of the content debate, but we [...]

  • blargh

    …and they don’t know why

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=630414803 Mike McCready

    I actually thought NBC’s coverage was good. I certainly don’t follow most of those athletes any other time than through the Olympics and I thought NBC did a good job of making you care about the competitions and the athletes with good back stories and I thought that through all their various channels they did a good job covering a large number of sports. And the tape delay? Well, most people are working when most f the sports are played so showing the competition in real time would have meant far fewer people would have seen the events. It was easy to avoid knowing the results ahead of time and even if you’re like me and wanted to know the results asap it still didn’t ruin seeing the actual competition.

    All those complainers would have probably made the same decisions NBC made in their shoes. Maybe what they don’t like is the medium of TV now that real time social media is available and they’re used to the immediacy of the web. I get that but that’s not what NBC is about.

  • http://kroq.radio.com/2010/02/28/the-world-is-live-nbcs-olympics-should-be-too/ The World Is Live. NBC’s Olympics Should Be Too. « KROQ FM – The World Famous KROQ

    [...] analysis for the NBC Olympics” broke 73 percent negative and 27 percent positive. Click here to see the whole [...]

  • Aaron

    Living in Seattle we are oh so close to the games but you had to avoid the radio, web, twitter, and even the local news if you did not want to spoil the fact the games were not shown live. If I get up early or stay up late to watch a competition live in Europe I would find a way to watch an event live in my own time zone!
    Additionally while I am a proud American I want to see all of the events, even those without US athletes but the NBC broadcast always has such a US focus. Sure you see the finals but not qualifications. We have a Canada cable channel that I would always turn to in the past since they would show stuff live AND they would show events that NBC would not show (and this includes coverage across all of the other channels like Univesal, CNBC, etc.) but this year that channel in Canada did not have the games so we were stuck. The only answer was to find someone with a dish that had the East cost feed of NBC to see stuff live.

  • http://ljg222.wordpress.com ljg222

    One could not keep interest in the events; exactly as you standed. Commercials; bad commentary; and lack of concern for the viewers. At the beginning, I tried to watch for 1 hr; 15 minutes; and counted actual sports coverage of 37 minutes. No point in trying to be a supporter. Also; the late time period of major events; took every child who aspires to be an Olympian out of the Olympics.
    All of this adds up to one thing; NBC went to make money and here themselves talk to each other. The Olympics and Olympians were a side show to promote their own agenda.

  • Flynn

    I’m with you on this one. I rarely hear complaints about the coverage itself and I don’t have any personal complaints. There are no more commercials than any other sports broadcast, you can watch live broadcasts online, which came in handy for watching the hockey games, and beyond the commentary for the snowboard half pipe, it hasn’t been that bad.

    - CMU Alumni

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=224308 Jesse Casman

    Erick,

    Thanks for posting this. Sometimes you find articles that inform, sometimes they entertain, and sometimes they express exactly what you’re thinking. In this case, it’s all three. NBC coverage has been atrocious, and I’m really glad you dug into it a little more; the Twitter angle for those of us using social media professionally was interesting. Good info.

    Jesse

    Jesse Casman
    San Francisco, CA

  • /dev/acpi

    hmmm ……… ppt still watch TV ?

  • Greg

    Let’s not forgot that BBC is a public service company that is funded by fees/taxes. Making the most profit is not as important to them as delivering a decent coverage of the Olympics for their citizens. Germany had an equally great coverage because of that.

    NBC is mostly interested in making the most profit from the Olympics, and to cut their losses. The Olympics aren’t a big money maker for the TV networks, therefore you will never see great coverage in the U.S. unless they start showing it on PBS or something.

  • Emily

    I wouldn’t mind NBC coverage so much if they had alternate viewing channels where I could watch it live (I love 2.5 hours away from Vancouver.. I know that the skater didn’t just “show up at the event” at 10pm.) Also, if I have to hear about how difficult it was for some speed skater to step out on the ice after finding out his puppy has cancer, I’m going to get sick. I do find them moving, but it’s OVERKILL! I could have cared less about L. Vonn’s shin injury by the 3rd day. Apolo Ohno is a local hero around here, and again, could care less after 3 days of NONSTOP coverage on them. Again, I understand the time delay, but only if they offered watching the events live on cable or NBC’s sports channel. I also couldn’t handle the ADHD way of reporting it. 2 bobsledders, one figure skater, and woot! some curling.. all in 30 minutes! Argh!
    I do like Bob Costas. Have no complaints about him. He has to work with their system, so I don’t have any complaints there.

  • Mike

    You have no idea what your talking about. ‘streming video formats’ Silverlight is an excellent platform.

  • rj

    I think the worst thing about their coverage is the obvious non after the fact commentary masquerading as real-time narration. It’s clear that the hosts have seen what we see before we do. How else would they know that some skater’s next move is his most difficult. They also seem to be setting us up for upcoming good or bad turns of events. We don’t need that. Just lose the commentary entirely.

  • Sid

    The coverage of the olympics is rigged. Remember all those atheletes we saw in the opening ceremony? Where are they now? We never see them. The coverage is rigged in favor of the US. NBC will show athletes from other countries lose right before athletes from the US are shown to win.

