An Apology To Our Readers
Michael Arrington
Feb 4, 2010

On Monday evening I received a phone call from someone I trust who told me that one of our interns had asked for compensation in exchange for a blog post. Specifically, this intern had allegedly asked for a Macbook Air in exchange for a post about a startup.

After an investigation we determined that the allegation was true. In fact, on at least one other occasion this intern was almost certainly given a computer in exchange for a post.

The intern in question has admitted to some of the allegations, and has denied others. We suspended this person while we were sorting through exactly what happened. When it became clear yesterday that there was no question that this person had requested, and in one case taken, compensation for a post, the intern was terminated.

This was not one of our full time writers, and so the frequency of posts was light. Nevertheless, we’ve also deleted all content created by this person on our blogs. We are fairly certain that most of the posts weren’t tainted in any way, but to be sure we’ve removed every word written by this person on the TechCrunch network.

Our attorneys have advised us not to disclose the name of the individual because the person is not a legal adult. We also think that, given the intern’s age, it may not be appropriate to make their identity public.

We are all shaken here at TechCrunch – this is someone who was our friend and who we trusted to be honest with our readers. Our hope is that the intern learns something from this experience and grows into the kind of person that will be more welcome in this community.

I apologize to each one of you. I promise that we will always maintain complete transparency with you on how we operate, even when it isn’t such an easy thing to do.

Advertisement
  • Related Topics
Advertisement
  • alex

    What did you expect when you took on kids and gave them access to one of the most read blogs on the internets?

  • Ian Crew

    Bravo, Michael–a good way to handle a very unfortunate situation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Richard_David_Jordan/670058782 Richard David Jordan

    Right way to handle it.

  • Andy

    Thanks for being upfront and not sweeping it under the carpet Mike.

  • DNA

    Nice that you aren’t disclosing his identity. It’ll give him a chance to make amends.

  • Concerned Reader

    Wow, this is nuts. I wonder who it was?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ray_Ray_Angel/551968797 Ray Ray Angel

    Great work Michael on coming out and saying this, admitting the problem and making a commitment to keep the transparency.

  • http://jeffthegreat.blogspot.com Jmartens

    Don’t hire kids!

  • mcoond

    glad that this was sorted early on and at least u r honest enough to disclose this and admit lapses committed by someone over there.

  • http://www.nicholaswu.ca N

    Full disclosure = good. Appreciated.

    But I dunno “We are all shaken here” just sounded off in the apology…

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dennis_Yu/18811629 Dennis Yu

    Mike– kudos to you for honest journalism. TechCrunch readers will respect your publication all the more for this.

  • Sean

    Thx 4 being upfront. Was it Daniel bru?

  • karstensrage

    +1 Great job and a testament to transparency. Thank you.

  • http://hellologic.com Nathan Brauer

    For all you know, the writer could have been family.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris_Montone/805578064 Chris Montone

    By deleting all their posts haven’t you indirectly revealed who the person?

  • http://woodmarvels.com Jon

    Sucks that such a thing happened but being honest about it and taking steps to remedy the situation, as you have done, is a great move. Thanks for sharing!

    Jon @ WoodMarvels.com

  • http://www.blackysky.com Ricardo

    I hope he will learn something from that and never sell his soul for a quick buck… corruption is everywhere…. sad …

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris_Montone/805578064 Chris Montone

    By deleting all their posts haven’t you indirectly revealed their identity?

  • V.

    Sounds like you need to hire college interns instead of minor aged high school interns.

    The threat of legal recourse will be much more effective with an exclusively adult aged writing staff.

    ~ V.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Epitome of why you are successful and such a classy way to handle the situation. Honored to share the space with you.

    Thank you for this post.

  • dang

    Dang. now who am I gonna get to write my stories?

    Just kidding :) Mike- Good work.

  • http://www.whitepages.com Kevin Nakao

    I understand why your are shaken and commend the disclosure. We all like to mentor new talent, and it can shake you to your core when principles and trust are violated.

  • Chris

    By deleting all their posts haven’t you indirectly revealed their identity to some people?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Erika_Bitzer/711384687 Erika Bitzer

    Wow, I really respect how you handled this. Corporations should take note.

  • Donkey Face

    Was it MG? coz he writes craps most of the time…

  • http://www.facebook.com/ michele

    Interns aren’t allowed to receive any type of reward? I don’t know the rules to being an intern…

  • http://www.addtodesign.com Mathew Carpenter

    The little respect I had for this individual is now out the window. Too be honest, it’s not surprising after you now think about some of the posts this person has done in the past.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Clearly, you haven’t had your trust breached.

  • Jewel

    Thank you for being honest and remember there are adults out here who need a job.

  • ag

    so basically hes selling TC’s blog space?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jewel_Trotman_Fryer/1214299388 Jewel Trotman Fryer

    Thank you for being honest and remember there are adults out here who need a job.

  • Dave

    Credibility gained through an honest disclosure of events almost always outweighs any damage done.

    Good work Tech Crunch for leading by example.

  • http://www.michaelcarrano.com Michael

    Glad to see the transparency in the way TechCrunch operates. However, I’m kind of curious as to why TechCrunch would employ such a young individual.

    Hopefully this individual learns from this mistake and grows to become a better person from this incident.

  • http://www.ihany.com Hany Rashwan

    I think it’s fair to say that if you find out that someone you’ve been working closely with for months has actually been asking for money on the side illegally (the equivalent of taking a bribe), you would also be “shaken”.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Josh_Leong/1809817 Josh Leong

    When’s the next round of hiring new ETHICAL interns? I’d love to apply to fill that spot, i’m 23.

  • http://www.amitbhawani.com/blog/ Amit Bhawani

    May be they believed his hard work and allowed him in, who did his childish acts. Good to see that he is now removed.

  • http://fakhru.com Fakhruddin

    Thanks for the clarity and integrity that Techcrunch maintains. This move spreads a good message about TC.

  • Corry Uptus

    Can I still keep the macBook Air?

  • http://twitter.com/peterc Peter Cooper

    Yes, since you can just do a Google “site:” search and click through all the authors till you find the one with all the deleted posts.

    But, to be honest, what does it matter? It was a mistake and they’re resolving it. I hope it doesn’t dissuade TC from giving interns a shot in the future :-(

  • Craig

    Even though the handling was good, what is up with having non professionals (and non fulltimers) being on the front line of your branding, messaging, customer interactions? Not a little bit troubled?

    Really unfortunate that such a tradeoff needed to have such an unfortunate outcome.

  • http://www.columnbreak.com Josh

    Wow, not cool. And all of this just for a MacBook Air…

    He should’ve asked for the Large Hadron Collider and hung up.

  • Ben

    The right response, and thanks for informing your readers.

    Additionally, considering the intern’s youth, very good of you to not disclose his/her name. How easy it is to forget that we all do stupid things when we’re teenagers, some of us more embarrassingly than others. Having dodged a bullet and knowing it, they ought to learn from the experience and have a chance to rebuild themselves, as opposed to having a career permanently tainted by what is so obviously an idiotic and easily discovered flaunting of basic journalistic ethics (I’m amazed any company actually gave a laptop instead of dialing you up).

    Thanks to all of you for your continued high-quality work.

  • Nick Peters

    Appreciate the openness and maintaining their anonymity – it’s definitely the right way to handle it.

    I would take issue with some of the comments saying ‘what do you expect when you hire kids’. Please don’t let one person’s error put you off taking on young people.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Wan-Qi_Ask_Kim/1337876432 Wan-Qi Ask Kim

    Mike, I’m uncertain about your journalism ethics. But as far as your humanity, I Applaud you. I hope you continue giving kids a chance to fail or succeed. If it wasn’t for bigshots who took big chances on my sorry ass when I was in my teen, I wouldn’t be where I am today.

    I applaud your mentorship of teens. Please continue taking risks on them.

  • Adam

    Shame that a 17 year old with much potential has already soiled his reputation in the tech community. Though TechCrunch was kind enough not to broadcast his name, everyone with a brain knows who it was. Hopefully Daniel will apologize to the TechCrunch writers and community so that he can move on from this as quickly as possible.

    This post sponsored by the Bribes in Tech Network

  • http://ianmrountree.com/ Ian M Rountree

    Wow – what a shake up! Good on you for swift, decisive action, however. Too often this kind of thing gets lost in the shuffle.

    Hope to never hear of this kind of thing again (mostly because it can be such a blow to troupe morale!).

  • silicon valley dropout

    what a f**king idiot to throw away such a golden opportunity to work for techcrunch

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Yuset_Pozo/513416171 Yuset Pozo

    This is why I am a loyal reader..mike you like the truth more then the money..

  • Justyn

    That’s too bad. He’s a good kid, he’ll do ok – lesson learned hopefully. Have to imagine the *offer* was presented to him first, went downhill from there.

  • http://www.quanp.com/us nakanakaman

    I think you’re so honest and great! I trust Techcrunch more. In Japan case, never reveals like this thing. Please keep good work!

  • http://www.afpakblog.wordpress.com Random Reader

    Way to go. Not revealing his identity should give the up-and-coming techie a chance for amends.

  • http://brianjameswilson.blogspot.com/ Brian Wilson

    I did a search for him in their archives. It pulled up a long list of posts so I assumed it wasn’t him. But then I clicked thru to 10 of his posts and they all returned page not found messages. I think it was him.

  • Sean

    So I did a search and turns out it is Daniel bru doesn’t suprise me. He did so many weird posts. Do a search for yourself if you don’t beleive me.

  • Craig

    why do you feel the need to divulge who this was? What right do you have to do this? You must be the Supreme Dipshit on High.

  • Donkey Face
  • Adam Gell

    Just reading this today, maybe it was this kid:

    http://www.workstationsetups.com/mac/home-setup/

    http://www.danielbru.com/

  • http://ijustine.com Justine

    I think you just need a good old fashioned video blogger in the mix.

  • http://kmcgrady.posterous.com Kieran McGrady

    People have to learn. You can’t not hire kids and expect them to do a good job right off the mark in the future.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Scott_Kramer/653430944 Scott Kramer

    You’re definitely one class act, and why I turn to you each day…thanks.

  • youngluck

    MG?

  • Will Smidlein

    Hey, Being a younger person, I feel for them. Just really though…. really?!

  • Pooya

    Good for you guys, Michael sure knows how to keep this media clean!

  • youngluck

    HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • Andy

    Right, our prisons are full of kids, nothing but kids.

  • alex

    I’m sure you were young once, and thus understand the different ways in which adults and not-yet-adults will deal with abnormal situations (… like being a techcrunch writer with basically a free reign).

  • Will Smidlein

    Just a quick pointout…. if you see this guy on the street, ummmm…. yeah. http://www.crunchbase.com/assets/images/resized/0002/3264/23264v3-max-250×250.jpg

  • Dave Hanna

    Handled with class.

    Now, how do you handle the startups that asked for the post in the first place?

    I am sure these folks were a little older and shame on them for luring kid in first place.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Gerardo_Curiel/694255764 Gerardo Curiel

    “the intern was terminated”. Techcrunchnator anybody?

  • http://www.pathikshah.com/blog Pathik

    Mistakes happen. He was a kid.

    BTW great move, TC

  • http://Octechnophile.com David amodt

    He’ll just work at gizmodo now. Lol.I wouldve ratted him out since he’ll probably pull the same stunt elsewhere and now there’s no record of him.

  • http://www.seattle20.com Marcelo Calbucci

    That sucks.

    You should actually add a paragraph to this post telling all entrepreneurs, investors & PR folks they should denounce this kind of pay-to-play — on this blog or any other blog.

  • Andy

    Yes, but you can chain kids in your basement whereas that’s not legal for college interns.

  • Will Smidlein

    hahahaahaahaha

  • Will Smidlein

    For an AIR?!

  • Adam

    Indeed, I am the “Supreme Dipshit on High” , whatever that means.

    You caught me.

  • http://richworks.in Richie

    Well, it is a good thing you didn’t reveal his identity and handled the situation perfectly. Isn’t writing articles for TC is way cooler than begging for a Macbook air?

    My gosh!!! That kid… what a senseless maniac!

  • Davey

    Frustrating, but thanks.
    I followed a lead based on a blog-post earlier this week. Thankfully the post is still on your site, so it isn’t a potentially questionable firm.
    However, if much of what the kid wrote was about companies that are above board, it’s too bad that the removals will mark them as potentially toxic.

  • dazou

    If no harm was done, then why apologize? Poor kid.

  • http://www.gizapage.com Vijay Rayapati

    Bravo TC and Michael – I am touched by your transparency.

  • App guy

    Since his name is now public I think the names of the companies who bought favorable posts from him should also be revealed. While he was of course wrong to do this we should also be informed as readers which companies and individuals bribed a minor in exchange for posts.

    For now I’ll assume it was the most blatantly useless companies that he frequently wrote about.

  • Rose

    Thanks for disclosing.

    The most valuable lesson I took away from my internship at an online pub was the importance in honesty. While it’s common sense, it should be something that is heavily stressed during a journalism internship. There are many companies that are reaching out to you to get a mention and it’s important to be able to separate yourself and think of the readers, the future readers and if the content you are writing about genuinely contributes to the interest of the community.

    I wish the intern luck. It sucks to have to learn the hard way but it’s important that they do. Hopefully, he/she will learn from this and go over and beyond what they need to do to rectify their mistake.

  • Johnny

    This makes a great case for never letting an intern get close to anything important.

  • http://gerardo.com.ve Gerardo Curiel

    “the intern was terminated”. Techcrunchnator anybody?

  • http://www.sriraj.org Sriraj

    Naaa, MG looks 30+ for sure :)

  • dan

    There are enough posts about apple products!

  • deepak

    i like your integrity and transparency…role model for other to follow.

  • http://staynalive.com Jesse Stay

    Careful Justine – they got MG from VentureBeat. You might just get an offer! I’m all for it!

  • mike

    because i’m sure adults would never act this way.

