Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For
Jason Kincaid
Mar 26, 2010

In anticipation of a slew of new features that will be launching at f8, today Facebook announced that it was once again making changes to its privacy policy (you can see our post outlining these changes here). One of the biggest changes that Facebook is making involves applications and third-party websites. We’ve been hearing whispers from multiple sources about these changes, and the announcement all but confirms what Facebook is planning to do. In short, it sounds like Facebook is going to be automatically opting users into a reduced form of Facebook Connect on certain third party sites — a bold change that may well unnerve users, at least at first. Here’s how Facebook is describing the change in its blog post:

Today, when you use applications such as games on Facebook.com or choose to connect to Facebook on sites across the web, you are able to find and interact with your friends. These applications require a small set of basic information about you in order to provide a relevant experience. After feedback from many of you, we announced in August that we were moving toward a model that gives you clearer controls over what data is shared with applications and websites when you choose to use them.

In the proposed privacy policy, we’ve also explained the possibility of working with some partner websites that we pre-approve to offer a more personalized experience at the moment you visit the site. In such instances, we would only introduce this feature with a small, select group of partners and we would also offer new controls.

So what does that mean? We’ve heard that select Facebook partners will now be able to look for your existing Facebook cookie to identify you, even if you never opted into Facebook Connect on the site you’re visiting. Using that, the third party site will be able to display your friends and other key information. It’s possible that these sites will also be able to display any data you’ve shared with ‘everyone‘, which is of course now the default option on Facebook.

Facebook’s draft privacy policy states that you’ll be able to opt-out of these sites, and you’ll also be able to opt-out of these ‘pre-approved’ experiences entirely. But by default, you’re all in. How convenient.

Here’s the langauge from the draft privacy policy itself. Note that the ‘About Platform’ page does not yet include a list of approved partners:

Pre-Approved Third-Party Websites and Applications. In order to provide you with useful social experiences off of Facebook, we occasionally need to provide General Information about you to pre-approved third party websites and applications that use Platform at the time you visit them (if you are still logged in to Facebook). Similarly, when one of your friends visits a pre-approved website or application, it will receive General Information about you so you and your friend can be connected on that website as well (if you also have an account with that website). In these cases we require these websites and applications to go through an approval process, and to enter into separate agreements designed to protect your privacy. For example, these agreements include provisions relating to the access and deletion of your General Information, along with your ability to opt-out of the experience being offered. You can also remove any pre-approved website or application you have visited here [add link], or block all pre-approved websites and applications from getting your General Information when you visit them here [add link]. In addition, if you log out of Facebook before visiting a pre-approved application or website, it will not be able to access your information. You can see a complete list of pre-approved websites on our About Platform page.

Here’s how Facebook defines the term ‘General Information’:

The term General Information includes your and your friends’ names, profile pictures, gender, connections, and any content shared using the Everyone privacy setting. We may also make information about the location of your computer or access device and your age available to applications and websites in order to help them implement appropriate security measures and control the distribution of age-appropriate content.

Advertisement
  • Related Topics
Advertisement
  • http://librarianchat.com/forum/ librarianchat

    I don’t know whether to be happy or scared.

  • http://www.bluecable.ca Ediciuz

    Is Facebook trying to become the new Internet?

  • http://www.erikbigelow.com Erik Bigelow

    Little by little they chip away at your privacy so get annoyed but not enough to leave. Good strategy, and why I don’t use FB anymore. Distributed social networking is the only way to go to own your life on the web.

  • Ryan

    Why would this make you happy?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1598274710 Kev Kevarino

    That’s so awesome that FB will automatically opt all of us in to share our data with the mysterious and unidentified group of approved third party sites.
    *much sarcasm*

  • Adam

    It’s Beacon 2.0.

    When Google starts “pre-approving” users with Buzz, we can’t be surprised when Facebook does the same thing. Maybe CAN-SPAM should be updated to prevent all forms of automatic opt-in.

    They are certainly trying everything to get me to quit Facebook.

  • http://www.loudable.com Suhasini

    Well this is going to put Facebook in some kinda controversy for sure.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=204528 Jeremy Gordon

    been looking for a reason to kill my FB account, this may be it?

  • lisa

    “After feedback from many of you, we announced in August that we were moving toward a model that gives you clearer controls over what data is shared with applications and websites when you choose to use them.”

    What about the feedback this fall and earlier this year? The feedback from once some of these “new controls” reset privacy settings without warning?

    FB’s pretend response to feedback and its proclivity for making most features opt-out rather than opt-in is nothing but a Potemkin village in action. In other words its as phony as a two dollar bill, and any other metaphor you can think of.

    Fact is that much of the huge influx of FB users in the past 1.5 years are web novices and often don’t understand or know to follow all the twist and turns that FB “feature” changes bring about. Usually not until something they really didn’t want to be public is public, or some private information they didn’t want shared is sold to advertisers.

    And yet, of course, most of us will suck it up and keep using FB, including myself … it truly has become an addiction that we stick with no matter how bad for us.

  • gregorylent

    ugly, toxic company .. very old paradigm .. something for the unwashed to dally with

  • James

    How convenient that Facebook made these changes to their privacy policy today. It’s an obvious attempt to evade fallout by burying what could be construed as bad news (if you care about your privacy) ahead of the weekend.

  • http://nextweeq.com pedalpete

    Isn’t that a bit of an oxymoron Erik? Isn’t ‘distributing’ your social network exactly what FB is doing?

    What are you recommending here?

  • Ryan

    There is a fight for ownership of personal namespace on the internet between FB, Twitter, Google, etc.

  • http://www.qxdesigns.net Jeff

    I love that “General Information” is actually quite personal. How can a first and last name, and names of your friends, along with pictures that identify you be considered general information?

    When people realize that no matter how many times Facebook states that they “want to protect their user’s privacy” — this is the farthest thing from what they’re doing and what they plan to do in the future.

    They are simply using your personal information to make money, since you OPTED in to using their service. Wake. Up. People.

    That’s what happens when you’re not a public company, there aren’t nearly as many rules and regulations to abide by with regards to Consumer Privacy.