  • bassitone

    NBC just shouldn’t have exclusive US broadcast rights, that’s the solution. I used to not mind it, but having to hunt for MSNBC for the US-Canada game last weekend made me realize just how bad it is… I don’t even mind the GE Health commercials that much, but that’s just the music nerd in me:)

    Just let us be able to watch one sport all the way through instead of breaking it up like they did

  • http://www.brianshall.com Brian S Hall

    I wrote about this on my site (www.brianshall.com) — only from the perspective that you really should stop whining given that you really want all this great content for free while NBC foots the half-billion dollar bill.

    Simple solution: use social media, online payments and get 50 million Americans to pitch in a few bucks each.

  • http://www.fanhistory.com/ Laura Hale

    The coverage was awful. It could have been better had NBC used CNBC, MSNBC and USA more effectively to cover events. (But even those often had tape delays, or showed the second half of a two part event. Where was the ski jumping?)

    It was made worse by the Pixar commercials in the middle of coverage. I get it. Pixar has a movie coming out about vikings and dragons… but after the third or forth time a commentator cut to the Pixar vision of generic Olympic event in viking times? I had enough of that. The second week had less of that, and instead involved promotion of another movie that the anchors didn’t plug as much.

    They decided before the games who the athletes that we would care about were. They had video packages made. We got to see them again and again when ever they could think of a relevant reason to show those pre-packaged clips instead of actual sports. When unknown sports heroes arose, no one seemed to know how to cover those.

    There were few options to watch events live on their website, except for the few that were being run live on their sister networks.

    There were large moments of advertising Whistler and British Columbia… which would have been awesome, had they not felt like everything being aired by others trying to capitalize on the Olympic feeling.

    Then we had moments of sexism, where commentators insisted on calling female athletes girls. We had moments of putting down and insulting Olympians because the commentators didn’t see their sport as a real sport. We had moments of homophobic behavior where commentators mocked Johnny Weir for what they considered his effeminate behavior. We had moments where blatant racism wasn’t called out with the Russians and their Aboriginal dance but still happily highlighting their lovely and interesting costumes.

    It was a failure for the US and pretty embarrassing. It almost explains why the USOC screwed Chicago out of hosting 2016 in order to try to get their own network to cover the events.

  • Chris

    What the fuck are you talking about?

  • Brandon

    Adobe troll? =P

    Thank god they don’t use Flash. That’s the single thing they got right!

  • Nathan

    Heh, I do find it a bit ironic that you complain of the tape-delay in the first paragraph, then go on to say “Thank goodness for DVRs”. Yet, I think it brings up a good point. NBC’s primary (publicly stated) reason for the tape delay is that otherwise, people would miss the event. That made sense ten years ago. Today, though, you have DVRs. More than that, you have the web. Why not show the events live on the web, then tape delay on TV?

    And that speaks to what I feel is NBC’s main problem not only with broadcasting the Olympics but broadcasting in general: a failure to innovate.

    That being said, when they’re actually showing the sport, the coverage is great. Some of their sports broadcasters are former gold medalists who know what they’re talking about and are able to point out stuff that viewers would otherwise miss.

    Unlike others, I don’t mind the commercials much. If you’re complaining about the commercials, something tells me you never watch sports…

  • Anonymous

    Uhm… The author was referring to a segment an NBC correspondent did. There was one on polar bears. One on lumberjacks. In Canada.

    So, a-hem, they were Canadians.

    But, of course, everyone knows that neither the US nor Canada have rather vast stretches of sparsely inhabited lands, and that lumber is definately not an important export.

    But I hated those segments.

  • ms. doubtfire

    Universal Sports channel just rocks, until the olympics began and than they are just showing re-runs of past WCs. i thought they would have 24hrs re-runs of THIS 2010 olympics. listen i knew a hand full of the athletes partaking and they were screaming on a daily basis they had to watch tape delay of their event and were mad as hell. a lot of the alpine skier were pissed and streaming on twitter on various sites running these athletes day to day comments. i am a nordic fan so that worked out but normal people are not into nordic cause americans suck except combiners. they got to get rid of ALL those commentators xcept for brooker, cooper, ryan and chad salmela.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=684230759 Jack Smith

    People who are complaining about NBC’s Olympic coverage on Twitter, are possibly the same people who would complain about the denomination of the bills if you gave them a million dollars.

    If you choose to get your info from online sources or other tv networks, great. You’re getting it how you want it, so why bitch about NBC’s coverage…maybe because you can?

    I am an Olympics junkie, I’ve been following the Games online and on NBC. Perhaps it’s my age, I can remember watching the Olympics for the first time in 1968 when I was 12, had to stay up till crazy hours to watch the coverage on my black & white TV. And now we can have up to the minute updates, anytime we want…and we’re complaining?

    To me, a lot of you sound like spoiled whiners. And of course I knew I would read the comments about the BBC or some other non-US network doing a better job. Predictable and typical.

  • Tim

    *cough* terrible convince sample is terrible *cough*

  • http://flowingdata.com/2010/02/28/olympic-musical-how-fractions-of-second-make-all-the-difference/ Olympic musical – how fractions of second make all the difference | FlowingData

    [...] the rest of NYT interactive Olympic coverage here. You know, just in case NBC coverage doesn't cut it for you. AKPC_IDS += "5815,";Subscribe to the FlowingData RSS feed to stay updated [...]

  • Donald Hyatt

    Why does NBC have to be a cheerleader for USA? Just cover the event. The cold war is over. Winning the Olympic does not make us superior to other countries.