  • Nite

    Now you are locked under MG’s Mac-radar ;)

  • http://vikas-gupta.in Vikas Gupta

    I’m impressed! What a great way to make it public! You did the right thing. :)

  • Steven

    Michael,

    your honesty and transparency are much appreciated! Excellent reaction to make this difficult decision public, this boosts the credibility of TC even more.

    Steven

  • Justyn

    Shame on the commenters. Yes, it wasn’t hard to figure out, but clearly the intent of the post was to NOT identify him. Instead of cutting the kid a break you want to impress everyone with your *click a few times* investigative skills. Not cool.

  • trench

    Honestly, I could care less who the intern/”writer” was… I want the list of sites involved.

    Are you going to offer *that* level of transparency?

  • Tom

    Welcome to the world of Gen Y…

  • Anon
  • http://trueslant.com/marcfloreshttp://www.mobilecrunch.com/author/marc/ Marc

    Hmm, I wonder who could fill that spot.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jeff_Hodsdon/683226814 Jeff Hodsdon

    This post sounds like he murdered somebody

  • tt

    The fellow in question wrote recently a revealing tweet:

    Writing probably one of the hardest emails I’ve ever had to write. The world will know what I’m talking about this weekend.
    11:00 AM Feb 2nd from web

  • http://lalawag.com sean percival

    A real heartbreaker

  • craig

    That’s nothing, MG probably has boatloads of free twitter gear and I.O.Us from loopt.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Asa_Hartley/732486401 Asa Hartley

    Bill Clinton can attest to that.

  • http://12seconds.tv sol

    Shame on whoever preyed upon him. Whichever startup that is, shame on those individuals.

    He’s a good kid. He will grow from this, no doubt. We’ve all done stupid things. I’m glad that TC has integrity.

  • Pinky

    I hope you’re joking old man.

  • http://sidlabs.com Adnan

    You did it very right. Bravo! I really respect the human side of yours. Very appropriate way to handle such situations.

  • Nite

    I am not sure whether it is Daniel Brusilovsky or not. His posts have surely been deleted. But, in the ‘About TechCrunch’ link, his name is still there and it states that he is still a writer for Techcrunch. So, I don’t know….

  • http://blog.redfin.com Glenn Kelman

    Very nicely handled Mike, and I’m sorry it happened.

  • http://blog.manishsinha.net Manish Sinha
  • Everfalling

    wow. he risked his employment at techcrunch for a mac? hope he enjoys it the ungrateful little shit.

  • Cash Reid

    Come on it is obviously Daniel. All of his posts are mysteriously missing… I am really disappointed in him as, being his age, I really looked up to him. I also think it is unfair he is singlehandedly smearing the morality of teens.

  • Kelly

    You have to admit it is pretty cool that Techcrunch gives opportunity for those that want to work as an intern. Some people do not realize that something like an internship at a company like Techcrunch is a once in a lifetime opportunity and you will never, never, NEVER have another chance like this in your life! Thanks Michael and Techcrunch for the continued transparency and honesty, true character has been shown. I just hope this incident has not ruined future opportunities for other young people with drive and desire to succeed!

  • Michael T. Halligan

    I have to ask, how is this any different from TechCrunch writing glowing posts about companies that spend many thousands of dollars per month on advertising? Or singing the praises of the lame startups that pay thousands of dollars to annoy people in the “Demo Pit” of TechCrunch 50?

    TechCrunch isn’t a newspaper, it’s a blog, and an overly sensational one at that, one that is just a bit too focused on Twitter, Facebook, and Apple for me to have taken seriously for many years now.

  • Ram

    Quick, before it is gone …
    http://www.crunchbase.com/person/daniel-brusilovsky

    Also, search for that author on techcrunch and yep, all the articles lead to a “Page Not Found”

  • http://exploratisserie.com/ June

    Google never forgets. And come on, it’s not fucking hard to figure it out. Wow, I can’t believe they were so tactless and pretty much ruined the kid’s career.

  • Courtney

    That’s unfortunate. Well, I’m sure con-artists have internships available. ;)

  • annon

    I’m frankly suprised by the lack of censure by the commentators “he’s just a kid” and “you shouldn’t have divulged his name”. Truth be told he isn’t “just a kid” is he? he’s 17 not 7. and according to his website he has founded several companies and is a tech evangelist for Qik etc. He a professional, he works and gets paid etc. why should why hold him to the same standards? He sold techcrunch’s blog space which in fact is their product. It’s no different than if some teenager working at target stole inventory and sold them on the streets. This kid would be facing criminal charges. It was dishonest and wrong. and he did it repeated so it wasn’t a once off. Apology for such dishonesty in banking, finance, other white collar stuff sends the message that this behavior is okay.

  • http://www.newageofpolitics.com Charles H.

    As someone who is currently going through the process of finding an internship, I can address at least some of this. I do not know the rules for high school interns (since Mike states that the person in question is not a legal adult, I am assuming they are not yet in college), but for college-level interns, the “reward” is usually either academic credit or a fair salary.

    Journalism is one of my areas of interest, and having researched literally hundreds of internship possibilities, I have not come across a single one where receiving goods such as a laptop is a suitable reward. In fact, according to the Federal Trade Commission, being “sponsored” for a blog post, as apparently this intern was, and not prominently acknowledging it is illegal as of last year.

    As an intern, he would have been treated like a regular employee, and would have had to abide by the same regulations that Mike, MG, and every other blogger on the internet has to follow. The fact that he is a minor makes almost no difference in this instance. This would seem to be a fairly large black mark against him the next time he tries to get a job; after all, some commenters have already mentioned how easy it is to discover the identity behind the one responsible. I have not worked in a human resources department, but everything I have heard about the hiring process includes a check online of just about anything imaginable.

  • Heh

    “But I’m a kid at heart”.

  • raul

    Handled well, an unfortunate situation but these things do happen and its how one responds that matters. i would definitely hire a kid, if i found them promising and would be extremely disappointed if let down like this. Hopefully the person in question learns from this as there is nothing worse than letting down folks who choose to believe in you.

  • Scott

    Just so you know TechCrunch…you never came across as non-biased. I mean, I still read you and all that…but when you drone on and on about Twitter or some startup started by a 16-yr. old, you aren’t exactly fooling anyone.

    Even so, glad you got the situation under control.

    Besides, who the hell would want a Macbook Air!?! I’d have fired him based on taste alone.

  • http://www.5minutesformom.com Susan (5 Minutes for Mom)

    I’m glad you chose transparency but I agree that by deleting all his old posts it made it clear who he was.

    It does seem to me that having a 17 year old write and publish for a site as big as techcrunch might not be a good idea. But that being said, age doesn’t seem to always factor into good judgement.

    I hope he learns from this and that others considering such temptations are warned.

  • Shay Guy

    “Reward” isn’t the term. He was accepting bribes. I don’t think it’s even permitted to accept gifts.

  • deb

    How about revealing the sleazy companies that gave the intern the computer. Ethic are no secret to these companies. They knew they were stepping over a line.

  • Nat

    How can you just say don’t hire kids? The writers age has nothing to do with it, it’s purely the matter of the writer taking compensation to say good things. This has happened and will happen again.

    But blanketing against hiring kids because one person messed up is wrong. If people are unwilling to give younger people experience, we are just guaranteed to make repeat our mistakes again, because kids won’t have any chance to learn from anything but their own mistakes. Find the smart and honest kids. Bring them under your wing and teach them. If you do and get burned, oh well, I have no doubt that both of you will grow from the situation.

  • Heh

    “Never allow family to stand in the way of profit”

  • Zorba

    The comment about Bill Clinton and interns at 10:25 PST is damn funny :) haha

  • Scott

    Yeah, and people over 18 tend to want to be PAID for doing work (‘specially college educated people). In this economy especially many companies use the term “Internship” as a way to get cheap, if not free, labor.

  • http://www.gizmotastic.com Jeff Manes

    For a site like yours that will report the violation of journalistic ethics there are hundreds of blogs that will opening ask for swag. Thanks for being above board about the incident.

  • Sigurd

    While I applaud the disclosure I am left with an uneasy feeling after realising that some of the TC articles are apparently written by high-school age teenagers.

    I may be biased that way but I prefer my news to come from people with some education and life experience.

  • Heh

    Bribe is such an offensive term, let’s use “lobbying” instead.

  • Chris

    Weren’t there rumors that he and his little friends have been stealing designs and such for some time now selling them off as their own to make a buck???

    Punk kids!

  • Anon
  • http://helmetcameracentral.com Chadical

    June spot on. agreed.

  • Heh

    I’d pay to see that.

  • http://techretold.com Shan

    It’s a one off case, Do n’t think all the kids would be like him

  • DeveloperFish

    WTH? You don’t manage your interns? Anyone w/any management experience would know that young interns are still learning their way – they need to be coached; they need to be mentored; and they need to be actively managed (daily).

    Mike – the intern is certainly guilty, but you and your staff are also at fault for not providing the active guidance and leadership…

  • charles

    perhaps it was the shaking down of startups that ruined the kid’s career, not this post.

  • http://www.nibrasbawa.net Nibras Bawa

    It pays to be honest. Humbled by your sincerity. Maybe you can add a “Techcrunch code of ethics” for all staff? I am sure there are guidelines in place already, but am just thinking maybe you should make it clear to everyone.

    Salute & Respect from Singapore !

  • http://mohanarun.com Mohan Arun L (@marun2 on Twitter)

    That’s interesting, are interns allowed to publish whatever they originate, with the so-sure chance of getting published that the startup would definitely give a computer in exchange for it?

  • DeveloperFish

    Mike – you guys should have been providing more active coaching, 1 on 1 guidance, and management. Kid is guilty… but your environment enabled it…

  • Chris

    twitter is ALL over it…

    http://twitter.com/#search?q=danielbru

  • You are completely clueless

    Tactless is blatantly taking bribes. If the kid’s career gets ruined, it will be his own fault. You’ve clearly never run a business. How can you even see or breathe with your head so far up your own ass?

  • Laura

    Classy.

  • http://felix-hansen.com Felix

    The fact that he wanted an Air (thin as sh!t and about just as practical) clearly shows that he’s a naive kiddy with total lack of great forethought of his actions.
    Kiddies are like gremlins, they come with instructions and should never be left unattended for too long.
    Michael, I’d like to know whether young interns and whoever has the power to publish an article are clearly briefed about what’s good and what’s bad. Is there something like mentoring for such kids?

  • http://www.MartijnVreugde.com Martijn Vreugde

    The kid ruined the kids career, he was smart enough to get the internship at TC I’m sure he knew very well that what he was doing was not ethical.

  • OhhJohnny

    I appreciate the transparency and think this is the best way to handle things. Temptation is hard to resist for a 17-year-old, and even for those who are a bit older. Shitty for him but he deserves all the crap this will lead to. He will be able to bounce back, look at the Business Insider dude – he was ripping people off for millions of dollars and is now semi-respected in the space.

    Of course, I never like Daniel’s posts and was always wondering what the hell he was doing there. I know he’s the son of someone close, but hopefully this will teach TC to be more careful about its writers.

  • http://herdrick.posterous.com Ethan Herdrick

    Commenters: please stop with the name drops of your suspect. Kids do bad things. Have some mercy.

    Michael: well done.

  • AB

    Feel sorry for this
    Daniel Brusilovsky kid, he doesnt know that this will remain WELL documented for years to come!! All his life basically …

  • http://www.newageofpolitics.com Charles H.

    As a politics geek, that term seems to fit, though the startup was lobbying him, so the language would need to be changed around slightly :)

    And @Shay Guy, it isn’t permitted as per FTC regulations issued in the past year.

  • Felipe

    I was always amazed he was there in the first place. His articles were very poorly written anyway. I knew it wasn’t going to last long. But I didn’t know something like this would happen…wow.

  • EH

    i’m not convinced this kid wasn’t also an illegal intern.

  • Kevin Dent

    WTF Mike, it is not like he was given virtual products from google and then dis’d the iPhone…………….no wait!

  • Da truth

    Looks like this person is just right to work on Wall Street, or Vito Corleone operations

  • Jason

    hmmmm. I wonder which Kid it could have been. Daniel Brusilovsky maybe? Good grief, that kid was so annoying anyways. Best of luck with his Teens In Tech Network and lousy acquisitions.

    When will MG just go off and start his own tech blog? He outgrew his old job and now his latest.

  • Prashant Gandhi

    Regrettable behaviour. I am sure they had much going for them. Good on TC for being transparent.

  • Pixel

    Wow – you really terminated him? Pretty harsh that a macbook deserves the death penalty but hey,.

  • http://exploratisserie.com/ June

    It’s tactless to say what you’re doing is “protecting” someone by not revealing his identity… but then obviously knowing that you’re revealing who he is.

  • Jason

    Of course it was him. He should be banned from all events, I was sick of seeing him anyways. Arrington spelled it out. They only had one underage intern.

  • http://www.justinfreid.com Justin Freid

    It’s reassuring that you disclosed the conflict of interest, but can you please post the code of ethics that Tech Crunch follows?

  • AB
  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joshua_Willis/863315493 Joshua Willis

    I had no idea that kids who aren’t even 18 had enough pull on this site to take kickbacks to have companies featured. Puts this site in a whole new light for me, no matter how the situation has been handled after the fact. Is this a tech news site, or Romper Room?

  • LarchOye

    So um, why couldn’t you guys have just paid your interns for their work, and allowed them to use some 1337 hardware for writing posts a testing individual hardware components…

  • http://www.touchballgame.com/ Sachin

    he or she :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sherie_Rhie/100000557713585 Sherie Rhie

    There’s no better way of reporting it than what mike did. At least, the kid still has his identity secured. Although, I believe many are convince that the kid was the one who wrote this post (now deleted)

    Google dashboard to the rescue! :D

  • Sean

    Family members make horrible employees. They’re lazy and take shit for granted.

    That’s all I have to say.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    “We are fairly certain that most of the posts weren’t tainted in any way, but to be sure we’ve removed every word written by this person on the TechCrunch network.”

    How is that tactless? The kid’s career isn’t ruined — what’s important is how he chooses to accept responsibility for his actions. This is the Internet, we can all be heard and we all have voices.