  • ugh

    FB is an evil company run by a bunch of fascist pigs. Fight the power people.

  • http://shri-perspective.blogspot.com Shrinand Javadekar

    I think FB is already doing it. Try out this simple experiment:

    1. Go to FB and sign in. This sets up your browser cookied.
    2. In the same browser window (and withouth logging out of FB) go to a site that uses FB connect.

    3. It shows a FB logo along with my name and down at the bottom of the page, it shows me:

    Logged in as Shrinand Javadekar Sign Out

    I went to http://www.cricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/453433.html

    If this is browser+OS specific, I use FireFox 3.5 and Ubuntu 9.10.

  • http://www.noizivy.org NZN

    And Me… you forgot me… I Own Me.
    Do You?
    Own Yourself.

  • Phil

    In other words, Facebook is going to privacy-rape us again.

    They’re gonna hide in the bushes, pull down our panties, and privacy-rape us.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1165531801 Jeff Singleton

    This is about as ridiculous as Facebook going after the author of Greasemonkey because it takes away from the possible revenue.

    Hello … Facebook, you can’t control what I view once its in my browser. Morons!

  • http://www.dotrights.org Hari O’Connell

    The proposed changes also dramatically alter the policy on how applications and websites can store and use user data. Previously they could only use data in connection with Facebook, that restriction has been eliminated. As has the requirement that they delete data when a user uninstalls an application. You can read our blog post about these changes here: http://www.aclunc.org/issues/technology/blog/is_facebook_unliking_privacy.shtml

  • http://www.sectionz.com eman8ions

    My facebook posts don’t default to “everyone” and I never choose “everyone” so… pay some attention to your own privacy instead of acting oblivious to the internet and this is pretty …. irrelevant.

    Change your settings now and stop bitching.

    You can be sure the Canadian government will once again be playing mom n dad to FB.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1165531801 Jeff Singleton

    And as such, I have officially deactivated my FB account.

    Hey Mark, you greedy SOB. I hope you drown in all the unethical cash you will probably still make by selling the private information of all the others who won’t/can’t leave.

  • http://www.turnto.com George Eberstadt

    Doesn’t this suggest that users have been slow to learn the habit of Facebook-Connecting? Or just haven’t wanted to?

    I’d like to see Facebook articulate the policy for choosing which partners are admitted to that “small, select group”. Access to this service could be a huge competitive advantage for some sites. Will it be simply a matter of price? Will Facebook friendlies get priority access?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1165531801 Jeff Singleton

    Do you really think those privacy settings benefit you? And not Facebook. I promise you that those settings are only there for the warm and fuzzy’s.

    Why don’t you do a few searches on any search engine to see how much info is really being shared, without your consent?

  • http://favit.com/marfi Martin

    Kudos to the TC team for rising attention on such important issues. I more and more believe that in the future the fight will not be for money, clicks or visits but for neutrality – it will be extremely hard for new sites to rise up and gather visitors and authority. Where will the free internet end up?…

  • http://www.erikbigelow.com Erik Bigelow

    Facebook is centralized because you’re always on facebook.com. Yes you can go to friend’s page but you’re still on facebook.com. They own all your info and content.

    A distributed social network would allow you to be on different urls and still “talk” back and forth. I’m building a solution called get6d.com. We’re almost ready for beta testing as soon as we can get it to send messages privately we’ll release it. check out the site or my page. It’s built on the framework but still not finished.

  • http://www.intrnr.com Greg Paradee

    This reminds me of the Facebook Beacon program from a little while back. Of course you can opt out of it but that was the last time Facebook tried to share data with outside companies and it turned into an uproar. Although I agree this way is a much better way to implement it I still don’t need every site that Facebook determines worthy enough to share my information with to see it. Other sites allowed to use another companies cookies for data? It could only go downhill from here.

  • http://www.wiredwisconsin.org/with-facebook-currently-king-of-the-hill-you-have-to-play-by-its-rules/ Wired Wisconsin » With Facebook Currently King of the Hill, You Have to Play by Its Rules
  • http://www.hrabaconsulting.com/blog @hhotelconsult

    It’s about data, it’s not about a social network. I prefer twitter where I have opted into having no privacy rather than allowing FB to mess with my expectations and then constantly bungle it up.

    1) It has no relevance or usefulness in driving revenue professionally. It does… my biz pages convert rezzies, and we do get a lot of people on our site from FB… but it isn’t meaningful yet.

    2) Personally I don’t see a use for it… twitter works, with buzz adding deeper conversation, picasa or flickr for photos, linked in for online rez. I just don’t find it meaningful…

    3) It’s a closed network right? FB will constantly marginalize the privacy of individual users in attempting to monetize this closed network with flawed architecture.

    They are teetering on the edge… FB users are *not* loyal… and they will go wherever the games and links go. Think about how much *real* interaction is happening there, vs. being buried in youtube links, tmz gossip, and me me me posting pics, or the gaming itself.

    The entire social media landscape will be totally different in 5 years…. @jerjameson said that recently at #smtravel. He’s not kidding… and it’s going to be a crazy time watching all this.

    MH

  • http://www.thenetworkgarden.com Mark Sigal

    Well, you know the axiom, “First time, shame on you, next time shame on me.”

    Facebook (and Zuckerberg, in particular) have already been pretty explicit about their view of privacy as it pertains to default settings. They believe that if you are posting to a social site then your intent is to be public UNLESS you explicitly set your privacy controls otherwise.

    This is a disingenuous position, when you consider how many of their 350M users are not part of the techie generation, but then again, they have also shown (Beacon, ScamVille, the Privacy Putsch) that their culture is to act first, and if necessary, apologize later, something that I blogged about in:

    Is Facebook a Brand that You Can Trust?
    http://oreil.ly/8xySuW

    Check it out, if interested.

    Mark

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=619916674 Ignacio Sagone

    mmmm not so cool at all….

  • http://www.viewfromthe101.com Mat

    Oh no, as an avid internet enthusiast, I am angered at a possible encroachment on my perceived privacy rights!