  • JD

    In this entire Olympic season why does Ohino wear that red bandina. Does that sent a wrong message like a gang sign. Ohino should just get a haircut next time. Besides I believe the olympics in 2014 should not be broadcast at all. Everyone just complains about any network that airs the olympics. It would be better if the result of the olympics be delivered on your local sports station instead of watching it either live or taped delayed. America has the most whining people ever. No wonder why America sucks in business and it drives talent out of this Country.

  • JD

    Like I said eariler tape delay is no fun people just miss the moment. With DVR’s the olympics might as well be live.

  • JD

    Well this is the United States and we hated the tape delay portion of the 08 olympics in China. So I say this olympics is the best ever. So you suck.

  • http://www.nashvillehype.com Paul

    Agreed. It was the jumping from event to event that killed any passion I might’ve had at watching it. Bobsled to downhill to skating to another bobsled run, etc… too choppy of coverage. Just all over the map. Thankfully, the X-Games were two weeks prior and they know how to do coverage on those.

  • JD

    I’m talking about all those people that hate NBC should block the rest of Channels that have NBC in their stations.

  • BioEngineer

    Silverlight is a great lock-in for Windows. On any kind of Unix box, it sucks ass.

    Flash, as terrible as it is, is about as cross-platform as you can get until Google decides to open up On2′s technology. If (but more likely *when*) that happens, screw both video delivery platforms.

  • http://www.adtothebone.com Clayton Hove

    Good stuff, but you guys are a little bit late to the NBC statistical breakdown game – http://www.adtothebone.com/?p=256

    Cheers!

  • DJ

    @JD

    I rock, you sock.. :D

  • slogz

    I don’t understand why streaming events live is in any way connected to cable subscriptions. I don’t get cable. I will never get cable. If I watch any TV it’s on hulu or something. Yet for some reason I need cable to see the olympics streamed live?

    I shouldn’t need cable to stream the Olympics. It’s bullshit.

    Their broadcast contract should require live streaming without any extra conditions.

    Anyhow, I guess I didn’t watch any because of that so I can’t comment on the rest.

  • http://greenplus.net/?p=78728 NBC’s Olympic Studio Furnished with Reclaimed Wood | Green Resouces

    [...] coverage of the 2010 Olympic Winter Games has drawn comments from the sidelines, ranging from How We Hate NBC’s Olympics Coverage: A Statistical Breakdown to NBC delivers the goods in Winter Games coverage. We will stay out of the content debate, but we [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=9371562 Alex Valentine

    Because its redundant and poorly supported on most platforms.

  • http://www.nicernews.com/2010/02/nbcs-olympic-studio-furnished-with-reclaimed-wood/ NBC’s Olympic Studio Furnished with Reclaimed Wood | NicerNews

    [...] coverage of the 2010 Olympic Winter Games has drawn comments from the sidelines, ranging from How We Hate NBC’s Olympics Coverage: A Statistical Breakdown to NBC delivers the goods in Winter Games coverage. We will stay out of the content debate, but we [...]

  • sarcasticcupcakes

    It doesn’t work for me, either. I installed it twice on my old computer, and it never fucking worked once.

  • RJ

    Vonn ad nauseam. A bruised shin makes recurring headlines!

  • sarcasticcupcakes

    Folks, here in Aus (I’m American, so I totally agree with your NBC hate; the way they cover gymnastics makes me want to go on a shooting spree) it’s worse. If you don’t have cable, your coverage is on ONE channel. It runs from about 9 am to noon, sometimes 2 pm. Then a “recap” from 9:30 pm to about midnight.

    The commentators are so fucking useless it’s not even funny. Eddie McGuire is like Bob Costas minus the sports knowledge.

    The speed skating talking heads? An Aussie guy and a Dutch skater who has the most annoying voice EVER.

    Skiing? They made some really rude comments about the guy from Ghana – how “I could go faster than that backwards!!” Charming.

    Hockey & curling? They actually pipe in the CTV audio, which is awesome.

  • Joe

    Oh I’m so happy to be Canadian! around 6 tv channels in cable, ondemand viewing of previous events, and actually pretty good announcers.

    Leave it to NBC to screw up everything for Americans.

    Canada wins gold in both men/womens hockey, proud day. Priceless look on the American hockey teams faces during the silver medal ceremony LoL

  • Joe

    Hmm… if Flash is so bad, why is youtube and 99% of every other streaming site still using it? Livestream (one of the best for live video streaming) uses it as well…

    Sounds to me like you are a Mac troll. Just because your precious iphone/ipod/ipad doesn’t run flash doesn’t mean it’s inferior technology :P

    BTW – Flash 11 will change the game (once again), the platform is light years ahead of silverlight.

  • Dave

    Please… stop… talking…

  • Dave

    Did you even think before you posted?

    NBC does not provide the world with coverage. It provides the U.S. with coverage.

    So yes, NBC should revolve around what Americans want to watch because it broadcasts to Americans.

  • http://bear-bay.com/2090/olympics-how-we-hate-nbcs-olympics-coverage-a-statistical-breakdown/ Olympics | How We Hate NBC’s Olympics Coverage: A Statistical Breakdown

    [...] NBC, there are a lot Read more .cbadss{ background-color:#FFFFFF; font-family:; font-size:12px; color:#000000; width:400px; [...]

  • Dastroy

    I was very unhappy with the coverage this year. I live in AZ which is a one hour difference. Why was my feed 1 hour behind EST? The whole Olympics were ruined, I knew the outcome of just about every event! I had to log off of all my social media and not read any new sites, and not listen or watch television before an event if I wanted to watch and be surprised. Why? For professional television execs this coverage SUCKED!!!!