  • http://notbrainsurgery.livejournal.com Vadim

    Speaking of transparency, why would not you disclose the name of the company who bribed your intern?

  • John

    You should hire her. She is more charming than all of you put together.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Why is his identity relevant?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Wow. Way to keep it classy, Donkey Face. #troll

  • J. M.

    Before the digital lynch mobbing starts, there needs to be some perspective put in place. He’s a kid — and at the end of the day, kids do dumb things. Was it a written policy that was clearly explained to him? It can be confusing and perhaps there’s a bigger story as to why he wanted a Mac AIR as compensation to write a blog post. It can’t be for lack of his own computer (I’m certain he owns many) ~ and I’m certain he understands that the “pay to post” model is now being regulated.

    However, sometimes we lack the maturity at 17 to really understand the ramifications. But to publicly “tar & feather” Daniel outweights all of the other positive benefits and attributes he brings. I noticed on his blog, the Teen in Tech conference is on Saturday. Was it necessary to jump on this story right before this major event? Could you have taken a few more days to investigate and work out a reasonable punishment?

    I understand Daniel now has “AIR” on his face, but we also must allow people — especially kids — to FAIL and then anticipate they’ll redeem themselves.

    Wouldn’t a better punishment have been to have him write a blog post about why what he did was wrong and also set an example? He’s been fired as if he committed a felony — as opposed to what it was: a truly bad choice.

    Although I applaud TechCrunch’s transparency and willingness to admit fault, the burden is placed heavily + squarely on one boy’s shoulders. I hope he is strong enough to carry on through this experience and that we’ll forgive his indiscretion as a public and very painful growing experience.

    To Daniel: Write openly about what happened. Be honest and understand you will be forgiven eventually. Don’t let this stop your work with Teens in Tech ~ you are inspiring a generation of teens and young innovators. Even with this experience, use it wisely. And don’t be too hard on yourself.

    We all make mistakes.

  • DDE01

    i’ve always felt a lot of posts by the second-rate writers sound like paid placement.

  • Greg

    Thanks and good job on transparency.

    I only hope that the young intern was provided rules of conduct when they started. What might seem an obvious bad move to an adult might not seem that way to a teen. There’s a reason they can’t vote yet.

    I’d be more interested to hear what company(s) thought is was ok to bribe their way in. :) An adult paying off an intern sounds a lot worse to me.

  • http://shiftb.com Brandon

    Underage? I always knew that Paul Carr was shady…………

  • mike

    “the intern was terminated”

    !!!

  • http://www.tylerwillis.net Tyler Willis

    They have helped the person immensely.

    While the techcrunch insiders will be able to figure this out, this post won’t be the first thing that comes up in a google search result for the writer’s name.

    It’s not full protection, but, it is protection.

    Really sad this happened.

  • sigh

    Funny how it was only DB’s articles that I have ever in the past been compelled to criticize. The few articles which I found laughably poor, had pathetically weak editorial standards, and lacked a distinct understanding of the vertical for which company belonged to, were all written by DB.

    That said, I wish TC would have put up a bit more editorial polish on his writing before his stuff was posted.

    Still glad to see things are being treated transparently here. Even though it clearly calls out the dishonest writer. While on one hand I feel sorry for DB, I can’t help but think that youth is not an excuse for being dishonest and not having any sense of integrity. A bribe is a bribe.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael_Kendle/538533413 Michael Kendle

    Good job Michael. I respect the way you’ve handled the situation. Keep up the good work.

  • http://www.linkshares.net/ Orlando

    if you hire kids, dnt give them authority, they usually are not very cognizant that authority comes with responsibility

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Fred_Nikgohar/515011145 Fred Nikgohar

    @TC/@Mike… while I don’t agree with everything you say/do, the transparency your company exhibits is something to aspire to. Thank you.

  • McBeese

    Why? Is taking a bribe a difficult concept for you to comprehend?

  • Why fire him?

    It seemed he learned how the business works meaning he completed a successful internship? WHY FIRE HIM?

  • Bill

    I have to agree with June on this. Either disclose the name outright or make sure it stays unknown. This “our lawyers” stuff is vengeful.

  • http://www.intellionics.com Heeren

    I agree with “nat” The writers age has nothing to do with it.

    but i must say nice way to handle situation .. donno why TC commenters are so curious to know his identity

  • http://puffpio.posterous.com David

    6th Rule of Acquisition

  • http://profy.com Svetlana Gladkova

    True but there’s one point that should be taken into account as well. I guess the problem here is that the majority of the startups covered by this intern will hardly be happy about having posts about them removed because of the situation – at least those that did not bribe anyone and got their write-ups fairly. Getting covered on TC is a challenge so losing this coverage because of someone else’s inappropriate actions will hurt.

  • http://mutimba.blog.co.uk Mutimba Mazwi

    Thanks, Mike

    You have done the most honorable thing in the world, admitting a wrong!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people//1028251971 fb1028251971

    Agreed, was this story really necessary? Had this not been posted, the deleted TC posts would have probably have gone unnoticed.

    Still, I highly this incident will ruin the kid’s career. It’s only an internship that we’re talking about here.

  • Jon

    Appreciate the honesty but what was up with all of the promotion of Daniel Bru’s “startup”, Teens in Tech.

    http://www.techcrunch.com/2010/01/20/teens-in-tech-acquires-yazzem-redesign/

    Nothing like this would have ever been featured on TC if the kid didn’t intern for you so you lost your credibility even before this….

  • http://techretold.com Shan

    It’s he.

  • http://zoolcar9.lhukie.net/ LouCypher

    You forgot that there’s no privacy on The Internet. The person in question is now being attacked on Twitter.

  • Jussi

    Hi Michael!

    When reading your post, I first thought that this is a good way to handle things. And I think it was wise for you not to give his name. Would have been the right thing to do even if he/she was not underage.

    By giving out the identity, you would have acted as police, judge, jury as well as execution in a way. However, that is exactly what you did by removing his posts.

    You should have known that everything in internet is there forever. This has been immediately proven to you by your readers who have used various caches to see what is missing. So, you did point to the identity of the person in very clear way. I would not be surprised if you get a call from his layers – because you deserve it. I just hope that the small guy, “David” will not be crushed by one of the giants of internet, “Goliath”.

    Yes, he did mistake. No, he didn’t have the experience yet to handle his situation. But yes, you should have known better how to not handle the situation. Was the sentence that you executed a little over the board? Or was it only your own ego that you are only thinking about and saving (or fear of reputation and loss of marketing money)?

  • Andrew

    That post is available on Google cache – so now I know who this intern is.

  • Ken Aston

    Two things:
    - Removing the posts isn’t fair to the innocent companies who were covered and didn’t pay.
    - You indirectly make any of them suspicious of paying for the post.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    I think ya’ll are missing the point. It’s not the who, what, when, where, or why. It’s about HOW it was handled.

    Maaan what’s wrong with you people?

  • http://www.twitter.com/willpao Will

    This underage child should be fed to Arrington’s imaginary stalker. This underage child should be strapped to the window of Arrington’s car so that the next time someone spits on Arrington from the street, the spit hits the child.

    This child should be punished in every way imaginable.

  • James

    Yes, he did just that. I don’t like the fact that Arrington goes along under the pretense of protecting the kid’s identify then all but spells out his name. Any one (especially the Tech Crunch crowd) can figure it out.

    Bribery is always wrong but he’s a kid. At that age, you should have some room to make mistakes and learn from it. This post will hurt a bright future.

  • http://www.techknots.com/mobiles Vikas SN

    Its good to know that Techcrunch maintains such high levels of transparency.

  • Arnav

    Daniel Brusilovsky (http://www.techcrunch.com/author/danielbru/) (deleted)

  • http://www.tweetfind.com tweetfind

    Yes! Hire Justine!

    A Top Video Blogger…plus hiring Justine will make reading Tech Crunch videos/posts easier on the eyes…..jk ;)

    Ruben

  • Ken Aston

    So it was Rocketbox? Good to know, now we can all avoid it.

  • http://www.fix-xbox360.com/ Xbox mania

    And he is just 15… way to go!

  • Etrigan

    TC didn’t ruin the kid’s career. The kid ruined the kid’s career. That’s like blaming the government for ruining Bernie Madoff’s career.

    Taking bribes for posts? This kid has a broken moral compass, and will end up in prison, mark my words.

    And it has nothing to do with his age. Honest, good kids shouldn’t be tarred with the same brush as this crook, or denied opportunities.

  • http://www.tweetfind.com tweetfind

    Agreed.

    Tech Crunch should hire Justine, but only if she leaves here iphone and uses a Droid. ;)

    R

  • http://www.fix-xbox360.com/ Xbox mania

    Attested!

  • Gus

    Wait a minute: bribery has two sides: the one who asks and the one who pays. The post clearly says that someone gave a laptop. OK, the kid is a kid and cannot be named, but the company who paid the bribe is ran by adults who should know better, as did the other (great) organization who whistle blowed the whole thing. Statistically, it is very unlikely that I’ll ever meet or do business with the kid, but there is a greater possibility that I’ll do business with those two companies one day, and I’d love to know which is the socially responsible one and which is the one will compromise its ethical standards in order to get a single blog post. If they exchange laptops for articles, try to imagine what else they might do in exchange for investors’ money, IP, partnerships, contracts etc. Notice that they did not proactively came out clear – as did TC and the whistleblower – but only disclosed the fact after enquired by TC, and probably after understanding the legal consequences they could face bc of their misbehavior.

  • Nite

    It indeed is Daniel. He himself mentioned it on Twitter, indirectly.
    It’s okay though. Young guy learnt a very valuable lesson at a young age.
    Instead of demonizing him, we should support him. Yes, he did something wrong, very wrong. Who hasn’t? WHO HASN’T? Not exactly the same thing. But almost everyone has done something wrong in his/her life. The point is: Are you willing to learn from it and move on?

  • Ryan

    I think its a real issue. While there are tremendously responsible “emerging adults” in the world, lets be honest, kids are kids, and they sometimes do really stupid things.

    And before the clueless start lobbing excuses, humanity has long protected kids from their own actions, as society recognizes that emerging adults shouldn’t be buried for life by the stupid things they do as minors.

  • jose

    He will go places!!

  • http://nikolay.com Nikolay Kolev

    Yes, of course. All posts got deleted.

  • http://www.imalonelybird.com Kyle

    seriously? Lol, what connection did this kid have? You should consider collegiate children.

  • Ryan

    Kids need supervision. TC has an obligation to provide the proper guidance. Do you give a high school aged boy the keys to a liquor store and not expect him to throw a massive party?

  • youngluck

    Correction: Kid Ruined Kids career. It’s like being a bat boy and then asking another team for money or shwag to rub Pine tar on a players glove.

  • http://www.niyati.biz Ramesh Nair

    Mike, why don’t you then reveal the startups who bribed the intern with computers? Are they too not legally adult?

  • Alx Klive

    “If you separate a hungry child from an Apple orchard with a low-wall, he’ll climb the wall”.

    This is a really difficult one Mike and I don’t envy your choices. I had the pleasure to meet the young man in question and saw him as an extremely bright lad with an exciting future ahead of him. He’s obviously betrayed your trust, and made a mistake he’ll regret for the rest of his life. But the tough question is raised… should interns be writing stories on Techcrunch.com?

    In old media, interns were and still are widely used. Generally speaking however, ‘in the old days’, they weren’t allowed to write high profile pieces. Maybe they did fact-checking, maybe they did research, maybe they went along on interviews, maybe they wrote the lesser trafficked portions of a publication, but always with the oversight of an experienced Editor. On Techcrunch.com, every story is a high profile story, with huge exposure for the startups profiled. The intern in question knew this, and exploited it. Was he being exploited in return, is a tough question to stomach, but it’s a valid question to ask, that needs some soul searching and reflection.

    In terms of how it was handled, it’s hard to say what’s right and what’s wrong. As I said, I don’t envy your choices. You’ve certainly covered yourself with your readers, and transparency is applauded these days. But was that the easy option? Inevitably in doing so his identity, as a minor, has been revealed. It sounds like this all happened very quickly (I could be wrong) and I wonder if taking a week or two to reflect on things (maybe you did do this) might have led to a different conclusion. Perhaps with effort and guidance the ‘good’ stories could have been separated from the ‘bad’ with his ‘assistance’. He could thus have been let go quietly, with some covering excuse if even needed, one or a few posts deleted, and likely none would have been the wiser. He may not have learned such a harsh lesson, but perhaps the lesson… is too harsh.

  • http://www.joshrath.com Josh Rath

    Arrington, quit being a chicken and actually say the name of the person in question. Your so called lawyers told you to not say the name, because they are underage… which I can understand, but damn man. You made it pretty obvious. “We also think that, given the intern’s age, it may not be appropriate to make their identity public.” “…the intern was terminated.”

    So how hard was it to figure out? Not at all. Just a simple guess. My suggestion? Remove everything that even points to the person, because if you have it there, you might as well just say the damned name.

  • Damon

    I’m sorry to hear that this happened to you. I think you’ve handled it appropriately and I will continue to read, and trust, what you have to say. Thanks.

  • James

    This is a completely self righteous post from Arrington. I hate the pretense of protecting the kid’s identity and taking the high ground of transparency. Most people (especially the Tech crowd) can figure out who it is within a minute. This post is meant to punish and publicly shame a young kid.

    Bribery is wrong and ruins the integrity of journalism; agreed. The kid should be reprimanded to full extent within his inner circle, by those responsible for him. However, please keep in mind that he is a minor. A teenager trying to deal with temptations that even adults have a hard time controlling. Kids make mistakes; that’s how they learn.

    This issue should have never been discussed in such detail publicly. I hope the kid learns from this and is able to move on; he is bright and ahead of his time. This was an irresponsible and malintentioned post. Shame on you, Mr. Arrington.

  • youngluck

    Slick… I like how you just announced your availability for a position you know is now open, while simultaneously displaying a fair knowledge for the law and further supporting how easy it is to find out who your competition was. Well done son.

  • youngluck

    Huh? The Air is kick ass. The price is not.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/J_Paul_Armstrong/1384696030 J Paul Armstrong

    Definition of as tool: Any adult who would use fgoogle cache to discewrn the intern’s identity .