    I will immediately discontinue use all of the free products that use the information, that I chose to give them, to serve me ads and make a profit!

  • Brian D

    … and somebody is already working on/doing it.

    I’m sure it was posted on TC within the last week or so.

  • Ben

    “Facebook helps you to connect to us so we can share your information with anyone who will pay us for it.”

  • Brian D

    This happened to me when clicking out of TC’s fan page a few weeks ago.

  • Lally Singh

    (1) I love that there’s a facebook connect option to comment here.
    (2) Really, I think many people would be up for some parts of fb connect, if it was opt-in. FB doesn’t really have any respect for its members.

  • Fred

    The most credible player for this scenario would have been Mozilla using Firefox as the platform.

    I have been waiting for years, but they seem to sleep…

  • Fred

    Yep, just look at how Suckerberg behaved from the very beginning of “his” company…

  • Sarah

    Facebook:

    We’ve largely trusted you. Don’t make us leave. We don’t want to, but if we have to, we will.

    Never, ever underestimate the power of disenfranchised users. We left Friendster because the network sucked. We left MySpace because of the spam and porn. We’ll leave you too, make no mistake about it.

    We don’t even have to be actively pissed. Just passively sick of your crap will do it.

  • aka_smith

    Hmmm I’m conflicted.

    On one hand, I’m more thrilled than ever that I closed my Facebook account 2 years ago as this is grossly over reaching.

    On the other hand, as a developer guy I’m thrilled about how I’ll be able to juice the hell out of this.

  • igniman

    Another beacon failure ahead. Oh facebook, why are you doing this to yourself?

    This could lead to all sorts of trouble: Imagine a couple visiting a dating site without each knowing about the other. Without the opt-in procedure, they could both be identified as friends for up to 24 hours. I know facebook is supposed to approve these sites, but surely users will start seeing strange activity being generated on their behalf which they did not opt for

    Facebook should just work on making the connect procedure faster, not annoying users.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=835705461 Mike Dubnik

    And yet Buzz gets slammed for privacy issues. What a joke.

  • igniman

    P.S. As a facebook developer, i and many others have tried hard to create platform apps that are respectful to the user. This is extremely off-putting and sad for us. I hope this project FAILS, just like their “Great Apps” program, their “Verified apps” program and beacon.

  • champ

    It reminds me the days when people were shouting on myspace/google about privacy controls..what you have to say about hi coops of fb?

  • lawl

    You’re creepy dude.

  • http://cfp.acm.org/wordpress/?p=150 Tech News Roundup, 3-26-2010 « Computers, Freedom, and Privacy

    [...] hoping that Facebook users aren’t automatically opted in to sharing information with partner sites when the social networking site rolls out a new privacy [...]

  • http://social-article-marketing.articleplayground.com/ Article Playground

    oh boy…

  • Carlos C

    Go back to basis: FB is just a database of personal information. You use it because… put your addiction here (most probably: “everybody else uses it”). In any case, now your life is in a database.

    Wouldn’t you normally ask: “Why is FB/Tweeter/MS… so generous to lend me their database?”

    This is FB’s answer “to sell your data”.

    Now: “What do you do?”

  • Smarter

    LOL Twitter is not part of that fight. Twitter a something old people without real social networks use to pretend they are participating in “social networking”.

  • GS

    Why indeed.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1044011822 Linda Lawrey

    Your HERE link links to this post and not the one I think you meant it to.

  • http://www.news1.etigari.com/facebook-may-share-user-data-with-external-sites-automatically/ Facebook May Share User Data With External Sites Automatically | HERTZ RENTAL

    [...] The proposed change was first written about by Jason Kincaid on TechCrunch, who called it Facebook's Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For. [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1291399438 Elliott Klug

    This is more important: Your friends can share your information without you ever being involved:

    What your friends can share about you through applications and websites
    When your friend visits a Facebook-enhanced application or website, they may want to share certain information to make the experience more social. For example, a greeting card application may use your birthday information to prompt your friend to send a card

    If your friend uses an application that you do not use, you can control what types of information the application can access. Please note that applications will always be able to access your publicly available information (Name, Profile Picture, Gender, Current City, Networks, Friend List, and Pages) and information that is visible to Everyone.

  • Jason Kincaid

    Thanks, fixed it.

  • http://plzkthxbai.com Jason Wagner

    I deactivated back in December… best decision I’ve ever made.

    Twitter FTW!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=641185440 Vaughn Robinson

    actually you cant delete your account. Go ahead try. Its hilarious and infuriating. OH look! is that me writing this post on tc! When did I CHOOSE to click a button and login with my fb? When did I type in MY email address and MY password? O thats right I didn’t. There I am whether I like it or not. I disliked fb from the get go. Suckerberg.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=641185440 Vaughn Robinson

    Until there are enough pissed off nerds spreading the word to their parents and grandparents.

  • Alex

    This is the TRUE face of the zuckerbook. :)

  • Alex

    True

  • http://popurls.com/pop === popurls.com === popular today

    === popurls.com === popular today…

    yeah! this story has entered the popular today section on popurls.com…

  • CWc

    hmmm… :idea: Facebook < 2 more years

  • pf

    Well said Sarah.

  • http://www.thehappyaccident.net/have-i-ever-mentioned/ Facebook changes its privacy policy. Again.

    [...] I mention this because Facebook has made changes to its privacy policy again today. This article from Tech Crunch paints a not so pretty picture: Facebook’s Plan to Automatically Share Your Data with Sites You Never Signed Up For. [...]

  • cr8tive

    Pretty sure you can.. at least I did.

    It is not easy and user friendly, it was a pain in the a**, which made me dislike facebook even more. What the trick was when I deleted my account, there was waiting a period of about two weeks or so and not logging in.