  • http://boston.com Rich

    Specious numbers from yet another software vendor translates into yet another garbage TC post. Guess you guys had to post something on a Sunday night, huh?

  • Rose-Marie

    Very disappointed in NBC’s coverage, being on the same time zone (for CA) and still only get a small portion live????? In Sweden for instance, they had live every day, their time 6pm until 4am, 10 hours of live coverage. How come US can never have live no matter what time zone it is? I don’t understand!

  • John

    In which regimes do the media pre-select the content they want to show and serve you packaged coverage? Capitalism is no better.

    There is absolutely no excuse for tape delays when the games are on a similar timezone. Way to ruin the spirit of the olympics which have managed to keep mass sponsor advertisements at the competing venues.

    NBC you should be ashamed!

  • desertflower

    Having watched the olympics for several years I must say this is the WORST

  • sarcasticcupcakes

    I’m going to use NBC’s gymnastics coverage as an example because it’s what I’m most familiar with.

    Americans don’t necessarily want to see American athletes only. I wanted to see the Chinese girls, the Russians, and the Brazilians too. But NBC’s Beijing coverage only showed the Americans and the Chinese, and (quite seriously) 1 Russian routine and 1 Romanian. That? is fucking ridiculous.

    There’s something to be said for patriotism and showing your own athletes, but not to the exclusion of all other competitors.

  • http://www.perfectoled.com led display

    same i think i agree .

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=6200015 Scott Werner

    I was happy they used silverlight cause I was able to install moonlight alpha 3 to watch it on linux.

  • Arun

    Never mind Katie, SL is growing and fast. In a couple of days SL 3 will be second largest plugin after Flash 10. It will soon overtake Java 1.6. However overall Java has a larger market share when you add 1.4 and 1.5. That too will be conquered soon

  • Frank Furter

    Couldn’t let this one go….

    Most TC posts are pointless. I’m a relatively new reader here, and I really believe this is some techy geek office somewhere with 14 new college grads that hate, well, everything. They -REALLY- like to jump on that Apple-hate train, especially when it comes to the sexual app ban.

    Most of their content is very much subjective, and they come across as a bunch of bratty little smart-asses. You know the type. The IT guy down the hall at your office that is a major PITA.

    And I’m (obviously) an Apple fanboy, but Silverlight is well implemented, efficient, and is used in a lot more professional arenas these days. No, not professional blog sites. Professional corporations, like health care software and ERM systems.

    You have to know what you’re going to get at TC. No journalism, but fodder for great comment wars. (And in TC’s case, ad revenue). Sometimes it pays to be an idiot.

  • http://cheapsubscriptions.com Craig @ CheapSubscriptions

    Can I jump in here and blame Jay Leno? Just getting a head start.

  • deleo

    As for the Marriage Ref and Parenthood – please stop promoting these shows! I probably won’t even give them a chance because of Jeff Zucker’s force-down-our-throats marketing campaign for what look to be very mediocre shows. Enough NBC.

  • marc b

    Have you thought of the possibility that “young talent” may have no interest in the Olympics because the Olympics is a bore?

  • sarcasticcupcakes

    But you missed Simple Plan, Nickelback, Avril Lavigne, and some other shitty band. So don’t complain too hard. :P

  • rick

    Does knowing the outcome ahead of time affect my viewing experience? Are you serious?

  • http://www.udtek.com udtekadapter

    so indeed ! you know

    NBC’S Olympics Coverage let people feel uncomfortable ,ridiculous questions

    http://www.udtek.com/laptop-battery-c-1.html

  • andy

    Seriously, what the heck are you talking about? The only way that I was able to watch anything worthwhile from a sporting point of view was to bypass NBC and watch coverage from outside the US.

  • http://www.ArticlePlayground.com/ Article Playground

    NBC is da bomb. Whatchu talkin bout ? (smile)

    LOL!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=506848625 Mike Cherry

    Friggin’ NBC cut off the last 30 minutes of the closing ceremony! Are you effin’ kidding me?????!!!!!! NBC officially is the worst coverage I’ve ever seen of any Olympics in my 33 years on this planet. I think only Fox could manage to do worse. Give them Olympics back to ABC or CBS!!!

  • sarcasticcupcakes

    You missed a bunch of shitty music. Don’t feel bad.

  • Vincent C

    NBC’s coverage of the 2010 Winter Olympics in Vancouver Canada was the WORST coverage ever. From their comments and over use of commercials to their terrible camera views and rudeness to interview athletes while they are in the midst of enjoying the closing ceremonies. Moreover, they were rude to the artists performing and the Canadian ceremonies. I feel as if I was missing half the events, the ceremonies and the LIVE vibe of the event.

  • Tom

    Priceless look on the Canadian hockey teams face 24 seconds before the end of the game.

  • Mike

    See, this is what doesn’t make sense to me. If the Olympics is such a bad deal for NBC, why do they promote it relentlessly between Olympics, and why did they bid for it?

    The coverage this year SUCKED. In our timezone, NOTHING (except hockey and men’s 50 km skiing, decided at the last minute) was live. And the studio hosts are AWFUL. A bunch of old farts that sit in a fake freaking log cabin studio with a fireplace and have the most boring interviews ever. It’s as if NBC is determined to make sure that the Olympics are NEVER shown as being fun and entertaining, but always about misery, depression and heartbreak (aka “drama”).