  • Allison

    TC did what they had to do. If a writer steals staplers from the supply closet, it’s an internal matter. If a writer asks for kickbacks for coverage, the issue then becomes one of trust with the industry an outlet covers, and most importantly one of credibility with readers.

    No one likes this (except the trolls).

  • Beesley

    His name is Daniel Brusilovsky. Looked it up through googles cache. Douchenozzle.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/lvirs_Salmanov/500546796 еlvirs Salmanov

    I would love to intern for Techcrunch, for free:) and I promise I would never write about Apple. I would be like the opposite of MG:)

  • youngluck

    That dude has way too much shwag for a 17 year old.

  • DanielBru Alerts

    You should follow @danielbrualerts at http://danielbrualerts.weebly.com for up to date news.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Like I said down there: “Ya’ll are missing the point. It’s not the who, what, when, where, or why. It’s about HOW it was handled.

    Maaan what’s wrong with you people?”

  • slick rick

    True.

    On the flip side of the coin, wall street is alive and kicking. I’ve known internship offers that came with iPods and monetary rewards for signing … not a signing bonus for a full time job, but a signing bonus for an internship! Furthermore, some hedge funds pay 25K for 10 week summer internships, and investment banks pay anywhere from 12K to 20K for their summer interns.

    Our economy works in strange ways doesn’t it…

  • http://boys.efrenefren.com efrenefren

    you people forget that you were naughty little kids once.

  • John

    Well, not really. By mentioning that his posts were deleted. Everyone can find out who he is from google cache. I just did.

  • Big John

    “When it became clear yesterday that there was no question that this person had requested, and in one case taken, compensation for a post, the intern was terminated.”

    Isn’t that a little extreme? You didn’t have to kill the guy, just ask him to leave. Sheesh, TC doesn’t play around.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jolie_ODell/1562170236 Jolie O’Dell

    Jesus. This is absolutely shocking.

    I liked the kid a lot. I liked his work ethic, how careful he was in how he presented himself, his intelligence, his enthusiasm, his potential.

    And the fact that this came down to a friggin’ laptop is a real head-scratcher. If he’d needed one for blogging purposes, there’s no doubt in my mind Mike would’ve made sure he had it. But knowing what his home computing setup is like, I am certain that “need” wasn’t part of the equation.

    This seems so out of character from what I know of him. I really hope it doesn’t ruin the rest of his career, and I hope he learns a valuable lesson.

    When I think about all the dumb, dumb shit I did at his age (and for the decade or so that followed), I’m optimistic that he’ll get a second shot. I just hope he’s got his honesty & ethics issues sorted out by the time that chance rolls around.

    In the end, I’m sorry you guys got burned. I’m chalking this up as a big WTF.

  • cbrown

    Right way to handle this?!?? Are you fucking kidding me? This is irresponsible and poor journalism in the guise of altruism. TC has not come clean here. They are hiding both the identity of the author, but more importantly the biases in their reporting. Neither is responsible journalism. As an editor, the responsibility is to report the problem to the readers rather than hide it in the closet. This is taught in high school journalism and is not expected from TC.

    Arrington, as editor, I don’t envy your job. But you have to stop being a pussy. Either you stand bye your investigation and admit they error. The NY Times has done this in the recent past with falsified stories. Or, you investigate and dismiss the claims. What is completely unacceptable is the action that you have taken. You have deleted content and rewritten history without telling the readers what was wrong or biased.

    This is responsible, how?!?? Arrington, your responsiblity is to your readers first. Please don’t forget this.

  • john

    um, what’s the big deal, there’s no such thing as journalistic integrity these days anyway. Esp with tech writers, where is the line drawn. I would be interested to see if any of the Techcrunch writers had ever had a free dinner or beer bought for them by the companies they write about. I’m sure they all have. So get off your high horse Arlington, the kids probably just learning from the pro’s

  • http://techcrunchies.com Anand Srinivasan

    Ahw..I had seen quite a few posts from him, so imagined he was good enough to be full time!

  • http://studioglu.com glu

    the bloggers alliance demands to be taken seriously

  • jon

    I think you should put the posts up somewhere – it might be useful study material in blogging ethics going forward

  • http://michaelcummings.info Michael Cummings

    Sadly, I know this person personally, and it sucks that his reputation is going to be ruined for some time over this, but the fact of the matter is it is just wrong for him to have done this.

    It de-legitimizes the real journalism even if no other articles written were “tainted”, because you’ll always in your mind be asking the question “did this writer get paid or get a gift to write this?”

    I hope he apologizes publicly for his actions soon so he can move on from this, because its going to be a long road to build the reputation back up that he has been graced with for so long…

  • Mulligan

    “When it became clear yesterday that there was no question that this person had requested, and in one case taken, compensation for a post, the intern was terminated.”

    Terminated…..with extreme prejudice?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike_Geer/12816460 Mike Geer

    Hmm, yeah, Michael, as you of all people should know, by deleting all stories from this intern, you have given away his/her identity. It took 30 seconds on google to find them and their blog.

    Legally, you are, of course, covered, but best not to claim that you are protecting their identity.

    Although, I still pretty much believe in the ol’ “all publicity is good publicity”, so I’m sure he/she will prosper from this new found fame.

  • deno

    Siegler should be investigated as well! Or at least put in rehab to induce some kind of unbiasedness :D

  • youngluck

    Nice try, Daniel.

  • http://rebell.tv /sms ;-)

    he can’t affort a macbook air? whats going wrong with TC?

  • Johny Miric

    In the way how you are handling this kind of cases lies the reason why Tech Crunch is such great, trusty and very well established tech blog.

    When goals are clear than dealing with any kind of heavy situation is easy, and it seems that goals at TC are very clear.

  • http://christophermahan.com/ Christopher Mahan

    While I think the individual in question knew better, I think there is a certain amount of fault going to whoever was this person’s manager.

    There was a clear ethics violation, as an individual, an employee (intern or not–he was producing) and as as a journalist.

    Yet, this person is young enough that his manager/mentor should have emphasized the ethical aspect of behavior in an adult world, especially because of his activities in a public forum such as he was.

    It was not fair to assume that this person was mature enough to understand what many people don’t get until college (or later) and it was not fair to blame this person in the way he was.

    My attitude is that everything that happens at a company is management’s fault, and I see very little contrition from Michael Arrington regarding the collective failure of leadership.

    I think things could have been handled differently, in a way that would not only benefit TechCrunch but also the individual.

    I certainly hope that he will be able to move on past this and file the whole episode under “lesson learned”.

    To those who publicize this individual’s name, and while I am not a lawyer, I would caution that you may run afoul of California law AB 86. Do your homework.

    To this individual: if you feel unduly harrassed or otherwise pressured, please don’t feel the world is against you just because a few hot-heads don’t know how to act properly. Don’t hesitate to use legal means to defend yourself, and notify authorities immediately if you feel threatened.

  • techcrunch affected

    Daniel Brusilovsky worked his connections like a master swindler.

    This is going to seriously affect Arrington – TechCrunch’s credibility is on the line here.

    People will think, if a teenager can do this, then what are the adults capable of?

  • http://BigSquidMedia.com Mike Greco

    Thanks for handling it so well. I still trust you.

  • Jack

    I heard that it was Robert Scobles son. Such a sad story…

  • http://www.greenstreet.net PaulH

    Plenty of comment on the intern and Mike’s handling of the situation, but what about the startup(s) that gave the gifts in return for posts? If you was a startup and an intern asked you to grease his palms in return for a blog post on TC, would you?

  • robrob

    kids aren’t just kids, I had the concept of taking money in exchange for doing something immoral was the wrong thing to do and would probably get me fired. We protect kids, however we’re not talking a 9 year old here, this would have been someone legally old enough to work, we’re probably looking at 16-17. Mike only mentioned a legal adult, I doubt this person would have suddenly gained a mass of maturity in the next couple of years to not do this.

    The thing is, what they did might not be frowned upon at every tech site. Techcrunch has always upheld quite a high standard, something better than a lot of places. A few sites disclose when they received something relating to their articles (I know Ars discusses this quite openly as well), but there are many that don’t, it’s seen as part of it all, extra payment for their hard work that often doesn’t have much in the way of rewards.

  • http://www.lazysupper.com lazysupper

    he made a statement and apologized on his blog: http://www.danielbru.com/2010/02/the-line-was-crossed/

  • Carlo

    Daniel posted a non-admission half-ass apology to his blog: http://www.danielbru.com/

  • anon 2

    People still video blog?

  • http://www.growvc.com valto

    Daniel Brusilovsky: Apology To TechCrunch and others http://www.danielbru.com/2010/02/the-line-was-crossed/

  • http://tim.rocketry.org Tim

    He’s a kid, should have been supervised like a kid, and not given the trust a grown man and professional would receive while working for Tech Crunch. :(

    I appreciate your owning up to this and how you’ve handled it. You’re okay, Mike.

  • Chieze Okoye

    Yes because the kid taking bribes for coverage has nothing to do with ruining his career. It’s TC revealing that he did it. You’re totally right.

  • yeah

    well as much as we razz them i like the tc crew. they work hard and they work fast and unlike endadget they haven’t disabled their comments so they put up with us and all our harping, craziness, and love/appreciate/dissatisfaction. anyways when i first saw this post (was reading some other things and watching vids so i couldn’t read this one earlier) and it was at 3 comments (i bet it hit the twitter fast though…and it looks like it did) and had only skimmed the first couple lines i was like please don’t let it be dbru…and unbeknownst to me it is. this sucks for him. i remember reading one of his or was it leena who wrote the post and gave kudos to him, anyways i was reading a post about some new start up thing that was endorsed by teens in tech and some person (or people. i don’t know who hates him or his friends) were spamming the post with accusations about the kid and his friends doing some underhand things/shady business. i just thought the spammer dude was crazy and had some personal agenda to settle with the kid. oh well. sucks all around still.

  • anon 2

    No one will care in a week. Its not as if he slept with 13 women despite being married and having kids. I’m not scared to say it; but I’m over being concerned about Tiger. Get him back on the course, I miss him.

    At the end of the day, this is how the world operates. Everyone is given gifts at some point. Say sorry, move on. He’s young, get over it – no need to drag him over the coals.

  • dasein

    Michael, we deserve to know who gave the “gift” to get coverage. I don’t want to be their customer.

  • http://migshouse.com miguel

    Good to see the openness of the situation & keeping the intern’s identity anonymous. Great work on this front in what could’ve been an easily sweep-under-the-rug situation. Kudos, TechCrunch!

    Sad to see folks have the need to divulge the person’s identity. Hoping this doesn’t taint how people view teens’ contributions to the tech space. Chances are said intern was approached with an offer first.

    Why isn’t anyone posting about the lack of ethics the bribing party/company displayed? Sounds a bit like the intern’s getting thrown under the bus as the scapegoat in this situation.

  • yeah

    seriously how could you?

  • Techcrunch Reader

    Brusilovsky still has the gall to not remove “writer at Techcrunch” in his twitter profile.

    Seems like he was going to speak at Macworld – if Apple does the right thing then they’ll cancel the request immediately..

  • GB

    All shaken… yeh right. let’s talk about ethic…

    Did you just mean it’s much more ethical to have someone hacking into Twitter’s employee database, get their biz plan and publish them whenever you’re losing traffic ? BS

    Just another kid you did not wanna pay

  • yeah

    they don’t have to tell you who it is. anyone with a brain can figure out who it was. i feel bad for the kid somehow and i’m usually black hearted. it’s a bad situation. i didn’t mind reading his posts on this website. the dude definately gave the kids perspective on tech. thanks dbru.

  • youngluck

    Dad?

  • yeah

    lol see that wasn’t heard was it. i initially just guessed who it was…then hit the google looking for previous tc posts and i got my answer. even if his identity is disclosed i think people know who it is and also just read his blog. the kid’s a good kid. something happened. it doesn’t negate what happened, but it doesn’t entirely define him you know.

  • Corazal

    ok, the kid was underage. But what about the startup that bribed him…can’t you name and shame them??????
    Come on man, if you don’t, someone else will. Just a matter of time. And don’t give that line that they didn’t know it was a bribe. It sure wasn’t a shakedown, or was it?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Luca_Filigheddu/581740285 Luca Filigheddu

    I think he’s not happy about what happened and is learning a lot about this.

    On the contrary, if I were you, I would publicly reveal the identity of the startup that gave him the Air.

  • youngluck

    Tits alone validate 95.7% of your last statement.

  • http://www.twitter.com/matkem Matt

    This was just plain wrong in so many ways.

    Daniel knew what he was doing and I’m glad he didn’t get away with it.

  • yeah

    lol. i was going to ask so does this mean there’s a new intern slot at tc, cause i would like to apply, and then i thought better of it. we can’t resist human nature. some of us are just cunty.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Luca_Filigheddu/581740285 Luca Filigheddu

    very good point. Guys, please reveal the name of that startup.

  • http://gundy.org Gabriel Gunderson

    Is there anyway I can get my Droid and my 17-inch MacBook Pro back now? :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mona_Nomura/600746494 Mona Nomura

    Chieze, this was a lose-lose situation. Imagine if it reached the public, before it was addressed by Mike — what would your reaction be?

    Think about that.

  • yeah

    you can’t get any takebacks. some internships are also work studies where you get paid honarariums w.e that’s called/spelled, and uhm what else an expense fee to cover for travel and maybe even food if you’re lucky. while some will pay you a basic wage for a couple hours work and the rest you get hours for volunteering so if your school has one of those 40 hours volunteer through your school year(s) type of program to graduate, you can apply your hours to that. some schools allow you to do certain internships you can get credit(s) for. i was looking on the hrw site today for internships/paid work studies. it’s nice their site isn’t crap and everything is clearly laid out and explained.

  • yeah

    yupp.

  • http://i2h.com Neal

    Stop cheaping out, and hire an adult next time. And pay enough.