  • http://www.howtoloseweightfastest.com/ Gunn

    Well, it’s a good thing that my 40 year old white, male, livin in Georgia ass is signed up as a 67 year old black man who lives in Los Angeles. :-)

  • http://psychonauticalmindbloom.wordpress.com psychonauticalmindbloom

    There has been something inside telling me not to create a facebook account despite all the inticement from friends and elsewhere. I now have a good reason not to. Its not as if I didn’t already know this. You kinda have to figure every major online corporations is doing this sort of thing. The sad thing is that companies like facebook don’t even have to think about negative consequences of actions like this, because 99.9% of users don’t know or care about their information being shared. These companies know they can get away with pretty much anything as long as they doctor up the language right & make it sound like its good for you.

  • http://businesscover.ro/facebook-va-furniza-automat-informatii-despre-utilizatori-altor-site-uri/ Business Cover » Facebook va furniza automat informaţii despre utilizatori altor site-uri

    [...] Înaintea f8, convenţia anuală a dezvoltatorilor şi partenerilor Facebook, care va avea loc în aprilie, oficialii reţelei sociale au anunţat, pe blogul oficial, noi schimbări în politica de confidenţialitate a datelor personale. Printre schimbările importante pe care Facebook le are în vedere, se numără felul în care vor interacţiona şi vor folosi datele utilizatorilor aplicaţiile şi site-urile partenere, care folosesc aplicaţia Facebook Connect, notează TechCrunch. [...]

  • http://ibaku.biz ibaku

    Go to IBAKU.BIZ

    Better than facebook :)

  • http://board.protecus.de/t37690-2.htm Anonymous

    [...] [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1146776829 Shailesh Mishra

    Hey Sri,

    Your test case seems to me more like cookie based single sign on which is also done on G & Y! No info is passed on this. Its just a auth mechanism.

  • http://netzwertig.com/2010/03/27/wiederholungstaeter-facebooks-zunehmendes-vertrauensproblem/ Wiederholungstäter: Facebooks zunehmendes Vertrauensproblem » netzwertig.com

    [...] TechCrunch: Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • Mister T.

    “Privacy is dead” according to Mark Zuckerberg distorted and perverse view(never mind the constitutions of most western countries). He has no respect for personal liberty and privacy. It is in essence turning Facebook into a fascistic cooperate intelligence service where users aren’t able to opt out. Its frankly disturbing.

  • http://neosting.net/ NeoSting

    Do you read, and more, do you understand and think about what you write ? Maybe, it would help you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=572040305 James Carmichael

    I tried sharing this link on Facebook, and the article details were not automatically captured like normal.

    I tried a few other articles from TC and they were captured successfully.

    So it seems they’re also trying to prevent the above story spreading.

  • Brian D

    This will result in another version of The Uncanny Valley.

    I already know I will aviod sites that act like they know me.

  • Briggsly

    So does this mean if my web app is approved through this new FB privacy hack I can scrape this “general information” into my DB?

    I will have 400 million users in minutes!!! Hello large VC round!

    Get me Fred Wilson on the phone!

    - Snark Suckerberg

  • Charlie

    Facebook wants to build steady cash-flow, and this is apparently going to be huge (if it succeeds)

  • J. Peralta

    Agreed. I have taken the steps to privatize everything. People have to keep in mind “what you say may be used against you” a little more. If you don’t want anyone to see or hear you, don’t contribute to the site. It is everyone’s choice to do so, Facebook is only trying to get theirs ( yours, same thing ).

  • GOODinPDX

    Facebook: The End of Privacy: http://bagtheweb.com/b/lxYGFU

    Message to add sites that document the erosion of privacy on Facebook. #privacy

  • Justin Dorfman

    Creepy but so right

  • Bill

    Disable third party cookies in your browser’s settings.

  • h4xor66

    yes .. facebook wants to be the ENTIRE internet … they want you to use facebook as the internet to get any information that you are looking for .. expect to see the facebook search engine facetube movie site faceapedia …. facebook is evil , and it cant die fast enough for me

  • Corey Cossentino

    “In other words its as phony as a two dollar bill”

    So it’s real?

  • http://magarshak.com Gregory Magarshak

    Yeah this is just an example of using Facebook Connect and XHTML. If the developer abides by facebook’s TOS, they shouldn’t store your information. BUT GUESS WHAT!!

    Any developer can grab their visitors info simply by using XHTML and then screen scraping what’s on the page!

    What’s to prevent them from sending the info their own servers?

    Face it … Facebook is giving out your info to EVERYONE and “trusting” them to abide by their TOS. HA HA HA privacy RIP

  • http://newstrendstoday.com/headlines-facebook%e2%80%99s-plan-to-automatically-share-your-data-with-sites-you-never-signed-up-for/0787 Headlines: Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For | News Trends Today

    [...] Read more on TechCrunch [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1211590808 Michael Joseph Hraba

    Privacy is over was said by McNealy from Sun Microsystems in 1999. Zuckerberg is just playing it out on a eroding chessboard.

  • http://souvikmitra.com/2010/03/27/web/facebook-may-share-user-data-with-external-sites-automatically/ Facebook May Share User Data With External Sites Automatically | Souvik's Opus

    [...] of opt-in.The proposed change was first written about by Jason Kincaid on TechCrunch, who called it Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For.Here’s the language Facebook used to describe the draft policy:Pre-Approved Third-Party Websites [...]

  • Don

    Wow, this opens up all kinds of opportunities!

    Here’s a *great* business idea:

    1) occasionally post some porn on your site

    2) when a user clicks on it, store their Facebook info (and if you can store their friends too, that’s even better)

    3) tell the user that they have 3 days to sign up for your (paid) “Privacy Control” account, or you’ll “share” the porn page they clicked with their family and friends

    Pure gold! Thanks Facebook!

  • Glenna

    Don’t you mean a 3 dollar bill? Two dollar bills are real. Just thought I’d share (unless your just being sarcastic).