  • Mike

    Sure, maybe for weekdays you could justify the tape delay (not really, but I’ll give the greedy bastards at NBC that).

    But for WEEKENDS? They show the freaking PGA Senior tour live on TV on weekends. Would it be such an incredible sacrifice to show 6 weekend days of live coverage from the Olympics?

    NBC can go screw themselves.

  • Mike

    It’s very, very simple: show the events when they take place. Don’t fill the studios with old men past their prime, who talk with Serious voices about the gravity of the event we’re about to see, but instead put some people who can have fun with it and don’t have to tell us about the athlete’s mother’s battle against cancer.

    That’s a start, at least. NBC seem incapable of it.

  • Jim Phelps

    When are the Olympics going to be on and who is going to cover them for the USA market?
    .
    .
    .
    /sarcasm
    here it is the 28th and last day and to see all of the closing I have to watch 1 hour of some crap Sienfeld show and then watch the news and stay up to 3am to watch all. And I am only 150 miles South of the Event, in the US? Dick Ebersol of NBC is screwed, he lost a large amount on this event, or so I read. First Olympics where I did not care and watched under 1hour of the total offered.

    I guess I will watch the Nanny on Nick at Nite instead.

  • Mike

    Your post brings up some good points. One of them is the lack of athlete recognition.

    This is of course because in the US, NFL, NBA and MLB pay the networks so much that hardly any other sports are shown. In Europe, you see cross country skiing and alpine skiing World Cup events on TV weekly. People know the athletes, and they have an emotional investment in them.

    In the US, hardly anyone knows who these people are because they are never on TV, so why should they care during the Olympics?

  • Pay Attention

    I did not intend to bridge the gap between the networks on the political spectrum; although I was not surprised that I did not find myself uncomfortable with NBC based on politically biased coverage. They covered Team U.S.A. more, as a market plan (i.e. profitability) would require. And while the commercials were GE (and a few others who may be seen as politically motivated corporations) they were self promoting and neutral. Remember these corporations are also sponsors of my Olympic coverage.

    The Olympics are idealized as apolitical games. While in the past much has gone awry in that regard, it should be noted that NBC has not chosen to use the games to promote their overall left of center agenda.

    The games are over now. Well done Canada. Good job NBC…. not fantastic but good.

    P.S. No wardrobe malfunctions… ponder that. ;)

  • Pay Attention

    I’m getting a little on the old side now. I remember ABC’s Wide World of Sports. “The thrill of victory and the agony of defeat.”
    A serial program like that, diverse, exotic, exciting.. would do well today in today’s network market. And it could be done relatively inexpensively compared to the original program. Just interview the winners.
    Quick, incisive, stuff. The American people love a winner.
    Imagine the thrill of knowing just what Petter Northug was capable of and watching him do it instead of being shocked by it visually for the first time. The announcer told me so; but wow… I never would have thought to pull for him to the end.

    Thanks Mike,
    Knowing the athlete is the difference between passive and involved viewing.

  • PePa

    “”"But, of course, everyone knows that neither the US nor Canada have rather vast stretches of sparsely inhabited lands, and that lumber is definately not an important export.”"”
    Canada of course has HUGE stretches of uninhabited land. And lumber still is an important export for BC.

  • http://www.sriraj.org Sriraj

    I’ll correct it.
    Stupid Silverlight

  • ZM

    How can you not include a section of those who hate NBC because they cancelled ‘Kings’!?

  • ad

    I watched most Olympic events without ads on Russian internet channels. They show a complete event, not like Americans: when they just snow a portion of an event with their athletes and, in addition to that, with a lot of ads. It just stupid. After first 5 minutes watching NBC, I understood that its Olympic coverage is a joke. So, Russian and Ukrainian channels gave me access to a complete (with no ads) coverage of Olympic. Of course, you have to know Russian or Ukrainian language, sorry… :)

  • Gram

    I’m surprised Chris Collinsworth didn’t show up on the graph. That dude is below average as an NFL commentator and he played the game.

    Him covering the Olympics is like Bob Dole competing on Project Runway.

    I threw up in my pants yesterday when he started referring to himself as C.C.

  • http://www.ionlyliketheiroldstuff.com/2010/03/episode-38-olympic-dreams-vi/ Episode 38: Olympic Dreams VI | I Only Like Their Old Stuff

    [...] A Statistical Breakdown of how much people hated NBC’s Olympic Coverage. [...]

  • Nathan

    Chris Collinsworth should never be allowed on TV again. He’s terrible. Costas used to be good, but has gotten progressively more annoying.

    My other complaint is that they showed too many boring sports. I don’t need three hours in a row of bobsled.

  • http://www.d4bmarketing.com Dave Finkelstein

    Man, what whining, no the coverage was not great and tape delay is awful, but it’s still the Olympics and fun to watch. Stop complaining so much everybody, jeez.

  • Greg

    What I don’t understand is why they didn’t sell live streams of all events on their website.
    I don’t have cable, only antenna, so I didn’t get past their awful cable subscription verification. I would have happily paid $20 or $30 to get access to streams for all events.

  • Stevie

    I was puzzled by Universal running WC reruns. It just did not make any sense why that was going. I went to school with a short track skater, so at least that event was covered.