  • yeah

    lol. as if age has anything to do with it. ha. i know of more grizzled journo’s who do this and getting caught never phases them. they see it like it’s some sort of perk that comes with the job and that it’s not a conflict of interest(s) at all. hilarious.

  • Matt

    Indeed.

  • Eduardo

    Who took the bribe is now clear.
    What is not clear is who gave the bribe. Should we assume that every company he posted about bribed him?

  • jon

    People, this is a straight question of ethics. Youthfulness or age has nothing to do with it.

  • Vetinary

    WHAT?? “the intern was terminated”

    WHAT DID YOU DO TO HIM??

  • http://www.workingpinoy.com Naya

    I’ve read the teenager’s explanations on his blog, and although there’s no excuse for what he’s done, it’s still admirable that he didn’t make any justification, that he didn’t blame anyone, that he’s repairing relationships and that he’s learning and moving on.

  • yeah

    he’s divulding the obvious. it’s nice of the man to disclose the kids name but anyone who reads tc, cg, etc…anyone who probably comments on this website and knows how to use a search function figured this out really quick.

  • yeah

    hahah but she’s also funny. being funny is a big plus anywhere, even in hell.

  • Real Life

    Or you haven’t experienced real life.

  • http://masht.ag Antone Johnson

    I am saddened by the whole affair. People make mistakes, actions have consequences, and hopefully this will be a valuable learning experience that “builds character” in the long run.

    This is a matter of law, not just ethics. From my perspective as a lawyer, I’d like to emphasize what others noted above, that as of December 2009 it is illegal per FTC regulations for a blogger to be paid (in cash or in-kind) for endorsements or testimonials, which include blog posts about a product or company. His unlawful actions exposed TC to liability and risked tainting the whole organization with a government investigation. TC also did the prudent thing by taking down all of the posts rather than going through and rewriting or editing them; in the event of any litigation, it’s best not to compound the problem by creating even more evidence. Just my two cents.

  • yeah

    well since you’re the only one i see from all the comments so far taking this perspective (and i agree with the majority of the commenters), i’m kinda on the fence with this. i am not really surprised by this, not to say anything about daniel, but it’s just hard in general to be a journalist especially a tech journalist and not take takebacks from sources. temptation is there for us all you know and he had some moments of lapse. i think tc has a responsibility to inform the readers yeah, cause many of us have read the kids posts and might now be second guessing the kid and tc. he did it. it’s not the best thing. it’s definately a bad thing to be doing and to have it be so public like this, but i’m not sure who to blame here…or if i just want to point fingures and say fuck x, y, z person you know. it’s just an unfortunate situation. he knows he made a mistake and he wrote that in his blog. everyone could have used google casche or search to figure out who it was or guess who it was.

  • Evolution

    This is actually a very good thing for Techcrunch, in your development as a news organization.

    For years, “bloggers” have worn that term as a badge of honor, in that they aren’t “journalists,” free to speak their minds and tell things as they really are. Freed from any stated requirement of objectivity, the credibility standard basically boils down to personal responsibility, in that you hope that “bloggers” aren’t willing to succumb to temptation once they are considered to be influencers by Corporate America.

    That doesn’t work. People are people. And that’s why journalistic standards arose over decades, to protect information consumers from the corruption that can take place in information production.

    You’ve (hopefully) learned a hard lesson here. Sure, he was just an intern, but why should you assume this couldn’t happen to anyone else on your staff unless you start demanding more objectivity of them?

    Karma is a bitch. Hopefully we’ll move past the early 20th century version of tech journalism one of these days.

  • wendy

    i think this was very well handled on your part. had it been my blog, i may not have been as forgiving.

    however, i would have liked to know what company/ies offered to pay for posts.

    hang them out, and let the crows feast!

  • yeah

    divulding=divulging…or dibulging (makes you think of 8==D~.)

  • Charlie

    Funny how he manages to squeeze a link to his conference into his ‘apology’ post.

  • MonkeyDance

    Probably as a intern he was getting paid peanuts / nothing.

    As such you can’t blame him for wanting to afford things that a normal job would provide… hence taking any opportunity that arises!

  • yeah

    lol. you’re not the only one thinking that. life happens. mistakes get made, yes even over apple products. gah.

  • yeah

    but like some commenters said, taking away his posts is also a clear self identifier is it not? even if arrington did the right thing by disclosing the intern’s name, which is the right thing to do…and also maybe taking off the posts which is at the center of this which is also the right thing to do, tc commenters, although we might post stupid things, are not stupid. and some people aren’t even surprised by this (lol the kid’s haters). it’s just a sad state of affairs. he’s a kid. but it happens to adults too. it has nothing to do with age really. i think the post is as good as it can be in the time it was posted. maybe this could have been dealt with (this post to pacify/inform us readers) another way.

  • http://justinleung.net Justin L.

    I wrote my thoughts on this on my blog. http://bit.ly/aw1M2K

  • Dave Hanna

    Done with class Michael- kids learn by mistakes.

    However, who was the company that did have ‘adults’ that gave the teen the goodies in exchange for a write up?

    They are just as culpable

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/David_A_Segura/2902695 David A. Segura

    Typical silliness from Mike A. Drop the holier than though pretense and disclose the ‘tainted’ articles rather than deleting them. That’s the real issue here. Kids will be kids.

    Spare me.

  • yeah

    give him a break. he’ll get around to it, or simply say he used to write at tc (lol. not a good idea because if people google they will come up with this post).

  • Vincent

    if the Newspaper business is going to die and be replaced by Free blogs with teenager writing about things they don’t know and take money for it…then I think the “news” industry is going the wrong way all together

  • http://techcrunchies.com Anand Srinivasan

    Now that the identity of the intern is revealed, I guess TC should reveal the names of those companies who paid him.

    All other companies who got reviewed by Daniel are now going to be needlessly suspected of bribing journos for positive reviews. That’s going to be difficult to many..

  • Mark

    It’s an intern, and he is there to learn. In order to learn you have to make mistakes. I would have discussed this with him and given him a second chance. TC would probably have gotten a very loyal intern if they did that.
    BTW was he told in the beginning what your expectations where?

  • MJ

    It does raise the question if the system at TechCrunch will ensure that no posts in the future will be ‘tainted’ again.

    There must been a failure somewhere to let this happen. There are some question that aren’t answered:
    for how long has this been going on ‘compensation of monetary value for articles’ by this author?

    Did he write all the articles or where they written by others?

    How much control did the ‘sponsors’ have over the content of the articles?

    Is he the only one to accept gifts?

    What changes will there be at TechCrunch to ensure that this will not be happening again?

  • yeah

    alright post.

    keep your chin up kid. work hard and this will pass you by.

    i don’t know whether to applaude the finker or say what a damn narc…and as for tc’s responsibility in this, where are the self checks in your system. someone had to tell on your own kid whom you trusted, and whom you’re trying to get his side of the what happened? i agree with taking down the posts, but as one commenter posted, this implicates tc and doesn’t reflect well on his previous posts.

  • yeah

    this

  • http://blogit.hs.fi/piilaakso/2010/02/05/mika-on-oikein-bloggaaja/ Mitä uutta Piilaaksossa?

    Mikä on oikein, bloggaaja?…

    Skandaali: Maailman johtavan teknologiablogin TechCrunchin harjoittelija oli saanut  blogipostauksestaan vastineeksi tietokoneen. Lahja tuli yritykseltä, josta postaus kertoi. Hän oli myös pyytänyt toiselta yritykseltä MacBook Airia vastineeksi postauk…

  • yeah

    hard

  • Ken Aston

    Agree. He should have been given a chance to write a post to apologize and resign by himself.

    You can’t deny that indirect compensation in various forms, and if nothing else than at least personal (e.g. financial) interests, play a role in many posts.

    You indirectly revealed his name and denounced him. Considering it’s a kid I can’t applaud you for this. Openness and giving him a lesson could have been achieved without overly damaging his future opportunities.

  • what next

    First partnering with shady offshore firms. Now child labor. What next TC, hookers and blow?

  • http://www.frmask.net TrGuard

    I think you just need a good old fashioned video blogger in the mix.

    http://www.FrmaSk.net Forum Pages

  • http://www.cheapcheapcheap.com Albert

    SO much corruption. I respect TC and their honesty and integrity. This is why I read it :)

  • http://thecampdirector.com Jennifer H. Selke

    Smart teenagers like Daniel are wonderfully competent yet not immune to judgment lapses that plague the still developing teen brain. New research into the teen brain has found the frontal lobe is still developing into early adulthood. The frontal lobe helps the brain reason and make good decisions across various circumstances. It is not an excuse, simply a reminder that we have to be careful over promoting smart, responsible kids who are still learning and growing. As a summer camp director, I supervise over 100 young people each summer. Their mistakes have life-threatening consequences. Like Michael, I have been disappointed by the actions of some of my young staff and am always questioning if I let them down by giving them responsibility they were not yet ready for. Sometimes a mistake is a mistake and other times it is the result of over-promotion. I wish Daniel well. As those of us who have made it to adulthood know, it is not the mistake that matters as much as how you deal with it once it happens. We all also know that if this is the worse thing that happens in his life, he will die a lucky man.

    (I am so passionate about this topic that I wrote a post on my own blog if you want to read more about supervising teens.)

  • http://www.leebandoni.com Lee Bandoni

    This guy has simply been caught up in an “adult” world where this sort of stuff goes on every day. I’m sure half the readers on he blog would have done the same thing at 17 simply because they could.

    This guy looks like he could be a big player in the future so lets not write him off just yet!

  • paul

    Michael,

    Thanks for your honesty in divulging this with your readers – it’s very much appreciated. My guess is that he’ll be easily replaced with more eager and less greedy contributors.

    Paul.

  • http://www.startuppal.com Dimitar

    +1 for the transparancy. That’s one of the reasons why TC is so popular.
    As for Daniel, he’s still very young and has a lot to learn. Everybody makes mistakes and he learned a lesson this week. + 1 for him also – for publicly disclosing this in his blog.

  • http://itsnotvalid.com itsnotvalid

    Who’s making things like this?

  • TGF

    I agree. MA is getting publicity from what should be dealt with mainly internally . And for gods sake, he’s just a kid who’s learning to hustle in a world full of self serving corporate crooks.

  • http://itsnotvalid.com itsnotvalid

    I think cbrown is talking about WHICH post was the post that got compensation on, however I am unsure if disclosing this would be legal or not.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ken_Oporto/501766756 Ken Oporto
  • Anonymous

    You terminated an employee? Damn, that is firm but fair.

  • Suman

    pretty brutal but he ought to know better

    his blog post was almost retarded

  • christina thompson

    Why are you letting interns write for your blog

  • http://smallworldnews.tv BaghdadBrian

    Why would you delete all his posts? That is not transparent at all. It would be better to keep them and let people know where the bias existed.

    By deleting his posts you make it impossible for your readers to sift through where TechCrunch misled them and where it did not.

    Just my two cents, I think you should own up to your mistakes and acknowledge the bad content indefinitely.

  • PHP 4 lyfe

    Who is this kid? Just a couple weeks ago TC is covering that his startup acquired another company that was covered on TC

    http://www.techcrunch.com/2010/01/20/teens-in-tech-acquires-yazzem-redesign/

    He’s FB friends with some heavy hitters too. Who the hell is he? Has to be connected through his family somewhere.

  • http://nbrightside.com/blog/ Andy C

    I think there’s a significant difference between a disreputable company offering inducements which are then accepted by a naive, immature teenager and a teenager initiating the process and asking for a MacPro.

    Nor is age an excuse. I have a teenage son who knows right from wrong. This lad clearly doesn’t and never will.

    He and his parents should hang their heads in shame.

  • http://www.blogadmonkey.com/blog Dragan Mestrovic

    @Michael this is very sad!

    Not only Daniels behaviour is questionable but as well the behaviour of the company who has bribed him!

    He is a teen and is falling into the trap, but the guys who bribed him, I am sure are not teenagers and should be disclosed here to learn about such a company and culture which has bribing on there list of core values…

    I am sure there is much more potential for discussion here about this point in the future!

  • Will

    Cummings… ha ha :p

  • anon 3

    “the intern was terminated” made me chuckle.

  • http://popurls.com/pop === popurls.com === popular today

    === popurls.com === popular today…

    yeah! this story has entered the popular today section on popurls.com…

  • Peter M

    I am an avid reader of *Crunch, and I’ve seen some very questionable posts in the past – such as this one below, which seems to be planted and filled with with search engine friendly phrases.

    http://www.mobilecrunch.com/2009/07/14/sightmax-brings-live-chat-customer-service-to-the-iphone/

    It goes into little actual thorough detail about the product in a real test environment, too. I can’t imagine it being useful to many readers.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Satyajit_Sahu/833653150 Satyajit Sahu

    Poor posts! Why did they have to face E.of.Life? Couldn’t you change the username to a little skull and still leave the posts there?
    Think of the companies or products he wrote about. Poor guys lost their TC mention??

  • http://www.bloggeradda.com Mike Skel

    Best comment on comment!

  • Koomo

    That’s why I keep on coming back here…thanx

  • Rick Hard

    Was the intern fired or actually “terminated”?

    To be honest I think Tech Crunch should have been more aware of the intern’s cummings and goings.

  • Grotbags

    Kid wants free gear. Kid gets caught out, gets fired. Jesus, anyone would think by the tone of this ‘story’, the North Koreans had stormed Seoul.

  • Toot

    Lose the false piety, people. This stuff happens everyday at press releases and in newsroom around the world. The only mistake this kid made was getting caught.

    Dragging him over the coles makes you look like the hypocrites you most likely are.

  • http://blog.samuraiprojects.com/index.php Justin

    TechCrunch Posts Details of Fired Intern’s Mistake, and That’s a Mistake:

    http://blog.samuraiprojects.com/archives/techcrunch-posts-details-of-fired-interns-mistake-and-thats-a-mistake.php

  • John

    ..well, all I have to say is “Mike, you best be squeeky clean for eternity” You seem to be the holier than thou character. Paid you taxes, cheated on your wife….?? I’m sure that you arent the perfect person. Shit happens in companies. We dont need to know your internal workings. The only reason that you posted this is that you were scared that somebody would find out and ask you why you hushed it up. Put a young kids future on the bon fire….thats integrity. Possibly, in future, create some more structures in your organisation that will prevent things like this from happening. Write the stories, get us the info, sell your advertising and enough of the self indulgent look at me i’m so special bullshit.