  • Jeffro

    YOU ARE BEING LIED TO BY THE HEADLINE! NO WHERE IN THE FB RELEASES THE AUTHOR USES FOR THIS ARTICLE DOES FB SAY IT PLANS TO AUTOMATICALLY SHARE USER DATA WITH 3RD PARTY WEB SITES. NO WHERE. WHAT IT DOES SAY IS THAT A USER CAN CHOOSE TO LINK THEIR OTHER FAVORITE SITES TO THEIR PROFILE IF THEY CHOOSE TO. THE USER MUST ACTIVELY SEEK TO USE THIS TOOL AND GO THROUGH PRIVACY SETTINGS FROM THEIR DEFAULT SETTINGS EACH TIME THE USER ADDS ANOTHER WEBSITE SET UP TO DO SO. I thought these kinds of forums were supposed have an eye for detail and accuracy.. guess not. DUHHHHHH.

  • http://www.intermedia4web.com Carol Cox

    Facebook is not “evil” – it’s a business and it needs to make money. Because it provides its services to all of us for “free”, it has to make money somewhere (advertisers, partners, virtual goods). I put “free” in quotes because we all do pay something, even if it’s not currency. We pay by giving Facebook our information – our demographic and psychographic data, interests, likes, friends lists, etc. That Facebook is making these changes should not surprise anyone. As I tell my students (I teach a class called Internet Business Models), assume that anything you post on Facebook could one day be public, should it suit FB and their revenue needs.

  • Matt

    Ditch Facebook, save yourselves!!!!

  • Michael

    Well, the Privacy Commissioner of Canada will be going after Facebook again!

  • http://intoolate.wordpress.com/ Marah Marie

    You can. You have to Google for the deletion link, it’s not the easiest sucker to find…then you get an email saying your account has been de-activated and will be deleted in two weeks, but then it says if you sign back in before that, your account will be reinstated…I got around that by deleting my FaceBook logins from my LastPass add-on, since I don’t know my passwords off-hand, anyway.

    But now that I’ve deleted my FB passwords, I can’t check to see if my FB account was deleted unless I go the “lost password/send email” route, which I won’t do since that in itself might re-instate my account, for all I know…

  • http://intoolate.wordpress.com/ Marah Marie

    You’d be surprised how common the “phony as a $2 bill” axiom is. Many people have actually never seen a $2 bill. Which reminds me, April Fool’s Day is just around the corner.

  • bren

    I think what FB should have done is to just upgrade how they sync to different social-networks via feeds.

    Instead of this, automatically sharing users data to networks…

  • http://theharmonyguy.com/2010/03/28/how-facebook-is-adding-an-identity-layer-to-the-internet/ How Facebook is Adding an Identity Layer to the Internet | Social Hacking

    [...] what may become the next major privacy controversy for Facebook, the company has announced plans to automatically share certain information when a Facebook user visits certain “pre-approved” sites. In [...]

  • http://stormrecruitment.wordpress.com/2010/03/28/facebooks-new-privacy-policy/ Facebook’s New Privacy Policy « Storm Recruitment Services Limited

    [...] 28, 2010 by stormrecruitment Social networking site is about to release another privacy policy.  Time to lock down your profile to ensure that you aren’t sharing your friends with every [...]

  • Duck

    The sooner this cloud/hive/open community jive gets boooed off the stage, the better off we’ll all be for it.

  • http://inmycup.wordpress.com milestogo7

    WOW! I had no idea. I’ve been becoming more and more disinchanted with FB Now I may just delete my account all together. Thanks for sharing.

  • http://www.calitel.eu/?p=7466 Facebook demande l’autorisation de partager encore plus largement vos informations • Calitel.eu

    [...] Mark Zuckerberg veuille étendre ce service «à des partenaires pré-approuvés» par ses soins, enrôlant d’office les utilisateurs. TechCrunch s’inquiète déjà d’un partage de données avec des sites pour lesquels [...]

  • icemanx

    well they can share what they like

    but the best thing I have done is signup with every site I join a seperate email address

    so if it sends spam then I redirect it all back to the webmaster

    I dont care what they say – they shouldnt spam…

  • http://anyhat.net/blog/2010/03/28/facebooks-plan-to-automatically-share-your-data/ Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data – In Through The Out Door

    [...] Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For H@xor, Security none [...]

  • http://blog.juliendassonval.com/marketing/facebook-va-de-nouveau-jouer-avec-vos-donnees-privees Facebook va de nouveau jouer avec vos données privées

    [...] trouverez un article complet sur techcrunch . Lisez l’article et les [...]

  • http://urbanlistening.wordpress.com/2010/03/28/facebook-to-launch-meebo-bar-clone-on-its-quest-to-take-over-the-web/ Facebook To Launch Meebo Bar Clone On Its Quest To Take Over The Web « urban-listening

    [...] conference, including its plan to offer a Like button for the entire Internet and a creepy auto-Connect feature that will share your data with sites you never signed up for. Now we’ve heard from [...]

  • http://themezz.com/blog/2010/03/facebook-moves-deeper-into-the-dark-side/ theMezz.com » Facebook Moves Deeper into the Dark Side

    [...] Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • http://www.joepritchard.me.uk/2010/03/facebook-would-like-you-to-share-even-more/ Facebook would like you to share even more…. | Joe's Jottings

    [...] way through one privacy crisis, then they end up with another problem of their own construction -this time involving a new plan to allow ‘trusted third party partners’ access to informa….  At the moment, when you go off to a site – like a game – that connects to Facebook [...]

  • http://www.querbeet-deluxe.com/2010/03/ups-facebook-connect-ist-uns-ausgebrochen/ “Ups, Facebook Connect ist uns ausgebrochen”

    [...] Änderungen seiner “Privacy Policy” ein neues “Feature” vorbereitet. Wie TechCrunch aus allen Ecken gehört hat, werden Drittseiten auf bei Facebook hinterlegte Informationen zugreifen können. Als [...]

  • http://blog.kurt.id.au/2010/03/chrome-cookies/ Chrome Cookies « blog.kurt.id.au

    [...] to investigate the cookies on my computer(s) for a while now, and in light of the upcoming / latest facebook privacy policy amendment I decided to actually get around to doing [...]