  • Calvin Glenn

    You know what, so many people are complaining about NBC’s coverage. It’s totally silly to spending so much energy with this. I loved the NBC converage because I am an “average” U.S. viewer — not caring what technology is used to deliver the viewing experience nor having too much interest in any other team that’s not from the USA. NBC’s not the network of the world — they understand their audience and they delivered their product to that audience. I had no problem viewing anything — on the TV, on the Web, or on my iPhone.

    Can we just talk about something else that isn’t based on results from a skewed selection set?

  • Anne.ver

    NCB coverage of the 2010 Olympics coverage was a disgrace, most specifically, coverage of the downhill skiing. While we had to watch at least 6 minutes of countless ice skating performances (4.30 minute programs and then scores), we only saw maybe 6 ski racers per event with maybe 2 minutes per racer. And, did ski racing, men and women, not win over 10 US medals? What’s the deal? Do the hosting sport sponsors (Chevy Trucks for ski racing) have to pay NBC to provide coverage of that particular sport. Why did we have to listen to so much nonsense commentary about the sports when the coverage was so minimal and pitiful at best. In addition, did we need 5 minute profiles of individuals, when there was no coverage of the event. There was no live coverage of some events; what a disgrace by NBC. Shame on you!!!

  • Josh

    Out of honest curiosity, how much do the Russian and Ukranian channels pay for coverage vs. the $800 million that NBC paid? Maybe that’s the difference for the commercials

  • Sean

    I was willing to pay money online (dont have a cable tv hookup) to watch the USA vs CANADA game last night, but when i tried to stream it through NBC’s website, it prompted me for my local cable provider. BUT SINCE i dont have local cable service, it wasn’t allowing me to login, even with my verified internet/cable service information. HUGE PAIN IN THE ASS.

    CTVolympics.ca though was streaming directly from their website without any hickups for all Canada residents, but wasn’t allowed for anyone in the states. CTV’s coverage destroyed NBC’s in quality, but was blocked here in the states, so lame.

    All this filtering of media and information due to regions is pretty much garbage, and everyone’s worried about their own wallets being hurt. This wouldn’t be the case if you provided a service the customer actually wanted to use, rather than forced to use.

  • Chad

    Hey, where is the nice DONUT CHART that you guys had put up yesterday ?

    Did NBC make you take it off the blog post ?

    C’mon now, did you sell out already tech crunch ???

  • http://jayk.ca jay k

    A gold medal to CTV Canada our Olympic coverage was second to none! Amazing HD footage on TV and
    Stellar websites. ! Great knowledgeable commentators who were really compelling. CTV really showed what it meant to be Canadian, well done Canada beating the US @ hockey and winning 14 gold medals! Go Canada go

  • Avi Weiss

    Perhaps I’m in the minority of the people who’s opinion formed the statistical distribution shown above, but I enjoyed most of the coverage.

    To be sure, Bob Costas and Mary Carrilo were not the most scintillating TV personalities, and much of the interviews seemed over-contrived, to the point that questions were repeated to the same interviewee during different interviews, and they responded in kind with the same answers.

    But the Olympics are much more than simply sporting events. Part cultural event, part summer camp, and part athletic prowess appreciation and competition, the Olympics is a chance for the world to gather in a single place, and enjoy the spirit of competition and cultural exchange.

    Most of us didn’t have a chance to get to Vancouver for the games, and even if we did, event venue pricing and availability, along with little of no access to the athletes, and/or the “behind the scenes” action in general meant that the only way to enjoy those aspects of the game would be to see it through the eyes of those who do have the access and the time to discuss it, namely those in the media.

    If I simply wanted to watch just the sporting elements of Olympic events, I could easily watch them on their respective world championship TV programs. But the truth is the Olympics games are, for better or worse, considered special, and each athlete usually has an interesting “personal story” about their road to the games.

    Even though I have been to Vancouver, and have seen some of the local fare that was covered ad nausea, I did not have the time or knowledge to experience alot of the “Canadiana” that Mary and others seemed task with delivering: dog sleds rides, polar bear expeditions, lumber-jacking, etc. Campy? without a doubt, but interesting nonetheless, and something I wouldn’t have seen or maybe even known about had that not been included in the Olympic broadcast.

    Could the coverage been better? sure. Could the personalities been more engaging? Without a doubt. Could we have done without the tape delay for the daytime events? Would have been nice, but not critical. But overall, I enjoyed the 17 days of coverage, and just a wee-bit sad “winter camp” has come to an end.

    -avi

  • esra

    geez Joe, jerkass comments like that make the rest of us look bad. Try to have a little class. The Americans played a damn fine game.

    I was super pleased with CTV’s coverage, especially the stuff available online. It was great to be able to watch online at home.

  • Kate

    My biggest annoyance was the redundant fact stating over and over and over again. We know the Russian skater’s mom died, we know about Vonn bruised shin, we know that Apollo’s middle name is Anton…the factoid list is apparently extremely short at NBC. We don’t have to be reminded of this every time the camera pans to them. OMG!

    And yes, we do need some younger and more relevant commentators…not to mention the “side” stories that had nothing to do with the olympics…like the TENNIS player hanging out with lumberjacks or the 9/11 story….

    at least my local news channel didn’t interrupt what little Olympic coverage we got because of a storm. We know there’s a storm. I can see it from my window…now let me watch the Olympics. Faceshot!

  • http://comm334sp10.wordpress.depauw.edu/2010/03/01/nbc-and-the-olympics/ NBC and the Olympics

    [...] of the Americanpublic have been upset with NBC because many of the most popular and most anticipated events have been tape [...]

