Some consolidation is underway in the world of challenger banking apps. BBVA today told users of Simple — the pioneering mobile and online banking app that it acquired for $117 million in 2014 — that it is planning to shut down the service, moving accounts to BBVA’s USA business in the process.
The move is part of an ongoing effort at BBVA — which had been an active investor and acquirer of startups — to streamline its business as it works on closing a merger with PNC. The latter bank announced in November last year that it would acquire the U.S. business of BBVA for $11.6 billion.
In a note Simple sent out earlier today to users — being shared on Twitter by a number of them — the bank said that it will be transitioning their accounts to be serviced by BBVA USA, which already housed the accounts.
“BBVA USA has made the strategic decision to close Simple,” the note reads. “There is no immediate impact to your accounts at Simple and nothing you need to do at this time. Since your deposits are already housed at BBVA USA, they will remain in FDIC-insured accounts there, up to the applicable limits. In the future, your Simple account will become exclusively serviced by BBVA USA, but until then you can continue to access your account and your money through the Simple app or online at Simple.com.”
Users will receive more details in the future about the transition to BBVA, the note continued.
The response from Simple customers has been predictably downbeat.
Users migrated to the service specifically to have a faster and more modern experience compared to what they were getting through previous, incumbent providers. It’s also a pain to change banking providers and many customers were longtime users.
Even though Simple ultimately ended up getting acquired by one of those incumbents — BBVA, headquartered in Spain, is one of the largest banks in the world — it was run largely independently of its owner, as part of BBVA’s attempt to bring on more modern services to attract a younger class of users.
We have contacted both BBVA and Simple for further comment, and BBVA’s statement confirming the shutdown is now at the bottom of this post.
So far, it looks like the emailed notification is the only announcement of the changes for customers directly; there are no alerts within the bank’s mobile app, nor any announcements on the Simple website.
It is unclear how many users Simple has currently. It had around 100,000 users when it was acquired back in 2014, and some might say that the startup was ahead of its time.
In the years between Simple launching and now, we’ve seen an explosion in the number and popularity of so-called neobanks or challenger banks around the world, including Nubank, Chime, Current, N26, Revolut, Monzo and many more, turning what seemed like a radical concept into one that is now fairly commonplace.
Tapping into using a set of APIs to bundle services, and sitting on top of other banks’ infrastructure, neobanks are more fleet of foot and provide more modern interfaces on more modern platforms (such as mobile apps).
Foregoing some of the traditional trappings of banking like visiting physical locations and transacting with tellers, the newer banks have replaced them with algorithms that, for example, help people manage their finances through the month by analyzing their spend and suggesting ways to save money or organize their finances in a better way.
The turn in events for Simple plays into some of the precariousness of using newer “challenger” banking services. There is always a risk with smaller services that they might not stick around as solidly as their incumbent counterparts. At least, that is how the thinking goes. Recent years and bigger banking crises have definitely overturned some of those conceptions.
For its part, Simple has not always been perfect. The company has at times turned off certain features — such as Bill Pay, or types of customer accounts — without warning, leaving users scrambling to replace them with alternatives.
The question will now be whether users decide to stick with BBVA, or turn to exploring another challenger, or migrate to one of the bigger , established names, which keep trying to modernise in the meantime. There are, after all, many options to consider these days.
We’ll update this post as we learn more.
Update: Here is BBVA’s statement:
BBVA USA continually evaluates strategic priorities and resources, including existing and potential partnerships with outside organizations. We have taken the opportunity of the pending merger with PNC to reassess our goals for BBVA USA, so that we’re focused on the things that make the most sense for the company’s future whether on a standalone basis or a potentially combined basis with PNC. As a result, today we’re accelerating some changes and stopping work on others, including the closing of Simple. These reviews are part of our normal processes, and have resulted in other ventures being closed in the past year or so based on performance and the economic environment, including Covault (2020) and Denizen (2019).
Simple customers already have a dual relationship with BBVA USA and Simple. We will be migrating these customers to the award-winning BBVA USA mobile app. Those same customers will become PNC customers upon the close of acquisition, which is subject to customary closing conditions. As part of BBVA USA, Simple customers will have access to a much broader suite of products and services, alongside the bank’s award-winning mobile app, which includes BBVA Financial Tools.