CA Files Lawsuit Against New Relic Seeking Injunction, Claims Patent Infringement

Alex Williams

Monday, November 5th, 2012
New Relic

CA Technologies has filed a lawsuit against New Relic, the application lifecycle management company.

CA is seeking “undisclosed damages” for lost profits. It is also seeking an injunction against New Relic prohibiting the infringement of CA patents and the misuse of the company’s intellectual property. In other words, CA wants a judge to shut down New Relic.

New Relic Founder and CEO Lew Cirne is at the heart of the lawsuit. In 2006, Cirne sold his Wily Technology to CA. As part of the agreement, Cirne gave up three patents that CA says Cirne is now using at New Relic. Wiley was a company that also served the ALM space.

Since the acquisition, New Relic and AppDynamics have emerged as two major players in the application performance management space. The founding members of both New Relic and AppDynamics came from Wily. New Relic has prospered by catering to the needs of developers who need to better understand how apps are performing in data-intensive environments. AppDynamics caters to the demands of large enterprises. It describes what it does as better managing application performance within distributed, virtualized, cloud and big data environments

And Wily? CA has not shown a lot of traction in the application performance management space. That’s not much of a surprise, considering that much of Wily’s talent moved on to New Relic and AppDynamics.

So it seems that CA has decided that its best offense is in the courts.

According to CA, it acquired three patents as part of the dispute. Cirne is a co-inventor in two of the three patents. Cirne worked for CA after the acquisition. He left in 2007 and formed New Relic in 2008.


Company: New Relic
Website: newrelic.com
Launch Date: February 2008
Funding: $115M

New Relic offers SaaS Application Performance Management and Real User Monitoring for Cloud and Data Center deployed web applications implemented in Ruby, Java, .NET or PHP.

→ Learn more
Company: Wily Technology
Website: wilytech.com
Launch Date: 1998

Wily Technology, Inc. provides enterprise application management solutions. It serves various sectors, such as financial services, telecom, insurance, service, government, technology, media, healthcare, retail, industrial, transportation, and logistics. The company’s products enable organizations to manage the health and availability of Web applications and infrastructure. Its products include Introscope, a performance management solution; Customer Experience Manager, which provides views and alerts to detect customer transaction problems; Portal Manager, an enterprise portal management solution; and Web Services Manager, an end-to-end performance...

→ Learn more