  • CK

    I’ve been complaining about NBC’s Olympics coverage ever since they took over the contract staring with the 1988 Seoul Olympics. And while I am still complaining 22 years later, I do find I have to clarify my complaints and also give credit where credit is due. There is a difference between “coverage” and “programming”, and while NBC’s coverage still has not met the standards set by ABC’s Wide World of Sports crew back in the day, it has improved drastically, even from 8 years ago, when they actually had Al Roker doing coverage of I don’t even remember what. I found that, other than the fact that coverage of some events was truncated to fit into a programming block, the actual covergae – commentary, camera angles, switching, replays, etc. – was leaps and bounds beyond what it used to be.

    The programming, on the other hand…WTF? I understand that the United States has a large section of the population that likes things handed ot them in easily digestible portions, and I get the need, particularly for/from advertisers, to have a prime time audience for the Olympics. I have no objection to that; assemble a 4-hour digest that includes highlights of all the events, well-edited and packaged. But we have come a long way in the last 22 years. There is no need to cater to the entire population as though they were all like the 5 people left in the country who still do not have some kind of cable/satellite package in their homes. I don’t see why NBC can’t make a deal with cable/satellite providers to set aside a few channels for 2 weeks just like the NFL does with Sunday Ticket or the NHL does with their packages, etc. That way, people pay a nominal fee for full access to live programming of events shown in their entirety. This is the age of DVRs, and let’s face it, if we don’t have a DVR, most of us still have a VCR stashed away somewhere. And if we miss the big event, include as part of the package full access to On-Demand availability of a given event. And they can repeat events on those channels during the event off-hours. And, oh yeah, there’s the vaunted internet as well. Web coverage should never be lacking or inaccessible.
    NBC is covering every moment of every events, anyway. There is no reason or excuse why the public should not ever have total access to any Olympic event at any time. Not in this decade.

  • thelonious_dunk

    This is insanity! I can only assume that all of the bashers here have never heard of or at least don’t have DVR’s. I’m thankful the Olympics are over because the coverage was TOO comprehensive. I found myself watching Finland vs. Switzerland curling on CNBC and Sweden vs. Whoknowsistan women’s hockey on MSNBC at all hours of the day, not to mention the daytime broadcast on NBC which usually focused on Nordic Combined, Ski Jumping, Biathlon and some of the other long events. Every day, I had close to 10 hours loaded up on my DVR that I could blast through. Sure, the primetime stuff was tape delayed, but anyone with a DVR does their own tape delaying anyway! “Live” is dead! Plus, how the heck could they fit all of that in live? And yes, the PRIMETIME broadcast was biased toward U.S. athletes and what they editorially chose as the “big” stories, but there was just too much to cover not to skew it somehow. If you really are upset that you weren’t able to see France vs. Italy in quarterfinal heat #3 of Men’s Parallel Giant Slalom snowboarding, you must be related to the French dude in the event, in which case you should have just gone to Vancouver to support him.

    And to people complaining that events / ceremonies were getting cut off, have you ever watched a sporting event on a network before???? They ALWAYS go past the scheduled time! Extend your recording an hour. Sheesh, it’s like I’m taking crazy pills!

  • Dave Scafe

    By the pricking of my thumbs, Silver Moonlight this way comes.

    Then rang the bells both loud and deep. Gates is not dead nor doth he sleep.

    ~ ~ ~

    MR GATES: Your torments call us like dogs in the night. And we do feed, and feed well. To stuff ourselves on other people’s torments. And butter our plain bread with delicious pain… BSODs, DDOS, frightened users, abused standards, embraced, extended, extinguished” that is our diet. We suck that misery and find it sweet. We can smell the young lamenting the Red Ring of Death a thousand miles off. And hear a middle-aged fool like yourself groaning with vendor lock-in despairs from halfway round the world.

  • smz

    Horrible coverage, horrible, horrible announcers. Scott Hamilton grunting and squealing like a constipated cow with every jump during figure skating was a huge turn off…not to mention a complete lack of sports in other areas…I think NBC showed 20 minutes of bobsledding and 80 hours of sking….

  • ad

    Well, I watched it on-line (www.webtelek.com). When I said no ads, what I really meant is that I could easily fast forward to skip ads in a second. So, for me there were no ads what’s so ever. About the price they paid, that I do not know. Should I even care?.. hmm, probably not. I paid my per month service charge of $20 and enjoyed watching the Olympics (everything that they had on, was also available and still is in a recorded format too).

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=197805274 Patrick Toolan

    I’m not so convinced about this analysis with the twitter statistical breakdown; I can understand that this year’s coverage of the Vancouver Olympics by NBC was not up to what many other countries enjoy (thank god I live in France and England!), but the twitter stats don’t seem particularly reliable. I was more interested in ‘Vancouver Olympics’ because I don’t really care that much about NBC, so I looked for that on twittersentiment, and one of the comments, by a user called Yarbo, read: “I’m sad the Olympics are over in Vancouver. It was one of the best two weeks of my life, I’m so proud to be Canadian! #van2010″. Now the problem is, this comment was flagged as being negative! How on earth that could be the case I don’t know. Because it used the word ‘sad’? It rather casts doubt on the reliability of twittersentiment as an analysis tool.

  • gloria

    @ ad Thanks for the link to webtelek, never used it before, I subscribe to etvnet.ca and memocast.com, but this one seems pretty good too.