  • renecito

    FB cookie killer Extension for Chrome and other browsers

  • http://211.232.128.122:8888/?p=50 Facebook 유저들 “Everyone” 설정에 꼭 주의! 유저 동의 없이 서드파티 제휴사에 모든정보를 제공 « 쌍둥아빠의 쏘셜세상

    [...] 유저들에게 큰 반발을 살만한 기능을 포함한 새로운 프라이버시 방침을 발표했다.Facebook은 일부의 서드 파티 제휴 상대에게, 유저의 사전의 승낙없이 유저의 [...]

  • http://rainerwanner.com/2010/03/facebook-its-time-to-say-goodbye-for-me/ Facebook, it’s time to say goodbye for me « Rainer Wanner

    [...] Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • http://www.edk-12.com/ resources for teachers

    To be honest facebook starts to work on my nerves, do they really have to be everywhere??? Scary…

  • http://michaelzimmer.org/2010/03/29/yet-again-facebook-misunderstands-privacy/ Michael Zimmer.org » Blog Archive » Yet Again, Facebook Misunderstands Privacy

    [...] been numerous, valuable commentaries on what these changes mean for user privacy. See, for example, Tech Crunch (and again here), ACLU of Northern California, ReadWriteWeb, All Facebook, and Inside [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=777415704 Jörn Steinz

    I would generally appreciate to to be notified, whenever my data is shared

    http://www.mydecision.eu/1000-green-ideas/index.html

  • http://fstutzman.com/2010/03/29/facebook-again-to-test-privacy-boundaries/ Facebook Again to Test Privacy Boundaries « Fred Stutzman

    [...] regarding Facebook’s proposed changes to the privacy policy (so has Michael Zimmer, TechCrunch, RWW and VentureBeat).   The most controversial is a proposal for Facebook to automatically share [...]

  • http://ovigia.wordpress.com/2010/03/29/tracebook-trickbook-thiefbook-ou-facebook-nascimento-de-uma-fraude-com-ligacoes-pouco-recomendaveis-iv-e-ultima-parte/ Tracebook, Trickbook, Thiefbook ou Facebook? Nascimento de uma fraude com ligações pouco recomendáveis. (IV e última parte) « O Vigia

    [...] noticia o TechCrunch fazendo referência ao blog do Facebook, os senhores do Facebook preparam-se para partilhar com todos os seus parceiros [...]

  • http://www.facebookbiz.de/artikel/automatische-connect-anbindung-fur-externe-webseiten/ doing business on facebook » Automatische Connect-Anbindung für externe Webseiten

    [...] TechCrunch berichtete darüber, dass Facebook plant die Connect-Schnittstelle weiter auszubauen. Ein großer Schritt für eine weite Verbreitung könnte die automatische Verbindung zu Facebook Connect werden. Facebook plant, dass auf ausgewählten Webseiten eine automatische Verknüpfung zu Facebook erfolgt, ohne dass der Nutzer sich via FB Connect einloggen muss. [...]

  • http://sara-no-h.com/2010/03/29/opt-out-facebook/ Opt-out Facebook « Saranoh10's Blog

    [...] network that millions have joined, posted personal information on and use religiously every day. Facebook plans to automatically share your data with other sites. Now, Facebook has turned its privacy policy into an opt-out system. This means Facebook can use [...]

  • http://jetl.wordpress.com/2010/03/28/monday-morning-jetlawg-38/ Monday Morning JetLawg « JETLawBlog: The Official Blog of the Vanderbilt Journal of Entertainment and Technology Law

    [...] Facebook set to change privacy policy yet again with opt-out third-party sharing feature. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Monday Morning JetlawgWill Sandra keep Sunny?Sandra Bullock & Jesse James PollGET THIS: Celeb Kids in Striped Tights! Hello Sunny James!   [...]

  • http://tomsblog.it/valerioporcu/2010/03/29/facebook-non-google-ha-un-piano-per-conquistare-il-mondo/ Facebook, non Google, ha un piano per conquistare il mondo

    [...] secondo Jason Kinkaid, è infatti pronta ad autorizzare anche altri siti a leggere il proprio cookie, mettendo di nuovo [...]

  • anon

    Did anybody notice the privacy policy says “You can also remove any pre-approved website or application you have visited here [add link], or block all pre-approved websites and applications from getting your General Information when you visit them here [add link]. ” Actually, there is no link to change the settings.

    Anybody knows how to change the settings?

  • http://thekaeanchronicles.com/2010/03/29/wtf-facebook/ Wtf Facebook! « The KaeAn Chronicles

    [...] in 1 After reading TechCrunch’s article about Facebook’s plan to  automatically share your data with sites you never signed up for.  I thought about switching all my information for the infamous “Everyone” [...]

  • http://canarytrap.net/2010/03/publically-shared-still-means-privately-owned-another-round-in-the-facebook-privacy-rigmarole/ Publically shared still means privately owned: Another round in the Facebook privacy rigmarole | canarytrap.net

    [...] they provide. There are a whole series of proposed changes, which are outlined wonderfully by TechCrunch and the ACLU, some of which sound positive and useful. However, it’s the really exploitative [...]

  • http://www.lickmychip.com/?p=1122 The State of the Internet Operating System | Lick My Chip !

    [...] application, and your phone address book shows the photos of your Facebook friends. Facebook is expanding the range of data revealed by Facebook Connect; they clearly understand the potential of Facebook as a platform for more than hosted [...]

  • http://pasted.pl/2010/03/30/facebook-kombinuje/ Facebook kombinuje « Pasted

    [...] zła wiadomość (o której doniósł Techcrunch, a za nim także Antyweb) dotyczy prywatności. Facebook co jakiś czas przeprowadza na nią [...]

  • http://datababe007.blogspot.com/ Peg

    “1. Go to FB and sign in. This sets up your browser cookied.
    2. In the same browser window (and withouth logging out of FB) go to a site that uses FB connect.”

    No, go to FB and sign in. Now go to a DIFFERENT COMPUTER and go to a site that uses FB connect.

    I’ve used this trick more than once to demonstrate to stubborn users that NO, just closing the browser window on certain web apps does not sign you out. Depending on the app in question, not even if you shut down the first machine. Gollygeewiz. And d’oh.

    I haven’t yet used it to demonstrate that just signing IN to a certain web app can also sign you in to a bunch of others all over the intarwebs.