  • Boro

    You are all missing the point!! It’s because of a MacBook! It’s Apple’s fault!
    That company has to be destroyed – they corrupt the young souls of our society.
    No one would ask for a gray can as a compensation for an article…
    Apple = Devil!! 666!

  • Joe P.

    yep, this is a pointless post from Michael. If this happened in my company, I’d fire the guy and definitely NOT make a post about it on my blog.

    There is zero reason why Michael needs to post to the world about how he is so perfect, the kid screwed up, he got fired, end of story.

    Removing all his old posts is beyond overkill and just selfish.

    +1 for TC yet again :P

  • Alex Walsh

    I hope you terminated the internship and not the intern- that’s murder in my book and probably a little harsh for a first offence.

  • http://rcanblog.com Aashish

    He already published a blog post at
    http://www.danielbru.com/

  • http://www.iyogi.net Daina Thomas

    I wont call it complete transparency … it still has more to it .. you wanted to keep “his” identity under covers .. but you yourself revealed it.. who it was by mentioning that “all his posts are removed or deleted”… for once his mistake can be overlooked .. as he is a kid .. and you have taken a right step by terminating him ..

    But the major thing is who bribed the kid .. which company it was .. it cant be overlooked .. they are adults and they know what they were doing … the company’s name should be disclosed …. and general ppl should know it … he was a kid .. common ,,… if you show a chocolate to small kid .. wont he come closer to you to take it .. common you know it ..

    I feel the company’s name should be disclosed … and readers are quite smart .. they have already know who the kid is …

    Best,
    Daina

  • henrooo

    Since ‘Transparency” is being mentioned now the intern has been named, it is only fair you name & shame the company who provided your intern with the Macbook.

    The adult (I’m assuming) who decided to give you intern a macbook needs to be called out too, it is only fair.

    Nonetheless, I’m glad everything is out in the open. However, it would have been better if the focus would have been put on the ‘adult’ who agreed to exchange a Macbook for a Techcrunch post, rather than put all the attention and focus on an intern who’s a minor.

    I’m not trying to divert responsibility away from the intern either, but if we are going to be ‘transparent’, lets see the whole picture. So I kindly request you post the name of the company(s) who agreed to exchange a Macbook for posts. Now that would be Transparent.

  • http://o6uoq.com David Symons

    Hi,

    Kids will be kids. As some people have mentioned in earlier posts, I think you should look at the adults from other companies that were offering gifts in exchange for blog posts (that is, if the kid didn’t ask for it to begin with).

    Shame that a kid with a bright future has lost his opportunity due to aggressive business men wanting to prop their startup.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Joe_Dawson/501760832 Joe Dawson

    Great transparency; John Terry and Tiger Woods should adopt the same approach and blog about their antics as that would be good to read!!

  • UnAmerican

    I think an (unpaid?) intern had too much temptation. Generally this is why companies pay people to work for them. Are things so bad at TC they need interns?

  • http://www.trinest.com Trent

    So essencialy what happend was, some little kid (proabably 15 – 17 ?) decided that he could write some articles for Techcrunch, okay thats fine, but then he decided “hey maybe if I get Startups to give me free shit when I talk about them- lol!” which then caused all this shit.

    This is why kids on the internet shouldn’t be trusted, in my youth (haahaa I’m over 18 now and I’m already talking down to people younger me- classic) I ran a few sites, wrote a few articles etc. but back then the only problem kid writers had where they’d write like shit/spell bad. Heck I still do, yeah occasionaly they’d try and riddle some free shit, but they would never get it and soon move on and just do it because they could.

  • T-F

    Seems like Michael is talks about MG Siegler.

  • http://mobilebytes.wordpress.com Fred Grott

    Here is the sad tihng..

    TC got the greatest amount f traffic when it detailed it sown failing in having processes set up to detect ethics issues such as this..

    Its a failure in hiring, its failure in training, and failure in recognizing that certain journalistic processes exist because we are not he 18th or 19th century where this type of ethics problems was a standard occurrence

    It was standard in the 18th and 19th centuries for new firms to muck rake in exchange of favors. And it was only the randomness of it sometimes being on the right side as far as exposing bigger problems that we even have the term..

    Either TC will start using some Journalist techniques or they will fade into the darkness..

  • Thomas

    I thought you are going to apologies for the fact that you are censoring critical comments from selective readers. Maybe you should investigate more instead rejecting everything that doesn´t match your subjective view.

  • Tim

    Time to look into some of the other really obvious shills?

    Your starter for ten: http://www.techcrunch.com/2010/02/02/israels-time-to-know-aims-to-revolutionize-the-classroom/

  • gro

    ruin a career for mac? fullish

  • Wrong

    He said the kid requested a Mac, not that he got one.

    Of course the kid will now trade-up this 15 minutes of fame into more $$ somehow.

  • http://www.appgiveaway.com Al

    You tell’em Mike. Cash for posts, NO THANK YOU. I get asked to publish posts on my website http://www.appgiveaway.com and I say NO!

  • http:.//phat1.com Slipdisc

    They ruined his career? Seriously?

    That’s like saying, putting criminals on trial isn’t fair because its ruining their future criminal career.

    All of the events that unfolded were of his own making. And everything else is just the fallout.

    Cheers to TC for putting the smackdown on him asap.

  • nick

    looks like he posted an apology at his website http://www.danielbru.com

  • JLH

    Maybe this kid wasn’t an intern.

    I believe this because of 2 simple reasons:

    1. Internships usually don’t last for 9 months.
    2. As stated before, interns do not public official content.

    Maybe it is just a good excuse for not getting blamed for the kid’s misbehaviour.

  • dan

    Daina, I am not a grammar nazi. In fact I have spent countless hours on the internet ridiculing and deriding their babbling perscriptive nonsense.

    That being said, your constant use of ellipsis makes you sound downright stoned. And it sort of weirds me out.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Diego_Sana/1524900721 Diego Sana

    Ouch. I had this same kind of problem in a former startup i co-founded, in another level though. A guy from Custommer Service Support asked some users (teenage girls!) to date them in exchange of get them highlighted in our homepage (it was a fotolog like service). The guy was just fired, but we should have handled the case to police. These situations are sad after all.

  • http://imcbrandmark.com JohnS37

    Could have been worse, much worse.
    He could have asked for a windows box.

  • Diego

    By the way, i just read Daniel`s post apologizing. He’s still young, have plenty of time to the things right. I even think it’s also a good thing that he learned this lesson early in this life.

  • JLH

    Sorry, sent it before finishing…

    Maybe this kid wasn’t an intern, but a regular TC writer. The intern stuff was just an excuse from TC for not to be blamed for his actions.

    I believe this for two simple reasons:

    1. Internships usually don’t last 9 weeks.
    2. Interns don’t publish official content.
    3. Probably you can only hire him as an intern and not as regular personnel.

    The problem is very different if the blogger was an intern than if it was a regular TC writer.

  • art vandelay
  • http://www.entrepranu.com Greg Harrison

    Congrats to the Kid for realizing it was a mistake, and hopefully growing from it. We all make mistakes and so long as you learn from them thats the best you can hope for.

  • Tim

    Ruin a career? Puh-lease.

    This isn’t the 1950s anymore. You don’t strive for a media job and then once you get it, work your way tirelessly over a forty year career until you eventually work for the WSJ. The old-school investigative journalism of Woodward and Bernstein is dead.

    It’s 2010. Old media is in turmoil, desperate to make a profit. It’s the generation of the “portfolio” career, where few people work for the same company for longer than 5 years. It’s the age of the celebrity where talent doesn’t matter, so much as publicity. It’s an age where there are so many blogs publishing information on the internet, you can publish stories on the most widely known ones before you even hit 18.

    This kid is now a celebrity. He’s probably getting a ghost writer to pen his biography already and hiring a publicist to book him onto daytime tv so he can talk about the bribery in the press. He’ll be richer than most of us within twelve months.

    If TC didn’t want to give him a golden handshake during his farewell, they would have simply fired him and moved on.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Arsen_Ghazaryan/540510704 Arsen Ghazaryan

    I am truly happy that you guys are keeping TechCrunch as transparent as possible.

    I have an good idea for you.
    Why you guys are not creating some kind of hub for startups. The idea is simple: the startups will submit their propfiles and based on user ratings and some other activity you will decide which one to profile on techcrunch.

    I am pretty sure that 90% of all US based startups are submitting their information to you, in this case it will much more easier for you to profile only the good ones.

    P.S.
    We have submitted several our products to you for review but non of them got Techcrunched :)

  • rajesh

    since the name is public, can we get the posts back? i want to read them now

  • http://www.satellitetv-news.com/ David

    This guy accepted his mistake.

  • John

    I made a bad mistake at his age. It looks like he took it to heart as I did. In the end it was a good experience and I made myself a better person.

  • marvin

    Never mind the teenager – who paid the bribes?

  • http://benkoo.com Ben Koo

    He’s connected to Scoble and Le Muer. Its odd that Mike and those guys really let this kid do so much.

    I thought it was maybe his parents were heavy hitters in the valley, but that turned out to not be the case.

    http://benkoo.com/articles/biz-and-tech/who-is-daniel-brusilovsky.html

  • Idgarad

    Why do you have children working for you? I think your due for a child labor investigation.

  • kurt

    wow. did not know there were teenagers working on this blog

  • http://techcrunchies.com Anand Srinivasan

    The kid will get over it someday. But companies that he wrote about are the ones feeling the heat. Unless TC reveals the companies that paid the boy, all other companies are going to be suspected of bribing journos for positive reviews,

  • http://www.extendance.com Ralf Haller

    First of all the credit goes to TC for airing this case and putting things straight.
    Unfortunately there remain many black sheeps out there.
    In Europe I have seen two drastic cases and one of them is quite unbelievable since they are making a business out of it, not kidding. Take a look at http://www.trigami.ch
    Their business is rocking as I was told, selling to clueless SMEs in Switzerland social media service package. In the center of it is a network of 10k paid bloggers that will write about your products & services.
    The other case was Vodafone in German who also paid bloggers in a large marketing campaign: http://pr.blog.extendance.com/2009/08/03/vodafone-deutschland-misses-the-point-of-online-marketing

  • Peter

    It’s George Bush’s fault

  • http://www.chriskellett.com Chris Kellett

    We you say they were terminated are we talking their employment or literally terminated.

  • http://www.qxdesigns.net Jeff

    You’re telling me that TechCrunch writers aren’t indirectly getting money from companies that they plug via this blog? I find that hard to believe, where’s the revenue coming from?

  • http://www.socialmediamarketing.org brian benko

    Michael Arrington and Management is to blame. Not the kid.

    Products get dropped in Michael’s Lap all the time for free…..

    Shitty decision on the part of Michael Arrington.

  • José Luis Campanello

    Great: that you spoke. It goes to your credibility. Then some newspapers wonder why they are loosing readers….

    Not Great: that you removed all the posts. Some companies/products Techcrunch are being punished by something they didn’t do or agreed to do. And what about RSS? Are those removed too? If i search in the GReader will i find these posts? I think you should update those posts with a link to this one and let the reader decide. Or give each company the choice. Some are probable startups nobody new unless by a post in TechCrunch.

  • ralphwiggummm

    This is why we should never confuse bloggers with journalists.

  • http://www.extendance.com Ralf Haller

    I hope and think it is ads and events, but who knows what else…

  • Mike

    I am certain that when I was a kid, I never would have asked for kickbacks. This kid had a personality flaw and was rightfully sacked for it.

  • igniman

    the obvious thing to say is “a macbook air????”

    anyway, too many comments. Have we figured out which company it was?

  • http://azitravel.com/blog Taige Zhang

    are you sure they would ask for an Air???????

  • http://www.jonaHgrant.com Jonah Grant

    You have to be kidding me…

  • Tostada-man

    Can we FREAKIN’ know what were the topics that were tainted by this conflict of interest???

    The apologies have no use if we don’t know what were the topics that we need to be careful about…

    If you gave me some poison, don’t just say you were sorry….tell me what kind of poison I just drank so the ER can help me….

    dammit!

  • Matt

    So it’s someone below the age of adulthood working as an intern. Maybe you shouldn’t rely on cheap labour to provide content?

  • MyLocator ®

    in one way or another under the blanket butt rubbing goes on all the time here and in vc valley. in fact that’s what its built on. most already know not to believe everything hear here.

  • Small Biz

    Excellent points. By the way, was this kid paid?

  • atanu

    Daniel made a mistake, and has repented for it. Its what he did after his mistake that counts for more, and after reading his log post, I think he passed with flying colors.
    If the wall street a*holes and the bankers had one-tenth of his strength of character, the world would have been a far better place.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dale_Larson/722671792 Dale Larson

    “I promise that we will always maintain complete transparency with you on how we operate, even when it isn’t such an easy thing to do.”

    Michael: I really appreciate that this is the standard to which you hold TechCrunch and your staff. The rules just don’t need to be any more complicated than that. And you’re right, it isn’t always easy (or even possible) to do — for example, you can’t be completely transparent about the details of this matter.

    Despite the rules being simple, I’m sure the situation was complicated and that this was difficult for all of you. Best of luck to all involved as you move forward.

  • Keyboard Cat

    Which makes me wonder whether, even if he did what TC says he did, his parents will start running around threatening a lawsuit. If they’re well-moneyed, they probably will. That would probably be why Mike said they’re keeping his name under wraps (in theory).

  • cbrown

    Legal or not? I don’t get where this is coming from. If TC is a news organization (dubious claim), they have a right and responsibility to report a newsworthy item. ( They have not. They have claimed transparency but have offered anything but. )

    Please don’t misunderstand me. I am an avid reader and will continue to be one, but I cannot pat Arrington and TC on the back for this one. He chose a rather poor and lawyerly way to proceed. I wish he had chosen the more professional and journalistic route.