  • sean nathan bean

    yes silverlight sux… because my computer crashes with it… i shouldn’t have to be forced into downloading new MS crap… there should be choices…

    nbc olympiczzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz coverage

    why aren’t the complete events available online? i want to watch all the competitors for my favorite events… and not be forced to watch the sports NBzzzzz execududes think i wanna watch…

    why in the name of world sanity can’t google or yahoo buy the rights ???

  • sean nathan bean

    silverlight is all about locking folks into windoze…

    nevermind making people with computers more than 5 months old feel inadequate…

    if nbzzzzzz had any sense there would be streams on youtube, windoze mediaplayer, and realplayer

    its about the most eyeballs right?

  • sean nathan bean

    thanks… that site also needs me to install silverlight… my older computers can’t handle it… so thanx 4 nuthing…

  • sean nathan bean

    exactamundo … i don’t care about their backgrounds… don’t care if their father dumped them in a cabin… just freaking don’t care…

    show me the competition… and don’t cherry pick which competitors… if i wanna watch curling… i wanna see ALL of the curling teams…

    why is that so hard to get thru Nbzzzz execududes skulls?

  • sean nathan bean

    bingo… i want to see the entire competition… not just the US team… and not just the competitors “most likely to medal”

    i also hate that NBzzzzz turned “to medal” into an acceptable phrase

  • Melyssa Plunkett-Gomez

    Hi Patrick,
    Our tool VoxTrot Opinion does not rely on language to determine sentiment. The methods you refer to are very unreliable and inaccurate because of the exact reasons you give: words alone (especially in social media) do not give a good indication of opinion or sentiment. Those methods (NLP/Semantics) rely on positive words, negative words and the proximity with each other to determine sentiment.
    Our tool is powered by an algorithm which identifies and quantifies statistical patterns in the online conversation. When the analysis is set up, the algorithm “learns” the way different opinions are expressed in the conversation.
    If you want more info about our algorithm, our analysis, why we can say with confidence that our analysis is 97% accurate, check out our website and blog. http://www.crimsonhexagon.com
    Thanks,
    Melyssa Plunkett-Gomez
    VP Sales & Business Development
    @melyssa1968

  • JD

    At least NBC brought the Olympics live you cry baby. It is even live during the day through MSNBC and NBC

  • http://data-visualization.webglide.org/index.php/olympic-musical-%e2%80%93-how-fractions-of-second-make-all-the-difference/ Olympic musical – how fractions of second make all the difference « WebGlide – Data-Visualization

    [...] in perspective.See the rest of NYT interactive Olympic coverage here. You know, just in case NBC coverage doesn’t cut it for you. This entry was posted on Sunday, February 28th, 2010 at 11:42 [...]

  • http://carryingon.net/2010/03/04/nbc-got-away-with-it%e2%80%a6-you-can%e2%80%99t/ NBC Got Away with It… You Can’t « Carrying On

    [...] a result, 73% of the feedback on their coverage was overwhelmingly negative. I didn’t just poll the guys on Tony D’s bowling [...]

  • http://udtekbattery.wordpress.com udtekbattery

    so indeed !
    you know NBC’S Olympics Coverage let people feel uncomfortable ,ridiculous questions
    http://www.hpadapter.com

  • anon

    actually, it’s the Olympic Broadcasting Services who have all those camera positions who in turn create the neutral broadcast feed for everyone who bought the rights to show them. CTV may have an extra camera or two around the stadium but the main camera positions are OBS. It’s possible NBC decided to use their own camera footage instead of the footage by OBS that they also paid for.

  • Ilan Ben Menachem

    I’m talking about all those people that hate NBC should block the rest of Channels that have NBC in their stations.

  • http://www.myce.com/nbc-defends-winter-olympics-coverage-27977/ NBC defends Winter Olympics coverage | MyCE – My Consumer Electronics

    [...] “NBC Olympics coverage” and you’ll find plenty of negative results on the first page. It was widely publicized that NBC was likely to lose money on the Olympics, but the ill-will from [...]

  • http://blog.viningmedia.nl/2010/04/our-multimedia-olympics-obsession/ Our Multimedia Olympics Obsession | Viningmedia Nieuws

    [...] may have stomped our feet and threw Twitter tantrums in response to NBC’s frustrating coverage—including chronic tape delays and the [...]

  • http://www.penye.org triko

    this graph is a complete surprise to me

  • http://intensedebate.com/profiles/nusret1 yuregininsesi

    I was lucky to be in Canada during the Olympics and was able to see some of the CTV coverage. In just comparing what I saw there and what NBC has done, NBC was sorely lacking. And I won't even talk about the internet coverage. And don't think that CTV's coverage is great this year because the Olympics are in Canada. We had this same issue 2 years ago with the Summer Olympics. CBC had the coverage and they were superior to NBC even then. The Canadians know how to cover the Olympics. NBC needs to learn from them. The Canadian coverage always gets Gold, and NBC isn't even in metal contention.

  • http://laptop-komputer.com luis fabiano

    awesome that was great article,thanks for share with us.

  • http://getmakemoneyonline.com diana aviz

    after reading this article I would agree of that,all i say that amazing about this news,thanks

  • http://mortgagecalculatorlender.com vicente basquitos

    yes indeed I agree on that, quite favorable, after reading the news,thanks

  • http://www.ds.com sa
blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us