    I wonder what the “Wow, cool” to “WHOA, CREEPY” ratio will be to THAT.

  • http://bnwhite.com/2010/03/30/another-change-to-facebook/ Another Change to Facebook « Brittany's Blog

    [...] March 30, 2010 Facebook’s introducing a new plan to automatically share your data with third-party companies…. [...]

  • lisa

    Ha! Yes, well, my monetary ignorance is well spotted! Go with the sentiment if not the fact then ;) Thanks.

  • http://christanotterman.com/2010/03/30/facebook/ Facebook « Christan's Blog

    [...] Christan's Blog i go through life like a ninja « iPad and Google Chrome OS Facebook March 30, 2010 Facebook’s Plan to Share Your Information [...]

  • http://jimeltringham.wordpress.com/2010/03/30/playing-what-if-a-political-privacy-scandal/ Playing “What If”: A political privacy scandal « JimEltringham.com

    [...] too far-fetched?  Facebook gets knocked for privacy violations every few months – most recently for an informati….  Google  Buzz was famously lazy about privacy considerations in its rollout.  And they optimize [...]

  • Robyn Kelly

    I don’t think facebook should share my info with anyone.

  • http://laravogt.com/2010/03/31/facebooks-privacy-policy-changes-yet-again/ Facebook’s privacy policy changes yet again « Laravogt's Blog

    [...] 31, 2010 by Lara Vogt what I read: Facebook’s plan to automatically share your data with sites you never signed up for what I thought: Facebook making more changes? I’m not surprised. If I’ve come to expect [...]

  • http://g2thehart.com/2010/03/30/logout-of-your-facebook-account/ LOGOUT OF YOUR FACEBOOK ACCOUNT! « Ghart

    [...] LOGOUT OF YOUR FACEBOOK ACCOUNT! March 30, 2010 if you have facebook read this [...]

  • http://www.basicthinking.de/blog/2010/03/31/facebook-legt-fuer-30-minuten-die-mail-adressen-der-mitglieder-offen/ Facebook legt für 30 Minuten die Mail-Adressen der Mitglieder offen | Basic Thinking Blog

    [...] um ein neues Features zu implementieren. Es geht darum, dass nun auch externe Publisher Zugriff auf das Cookie des Netzwerks gewährt bekommen sollen. Selbst, wenn Nutzer sich auf fremden Seiten nicht für Facebook [...]

  • http://www.bbfajas.com.ve/wordpress/2010/03/31/facebook-revelo-ayer-las-direcciones-de-correo-privadas-a-todo-el-mund-0397 Technocismo » Blog » Facebook reveló ayer las direcciones de correo privadas a todo el mundo

    [...] tiene intención de cambiar su política de privacidad, pudiendo mostrar información a tercerossin el consentimiento del usuario. Pero esto no parecía [...]

  • Red

    Please do it. What you’re describing is the exact same way the brain activates a network of thought (web accounts) based on a single piece of information (Facebook sign-in).

  • http://www.defamer.com.au/2010/03/facebook-revealed-private-email-addresses-last-night/ Facebook Revealed Private Email Addresses Last Night | Defamer Australia

    [...] has new privacy alterations coming up, but this doesn’t appear to be part of it. Anyone know what happened? [...]

  • http://www.twitter.com/robinteractive robinteractive

    In the words of Bansky, “In the future, everyone will be anonymous for 15 minutes.”

    Even without these changes Facebook, your e-mail address already reveals A LOT about you in terms of social network activity: http://robinteractive.wordpress.com/2010/03/31/email-social-media-convergence-intentional-unintentional-marketing/

  • http://shanewhiting.com/2010/03/31/fbooks-selling-its-users-souls/ F***book’s selling its users souls.

    [...] Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • http://natnick.com/2010/03/31/facebooks-new-setting/ Facebook’s new setting « natnick

    [...] natnick « iPad > laptop ? Facebook’s new setting March 31, 2010 Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • http://schwarzemilch.wordpress.com/2010/04/01/facebook-und-der-datenhunger/ Facebook und der Datenhunger « schwarze milch

    [...] In Zukunft soll es für Facebook noch leichter sein, Daten seiner Nutzer, leichter an Dritte weiterz…. Zu der “Generellen Information” der Nutzer, die weitergegeben wird, zählen “your and your friends’ names, profile pictures, gender, connections, and any content shared using the Everyone privacy setting. We may also make information about the location of your computer or access device and your age available to applications and websites in order to help them implement appropriate security measures and control the distribution of age-appropriate content.” [...]

  • http://dimlightarchive.com/?p=301 Christian A. Young's Dimlight Archive |

    [...] – Facebook user? More privacy settings shenanigans afoot. [...]

  • http://shadowsecurity.info/4307/facebook-revelo-ayer-las-direcciones-de-correo-privadas-a-todo-el-mundo.html Facebook reveló ayer las direcciones de correo privadas a todo el mundo | Shadow Security

    [...] tiene intención de cambiar su política de privacidad, pudiendo mostrar información a terceros sin el consentimiento del usuario. Pero esto no parecía [...]

  • http://www.slargentina.com/2010/04/04/facebook-revelo-las-direcciones-de-correo-de-sus-usuarios-a-todo-el-mundo/ Facebook reveló las direcciones de correo de sus usuarios a todo el mundo | Software libre, tecnología y más

    [...] tiene intención de cambiar su política de privacidad, pudiendo mostrar información a terceros sin el consentimiento del usuario. Pero esto no parecía [...]

  • http://jordonious.com/2010/04/05/1o_reasons_to_ban_facebook/ 1o_reasons_to_ban_facebook « backstreets

    [...] original_article [...]

  • http://www.privacylives.com/washington-post-the-latest-facebook-fracas-your-privacy-vs-its-profit/2010/04/05/ Privacy Lives » Blog Archive » Washington Post: The latest Facebook fracas: Your privacy vs. its profit

    [...] possible change didn’t exactly get a charitable read in reactions like “Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For,&#8… and “Facebook Planning To Give Away Your Data To ‘Partners.’ [...]