  • p c

    KweditBailBondsman.net

  • http://www.karthickgopal.com Karthick

    Crossing the line driven by greed and confused with naivety ending up shooting yourself in the foot. Well played Daniel.

  • http://www.williamsportwebdeveloper.com Robert S. Robbins

    Oh please! A TechCrunch blogger is not going to become a celebrity under any circumstances.

  • ladyofargonne

    I find it interesting the TechCrunch doesn’t mention his last name but he voluntarily identifies himself. His blogs are gone but now he can be Googled forever in conjunction with his actions. Doesn’t sound like he is savvy enough to have realized he’s imploded his career and tarnished his personal reputation.

    I applaud TechCrunch on its integrity.

  • Mike

    Agreed. Serious hazards, working for MA.

  • RJ

    This has nothing to do with age. The guy is a weasel. Simple as that.

  • Val

    “In some way or another, a line was crossed that should have never been.”

    R u fing kidding? Who crossed a line? And what’s this “some way or another”? How about, “I crossed a line. I did it to obtain a gadget that I couldn’t otherwise afford or didn’t want to pay for. I did a scummy thing.”

    I mean what’s with all the passive voice?

  • http://www.hazardouspaste.com HazardousPaste

    Meh. Seems like a heartfelt apology and looks like TC handled this in a good way, but if I was going to write a sponsored post for a Mac at least make it a Macbook Pro :p

  • http://www.subermarket.com Khaled Hakim

    Things like this happen. We appreciate the transparency of Tech Crunch in telling us about this incident. It shows what kind of relationship you like to maintain with your readers.

    As for the non-adult, I am sure he / she will learn their lesson. Being dispatched from Tech Crunch will definitely set this person back and I am sure they will sooner or later realize that what they had done was wrong.

  • http://silentmajority09.com Robert

    It’s a shame that there are companies out there who would indulge in this king of behavior. I youthful intern was probably an easy mark for corporate predators. I don’t dismiss his part in this I just think the companies should be held accountable as well.

  • Karl

    That’s a doublespeak non-apology. “The line was crossed?” No kid, YOU crossed the line, admit it and move on.

    No one is going to hold it against him for long if he actually owns up to it, but this sort of hiding behind semantics and refusing to actually take responsibility is what tarnishes his reputation for me.

  • JLH

    Hey, they deleted my post!!!

    I said that he wasn’t an intern, but a regular TC writer. They are just covering it up with the intern stuff, and this confirms it!!

    Please pass the word if you see this message before it gets banned.

  • Dalia Pepper

    This “kid” has revealed what kind of man he may be one day and it’s a sorry one. Character is among the few valuable traits we have and if yours is warped to this extent and at this early stage of your life it’s a hard thing to mend. I suspect Daniel’s unethical leanings preceded his TechCrunch employment and will continue after; charming and bright as he seems to be.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Eric_Miltsch/1128085240 Eric Miltsch

    Michael,

    Nicely handled TC & Michael.

    It’s probably difficult for most people to imagine what it means working for/with TC – let alone doing it at 17. Heavy responsibility at that age…

  • Adam V

    From the article:

    “In fact, on at least one other occasion this intern was almost certainly given a computer in exchange for a post.”

  • Amit

    How about MG Siegler??

    He is a shareholder of 4sq and he blogs about 4sq everyday?? Is he the next to go??

  • devrim baris acar

    Maybe you just exposed this, because you knew it would be eventually exposed, just took advantage beforehand to form a public image that techcrunch is a honest company, which never created paid content :).

  • Mark

    Let he who has not sin cast the first stone…

    I woke up this morning thinking about a job I had over 15 years ago, and how I could have done things better. My boss, who was 40 at the time and having some medical issues, said quite a bit ‘call me when you’re 40′ after we would give him flak for being and ‘old man’. I’m now nearly 40 myself, and was thinking of Rick when I woke up for some reason.

    When I was working at this particular company, I was young, immature, and had very little life experience in the ‘real world. I made my share of mistakes that make me regret some of the things I did. Nothing I did was illegal or unethical, I just handled things in a bad way due to my inexperience.

    The point I’m making is don’t be too hard on a teen who makes a mistake, unless of course YOU never, ever made a mistake, or exercised poor judgement at some point in your young life. I personally applaud the young man for publicly apologizing, and addressing the situation. How many of you who are tossing stones at this kid would do the same in his shoes? I have no doubt this experience will be a positive event in hindsight that can have a profound effect on his character in years to come.

    I understand this is the internet, and one of it’s primary uses (aside from porn of course) is to hide behind the curtain of anonymity to berate anyone/everyone else to inflate one’s own ego. Just because this is commonplace, it does not make it right, nor does it make any kind of positive contribution to mankind. Kudos!

    P

  • http://luleka.com Juergen

    “the intern was terminated” the poor thing, you killed him or what?

  • http://www.andreapaternostro.com Andrea Paternostro

    As a tech journalist, passionate and TC reader I definitely appreciate your transparent way to handle this case. Well done. A.

  • http://www.andreapaternostro.com Andrea Paternostro

    As a tech journalist, passionate and TC reader I definitely appreciate your transparent way to handle this situation. Well done. A.

  • Sigurd

    9 months? Hardly an intern then. Just a teenage TC underpaid writer.

  • BillC

    I don’t know this kid at all, but my experience has shown me that small dishonest actions now lead to even bigger dishonest actions later in the majority of cases.

    I hope he has learned a lesson, and I also hope that I can be proven wrong at some point.

  • Apology Dew

    While you are at it Arrington, maybe you should apologize for previously inducing Yahoo employees breach their employment agreement by sharing confidential information with Techcrunch in violation of your obligation as an attorney and in contravention of the California code of professional ethics.

  • http://occamsrazr.com Ike

    Dan, the frequent use of ellipses is common in broadcasting, where I worked for 16 years.

    It’s a long-standing convention for writing for the teleprompter, which dates back to before electronic displays. Teevee people still do it, and it took years for me to break the habit after getting out.

    And as salaries continue to plummet in the industry (reporters and producers make a fraction of what most assume), I will tell you that if she is in television she doesn’t have two nickels to rub together to buy a dime bag.

    Best…

    Ike.

  • http://mdm-adph.blogspot.com mdmadph

    Why… are… you typing… like this…?

  • Snowman

    This is sad, but not at all surprising, at least from an outsider’s perspective. What did surprise me was the atrocious grammar and spelling errors in his blog post. Did he really write for a living?

  • http://www.danielruby.com Dan Ruby

    Thanks for being transparent about this, Michael. It’s not easy admitting something like this, but it’s the only way to move forward – pretending it didn’t happen could have had disastrous results.

  • meeee

    What’s the name of the company that bribed a child? Abusing the TC readers and the young age of the kid?

  • doug

    I will have to look at posts here differently now that I see you have children posting the content. I always though the content was not consistent in quality, so that is probably the reason.

    I can’t believe that you decided to give a link to this scum bag on his personal blog. You should not have given him the forum.

  • Foo fighter

    Am I the only one here willin to stand up for Daniel?

    1. Interns are usually unpaid. Or severeley underpaid. As someone performed many many tasks as an intern I know te value accrues primarily to the intern-master.

    2. If the intern is good enough to write articles, then he is good enough to be paid as a ft author. If he is not, why subject readers to the risk?

    3. I think the blame lies squarely with arrington. Who REALLY abused his authority? It was TC that tried to save a couple bucks. It thought it could pull a fast one by “hiring for free” Talented young people who’d work their balls off for nothing. That imbalance of power, reward and responsibility creates the financial motivation to accept compensation for something he clearly wasn’t getting from techcrunch. The military and CIA deal with this all the time. Often ghe money spies get is trivial. It is often the lack of respect and balance of power and authority that the double agent is reacting to.

    4. The morality an virtue arrington is aping is an utter sham. Arrington and TC are nit in this game for virtue. They are in this for profit. Why else hire an intern? Pay the guy forthe value he offers or don’t hire him at all. If you brought Daniel on or any intern for that matter under the guise that you’d be the financial beneficiary then shame in techcrunch. This situation highlights more about the emotional reality of techcrunch than its morality. Frankly, tc is a commercial enterprise and as such there can be no discussion of morality or virtue. Tc is not a charity. However, the intern is. He is donating his Real present value in exchange for the hypothetical value he can trade on at some later date. Tc makes no promise to Daniel. The only thing certain is that tc gets an immediate ebitda contribution. Frankly, the whole situation stinks.

    5. The company which bribed Daniel did so bc it is a commercial enterprise. It did the only logical thing. Ethical? Perhaps not. But whose to say that oter anallogous motives haven’t tilted arrington in the past. Eg political favors, personal vendettas, etc. Each one of those motives are equally suspect and moral equivalents to daniels actions. Fact is, Daniel probably learned a lot from techcrunch. Monkey see monkey do.

    6. The apologia is ill conceived and misdirected. Arrington has revealed that he abused the privilege of daniels employment. He had no oversight to thwart such things and or provided Daniel the sense that he was fairly compensated for his contributions such that a bribe wouldbe been immediately rejected. Additionally, arrington sees this as an ethics and virtue issue. I suggest he go further and discribe the environment and motives and implicit rules (do as I say not as I do) that laid the foundation for such a breach of trust if his readers. This situation highlights management more than it does Daniel. Arrington created the mousetrap. Daniel merely got caught in it.

  • http://www.digitalovercast.com Kien

    TC is awesome and I frequent the site at least twice a day, every day. Thx Michael for disclosing this unfortunate event. I hope Daniel learned something from all of this.

  • WOW

    Hey was a intern at Qik. This explains all their positive press..

  • SS

    I don’t see why everyone is fixating on the fact that the intern was a teenager. Who cares? The best part of the story was how TechCrunch handled the situation, and really took ownership of the problem. Deleting every blog post from the intern, firing him, giving an apology to its readers without being asked… these are all good things. Good, swift decision making in the face of a sudden crisis.

  • Rozco

    Give me a break. Give the kid a break. He was caught, he was let go…now you’re putting him out to the public? He will learn, like many teenagers do.

    BTW, will you report on those at techcrunch who took office supplies home?

  • marc

    honestly mike you have a real ego problem. A kid on your team that you most likely don’t pay and you do that If anyone did that in a real business a hr dept would deal with it internally and that would be that. That post is so unprofessional. Why don’t you disclose all your authors interests for real transparency?

  • http://usandeurope.com Justin Whittaker

    This was the right step to take BUT for all of you condemning Daniel Brusilovsky, stop. Get over yourselves. I know Daniel too and I think he’s a good person. This isn’t the end of his career. He’s only 17 and I’m pretty sure this is something he’ll never, ever do again. Let him move on without us kicking him in the backside as he leaves TechCrunch. His future is still bright.

  • http://www.theplugg.com Charbarred

    Apple addiction. What kids wouldn’t do for a shiny new Mac these days.

    This is your brain. This is your brain on Mac.
    Any questions?

  • http://www.technologynomad.com Ahmad

    Your transparency is admirable, appreciated and has touched me professionally. This one “post” of yours has made me that much more of a loyal reader.

    That said, things like this happen. In light of your transparency post, I suspect most of your readers are mature enough to not even think twice about your content, the integrity by which you write and the site’s overall ethics.

    Keep up the good work (and don’t look back much).

    Ahmad al-As’ad
    http://www.technologynomad.com
    http://twitter.com/technologynomad

  • http://www.visin.com,http://operationhugahero.org Thomas Townsend

    In today’s Social Media World, where Transparency is one of the Key Rules, Tech Crunch really sets the Standard as far as being a True “Trust Agent” as coined by Chris Brogan. Kudos to Tech Crunch for taking the right action and telling us about it!

  • DavidMotoRolla

    its a kid, so he only got a macbook – so sad :(( haha

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Albo_P_Fossa/1157100099 Albo P Fossa

    And (did I already say this? I didn’t see my post arise: if so, I BEG OF YOU PLEASE IGNORE MY STOOPID DUPLICATIONS but…) +1

  • Phil

    Why would you care? You guys have said time and again that you’re not ‘journalists.’

    You don’t usually second source. You run rumor as fact. Everything you write has an opinion in it.

    Why not get all ‘shaken’ when someone simply follows the logic your publication has established as status quo for new media?

  • Max

    I love all the people that just have to throw hatred at Arrington for posting this or this little asshole. He fucked up, he got caught, he realizes that he made a mistake, now move along, move along, nothing to see here.

    This isn’t a public official for Jebus sake — it’s a blog. Mistakes will be made, and if they fess up, huzzah. As for the company that was doing the bribing – they were trying to get a leg up LIKE EVERY OTHER STARTUP ON THE FACE OF THE PLANET. Yeah, they did something on the sly, big deal, get over it, if they are that desperate what are the real odds that their product doesn’t — actually — suck balls.

  • DavidMotoRolla

    my thoughts exactly, ofcourse they get certain presents and ofcourse there are ulterior motives in some posts – common!

  • /dev/mem

    I have heard startups paying PR ppl $xx,000 to get an article on TC ………. wondering if the kid was just following what most/some/few of the writers did. Just wondering ….

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jason_McCabe_Calacanis/504598293 Jason McCabe Calacanis

    Kudos to Michael Arrington for handling every publisher/editor’s worst nightmare–an editor extorting subjects for coverage–professionally and with complete transparently.

    The horrible part of this story is that the editor who was asking for a MacBook Air for a post on TechCrunch (it seems more than once, and at least once with an actual computer being given) was a loved 17-year old people considered a prodigy in the publishing space.

    Young people make mistakes and this is a non-trivial one. This will follow Daniel for a long time, and I hope that his parents, friends and co-workers spend a lot of time discussing this issue with him in the coming days, weeks and months.

    Finally, although this is a very serious issue, there are many worse things that young people have done. There are teens arrested every month for committing violent crimes like assault, rape and even murder.

    I’m grateful to the TechCrunch staff for handling this professionally and with dignity, and I hope that Daniel immediately apologizes and gets some counseling.