  • http://luumurecordings.com/mulva/2010/04/05/facebook-avaa-kayttajien-tiedot-mainostajille/ » Facebook avaa käyttäjien tiedot mainostajille. » Mediatulva – MULVA? » Digimaailman ihmeitä.

    [...] TechCrunch: Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For [...]

  • http://www.mywownetwork.com/ericbriggs Eric Briggs

    With over 40,000 plus servers, Facebook IS the new internet!

  • http://www.charmainelimblog.com Charmaine

    This is violation of privacy because some people use the social media for business purpose but not to get connected to friends.

  • http://studiobaroni.wordpress.com/2010/04/06/facebook-nuovo-giro-di-privacy/ Facebook, nuovo giro di privacy « STUDIO BARONI

    [...] Per TechCrunch, la nuova mossa del social network darà ai siti terzi la possibilità di identificareanche quegli utenti che non hanno mai accettato di accedere a Facebook Connect. In questo modo, le applicazioni terze potranno visualizzare i dati personali degli iscritti e dei loro amici. Con la probabilità molto alta che questi stessi dati personali vengano condivisi con chiunque. [...]

  • http://juegando.com/uncategorized/win-a-free-ticket-to-facebook%e2%80%99s-f8-conference/ Win A Free Ticket To Facebook’s f8 Conference | Juegando

    [...] we believe Facebook plans on launching, including a Like button for the entire Internet, a Facebook Auto-Connect, and a Meebo Bar clone. It’s going to be a big [...]

  • http://annares.wordpress.com/2010/04/04/labor-2-0-digital-sweatshops-pt-2/ Labor 2.0 – Digital Sweatshops, pt. 2 « the bad days will end

    [...] Facebook’s Plan To Automatically Share Your Data With Sites You Never Signed Up For. [...]

  • http://competingcooperation.com/?p=362 Why it’s time to close your Facebook account | Open Ecosystems

    [...] changes.  On cue, all of the folks that pay attention to Facebook’s privacy moves closely—TechCrunch, ReadWriteWeb, Louis Gray and Inside Facebook—rang the alarm bells. After all, do we really want [...]

  • http://thestephanieburke.com/2010/04/09/what-would-make-you-stop-using-facebook/ What Would Make you STOP using Facebook? « The Stephanie Burke

    [...] own grave. Have you looked into the new “Privacy Policy” they rolled out? Read about it here. Basically, Facebook is going to share your info with “Pre Approved Third Party Sites” [...]

  • http://portuseguridad.org/?p=773 » Facebook comparte tus datos con otros sitios web sin tu permiso previo

    [...] en Techcrunch. Share and [...]

  • sphamster

    lol @ twitter. Didn't you hear the other day that even Farmville has more active users? Hah. It's a fad. These are all fads. They can't own the internet. The final boss is too tough.

  • http://gutfeldt.ch/matthias/blog/ Matthias

    The question is, who owns your online identity? At the moment, your online identity is distributed across several commercial websites. If Facebook succeeds, they will own your online identity across all those websites. Your online identity is no longer distributed, it is centrallized – and it is no longer yours, but belongs to Facebook, and they can do with it as they please.

    So the best move would be to get your own website, start your own blog, and finally build your online identity in a way that ensures you actually own it.

  • http://leecatapulta.com/?p=194 Facebook: ¡Aguas Google que ahí te voy! « catapulta

    [...] Mark Zuchenberg, co-fundador de Facebook, expuso su plan para que en todos los rincones de Internet puedas sugerir, compartir, comentar y publicar a tus amigos lo que te gusta… Y facebook será el encargado de controlar todo esto, al mismo tiempo tomará la información y la empaquetará muy bonita para que otras páginas que jamás has visitado estén listas para darte la bienvenida. [...]

  • http://hostingz.org desbest

    How the hell do you remember every email address you have?

  • http://hostingz.org desbest

    Google and Facebook are competing together to own the internet.

  • http://hostingz.org desbest

    Everyone know that cookies and sessions expire after a predefined amount of time. Most websites make it 30 minutes.

  • MICKEY12GAUGE

    HAHA!

  • http://omahageek.sainzfamily.info/2010/05/14/general-nervous-about-facebook-integration-with-os4-0/ General — Nervous about Facebook integration with OS4.0 « Omaha Geeks iPhone App Review

    [...] Plu­g­ins, which include new “like” but­tons every­where on sites out­side Facebook.com, auto-login capa­bil­i­ties for those sites with­out click­ing on Face­book Con­nect, and even a Face­book social bar [...]

  • http://newsit.es/will-facebook-be-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-google-and-google-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-microsoft/ Will Facebook Be Tomorrow’s Google, and Google Tomorrow’s Microsoft? | Startup Websites

    [...] on the other hand has become the world’s identity gatekeeper—your age, sex, location, where you went to school, where you work, who your friends are—all of [...]

  • http://reviewsmanual.com/will-facebook-be-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-google-and-google-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-microsoft.html Will Facebook Be Tomorrow’s Google, and Google Tomorrow’s Microsoft? | Reviews Manual

    [...] on the another assistance has embellish the world’s identity gatekeeper—your age, sex, location, where you went to school, where you work, who your friends are—all of [...]

  • http://socialshoppingnews.landheremedia.com/2010/05/15/will-facebook-be-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-google-and-google-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-microsoft/ Will Facebook Be Tomorrow’s Google, and Google Tomorrow’s Microsoft? | Social Shopping News

    [...] on the other hand has become the world’s identity gatekeeper—your age, sex, location, where you went to school, where you work, who your friends are—all of [...]

  • http://firesaw.wordpress.com/2010/05/15/will-facebook-be-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-google-and-google-tomorrow%e2%80%99s-microsoft/ Will Facebook Be Tomorrow’s Google, and Google Tomorrow’s Microsoft? « Firesaw

    [...] on the other hand has become the world’s identity gatekeeper—your age, sex, location, where you went to school, where you work, who your friends are—all of [...]

  • http://yahoo bubamaigoro

    help

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us