    His first apology, titled “a line was crossed” doesn’t scream of complete ownership–in fact it has a plug for his “teens in tech” conference in it. I fear he doesn’t actually realize the gravity of this yet, but I’m certain he will. He is, in fact, lucky that TechCrunch doesn’t take legal action against him.

  • mike

    So, I hear you have an opening for an intern….

  • Chad Bradley

    I don’t blame Daniel, I blame the scumbags taking advantage of kids needs.

  • I win.

    Anne-Marie! Do the interns get glocks?

  • http://www.my140plus.com Niels

    Well it’s all very nice of TC to be so called “all transparent” about it, and not to disclose identities, but if anyone could have guessed the true identity would come out within hours, it would have been Mr. Arrington himself. Especially after they mentoned they removed the interns posts.

  • su2lly

    I’m going to guess that most of the people who are trashing this kid have never worked a job in the music business (radio,record label, retail)

  • Chad Bradley

    Some of these guys could be the scumbag solicitors :)

    WooThemes Expands To ExpressionEngine; More Themes Coming http://tcrn.ch/5XzHci

    ReelSurfer: A White Label Solution For Video Search http://tcrn.ch/7tdb9l

    AdNectar Serves Over 2 Billion Virtual Goods Over Social Networks http://tcrn.ch/649fTz

  • Bo L

    from the intern’s blog: “In some way or another, a line was crossed that should have never been.”

    this reminds me of the cartoon where the parent asks the kids who broke the flower pot and the kids answer “nobody did it” and you see a picture of an imaginary nobody knocking over the flower pot

    also from the blog: “This is the first day of the next learning stage for me”

    clearly it is… apparently the learning stage hasn’t started yet since, so far, he thinks that things are not in his control, lines are being crossed for some reason, and he’s a passive traveler.

  • Bob Hiler

    I strongly disagree as I admire Michael for his commitment to transparency. I would go even further and say that it’s his commitment to transparency even in the face of public embarrassment that builds my trust in him.

    Also, deleting Daniel’s posts is the correct decision as they are now tainted.

  • Ken Jackson

    There is a difference between Tiger and this guy. While I’m not sure I could trust Tiger if I dated him, I trust his skills on the golf course.

    With this guy, trusting his writing would be harder to do.

    With that said, at age 17 I did some really stupid stuff too. While maybe never something this big or public, it is stuff that I wouldn’t do 3 years later. Hopefully this is a lesson to him.

  • http://www.brandonmblack.com Brandon Black

    Yeah… but clearly she’s hot. It doesn’t matter. I’ve made my peace with her terrible grammar.

  • Diabl0

    Yes, judging from the links given here

    It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out that it was that kid, who’s now submitting an apology on his website.

    I guess this time, Google’s private spy won’t be needed anymore.

  • Mike

    This is bullshit! MA wants to show he is transparent. But we all know that he takes money for coverage like from foursquare.

  • http://www.brandonmblack.com Brandon Black

    I must be missing something important here…

    What exactly is unethical about this kid getting a Macbook Air in exchange for posting an article about a start-up vs. TechCrunch posting an article about a start-up in exchange for a “sponsored article”?

    Is the difference that only the kid benefits personally from the first rather than TechCrunch as a whole?

    Did you guys want a Macbook Air too? Or maybe, was this just a good PR opportunity to earn some brownie points among your less astute readers by being “transparent” about it?

    I’m addicted to hookers and black market Turkish heroin, but I’m sure announcing that on here probably won’t win me any favors… but who knows, right?

    The only thing this kid did wrong that broke the examples set by his employer was that he asked for a Macbook Air.

    Those things suck.

    He should have at least asked for a fully loaded Macbook Pro or held out for an iPad.

    Amateur.

  • Dr. Billy Bob Gisher

    The next time you have someone on your staff engaging in pay-for-play, it would be nice if you would assign them an icon that clearly identifies them as being on the take?

    And another thing, can you get somebody in that position who will do an article for something less than a free computer, perhaps an Arby’s coupon for a free roast beef sandwich?

    I don’t have the budget to handle someone who’s tastes are as expensive as Daniel’s were.

    All that said, if you want to assure your editorial purity, why don’t you guys go out and purchase smartphones and their apps instead of accepting them for free?

  • ZachP

    Not a legal adult? You have 17 year olds or younger writing your blog posts? Given TechCrunch’s quantity over quality approach I guess this isn’t surprising. The real question is now if MG is of age or not

  • yeah

    lol. did you see his pic? i think the guy is joking but you never know on the internet…

  • http://blog.hoofarted.com John

    I wasn’t aware of this situation until today, but I am happy to see a Web site with such integrity as to apologize to the readers over something like this. TC is now bookmarked.

  • Steven McCormick

    It doesn’t matter. If you look past the grammar and look at the content of Daina’s comments, you will realize the she is very intelligent.

    Besides, she’s from Thailand, and has only recently started learning English. I’d like to see any of you try to learn Thai in a couple of years and write flawlessly in Thai. Myself, I was completely lost, and felt like an idiot, when I had to IM in French on a French keyboard– and I took 4 years of French in high school.

  • Bob Dobbs Jr.

    Yeah that will restore TechCrunch’s journalistic integrity. A vapid valley girl who also happens to be an Apple fanboi .. Like totallyy, like yeah! Like OMFGWTF and some junk! Gag me with a spoon!

  • Steven McCormick

    They have kids writing posts here? Do the kids sign as authors? Or do they write and have one of the adult authors sign as author?

    All of the articles I’ve seen here on TC were signed by adults. Are we saying that some of the articles written by, say, Jason Kincaid are actually written by a 14 year old intern?

  • http://www.pathawks.com Pat Hawks

    What he posted on his blog doesn’t really read like an apology.

    “In some way or another, a line was crossed”

  • Steven McCormick

    Please provide a link to a cache page containing the kid’s writing. I don’t know how to search for it.

  • Nick

    Have you guys forgot what it is like being a kid? People make mistakes the guy is 16. Unless of course everyone here never made a mistake. When you’re 16 you are not thinking about the rest of your life.

    He got punished and will learn from it. In 6 months everyone is going to forget this even happened.

  • Soren Johansson

    I AM ANGRY AND I DEMAND BLOOD

    RAHHHHH

  • http://silenteagle.net Silent Eagle

    I don’t know, I find the whole thing absurd, hilarious, and both apologies ridiculously dramatic. You’d think the writer (a kid) had confessed to killing a baby panda w/an iPad he had received for free.

  • yeah

    there are lots of adults who make mistakes too. there are lots of adults who were once kids and did stupid things as kids. please. we kids may not have as fully a developed brain as an adult, or the experiences adults have, but we’re not all stupid, just like adults aren’t all smart and make right decisons all the time. what happened with this intern happens across the world of journalism many times over. it doesn’t mean it’s okay but that is the state of things. temptation is hard to resist.

  • yeah

    lol. he’s the author of the post. he obviously knows and you can also infer that he crossed the line. duh. i mean he’s not writing it about someone else.

  • http://www.getrocketbox.com Matt Ronge

    I can assure you it was NOT me. No compensation was exchanged. Please don’t spread false rumors!

  • G.P.

    Yes, Daina is a fine piece of art. She needs to be cast in bronze. Oh, and I heard she’s pretty smart in real life.

  • Phil

    “While I’m not sure I could trust Tiger if I dated him, [...]”

    Ken, I don’t think Tiger is gay …

  • Ed Pie

    Oh my, that was funny…

  • Joe

    Mike,

    Thanks for the apology. But what are you doing to make sure it doesn’t happen again?

    Yes, media is changing — there isn’t a need to go to journalism school and eventually work at a newspaper to get published. But one good thing about those ‘old-school’ forms of media is the standards they set. While this still could have happened in ‘old-school’ media, at least it would have been clear to the individual that this is completely unacceptable.

    -joe.

  • http://irieman.com SherwinRocks

    (So many angles in this story I don’t know which to comment on!)

    This incident is just one example of the “integrity problem” we’re seeing develop right before our eyes in the tech industry/culture.

    Arrington strikes me as essentially a “good guy”- a brash button-pusher, who often p*sses people off, but overall, a man who stands by his own integrity and more importantly, GETS THE STORY. And people love *and* hate him for it.

    On the flip-side, our blogger du jour is just another newcomer playing not by old-school rules of journalism, but by modern politics-rules that have seeped into every vertical. (I won’t get into it as this is not a politics blog). The “culprit” in this incident just happened to be a young adult intern, who just happened to get caught. “Pay for post” opportunities are still rampant in the blogging world; TC (based on some of the comments I’ve read this morning) does not accept this from their staffers, but as pretty astute readers we all know there are far more publications that tolerate and/or thrive off of it.

    Aside from those directly involved, no one can *know* whether or not MA’s handling of the situation was/was not appropriate given the former intern’s character. However, the fact that the intern/blogger managed to squeeze in a plug for his own event in his “apology” shows that he will make a great CEO or Senator someday.

    “He’ll get over it” we say? He already has.

  • Kevin Dent

    I am amazed at a lot of these comments, so many of us have fucked up when we were kids, but it was so long ago we have chosen to “forget” them.

    He did a stupid thing, no one died. They removed him and he was pretty transparent in his apology.

    In terms of revealing who gave him the computer “on the previous occasion”, personally I am not that interested.

    If you are a startup and someone says “hey gimme a pc and I will do a post on your company” are you telling me you would turn it down?

    If you would bravo to you, now please sit over at
    the table reserved for failed start-up’s.

    I do not know a single start up person -that is good- that would not kick a new pc to MA or anyone at TC if they thought that would get them a favorable posting.

    FACT most start-up’s hit the wall and go out of business without anyone ever knowing about them. Even start-up’s with fantastic products get shit canned to the deadpool of bankruptcy. So they are desperate and will do anything to get an edge.

    Michael Arrington can be a prick sometimes -like all of us- but I think for the most part he is a fair prick when he is. In this case, he did not go postal on the kid, he removed him and his posts, said sorry and moved on. I see not a grain of malice in his words.

    It’s the fuckers that would just keep this internal that scare me.

  • James

    Sounds like the kid is ready for a career in politics. Dan for Congress!

  • Phil

    I think there is an important difference between these:

    1) Get offered an Apple laptop in exchange for writing *honestly* about a company, even if there are negative remarks.

    2) Get offered an Apple laptop in exchange for both writing about a company and then talking it up, beyond what it merits.

    Both aren’t good but the first at least falls into the realm of paid advertising. Magazines have a long history of writing about products while “strongly encouraging” companies to place paid advertising in their pages at the same time.

  • yeah

    he’s a kid even if he’s been working with adults for a while now. he’s doing the most obvious thing which is accepting responsibility while trying to step away from the situation. and there’s also always two sides to the story just like there’s another alternative to how this information could have been relayed to the readers without this whole disclosing name and deleting previous posts thing. anyways and the kid isn’t going into what happened, how this happened, why, etc…but if everyone just thinks it’s only his fault, then they need to open their eyes. there’s responsibilites that fall on other people involved in this whole takebacks scenario who also dropped the ball, but we’re not hearing from them yet and they aren’t taking the lead. so don’t be surprised when you read comments about how maybe the people at the top at tc should have realised this was going on, or the commenters asking why there is a hole in the tc system and how it could be exploited without their knowledge and also other questions of conflict about shilling in general because as we all know to think that the kid was the only one doing it is very unrealistic.

  • diar

    The kid got caught up. I doubt he, at first, went out and solicited kickbacks from companies. He probably got approached by some PR flack and was offered something for a blog post…they probably let him keep a product after posting about it, something that probably happens with some regularity with real pros but isn’t an outright bribe since no specific arrangement was made.

    That same PR flack, who likely represents more than one company, realized they had an “in” and kept coming back to him, probably offering stuff upfront after a while. As time passed, the intern probably got a bit bolder and started asking for stuff, but I think this is a case of him being corrupted rather than shaking down struggling startups.

    I do feel bad for him, but he has to learn that you don’t always get a second chance. Sometimes just one mistake could ruin you.

    That said, I also think the PR flack or companies behind the scam should be exposed. To avoid lawsuits, do it separately. Just make a post out of the blue, something like “For the next year, we won’t be writing about company X, company Y and company Z.” And don’t explain it. We’ll know why.

  • Gordon Freemain

    It’s a journalist style called Shatnerism, i.e. you’ve …been… Shatner’d… on…

  • yeah

    dude please. some of the comments get caught up in the filters and someone from tc has to approve them…but most times comments get posted. i mean i said cunt in one of mine yesterday and it was posted. i also read your comment (you posted 2. the second one you said something about how you weren’t finished posting your thoughts and you probably accidently clicked submit). anyways lay off the conspiracy angle.

  • Kevin Ebaugh

    I never liked the kid’s posts anyway. Good riddance!

  • yeah

    ha. he’s 17. he probably lives comfortably with his parental unit. how can he write for a living? also another ha…the kid joined tc a couple months back last year. he’s been around trying to make a name for himself and tit (teens in tech).

  • Alex K

    I guess he was just an intern … but the boss has the right to do so and on a much larger scale. The kid still has indeed a lot to learn! How to be a hypocrite 101 chapter 1.

  • http://knoxbronson.com Knox Bronson

    Well, I read his non-apology on his blog. “A line was crossed.” Why do these guys put it in the passive voice and not admit what they did? I.e., “I solicited merchandise in exchange for posts on a hugely popular and trusted tech blog.” The kid is a little worm and will probably always be one.

  • Alex K

    I guess he was just an intern … but the boss has the right to do so and on a much larger scale. The kid still has indeed a lot to learn! How to be a hypocrite 101 chapter 1.

  • id8

    Tim is speaking for all his friends, from state prison.

  • yeah

    no. those are things you would think any company would do, but seriously not behind the postulating. you think this kid is the only one who has done this while working for tc or any other blog expecially in the tech business? and also i think the commenter who posted the comment about pre-empting a possible shitstorm is right on the money and that there was some back dealing on if you don’t reveal this then i will sort of situation. the kid outed himself. he would’ve outed himself anyways with this tc post or not, and also nice of them to delete everything as if the people who this post are meant for aren’t smart enough to figure out who the intern is. and also, this intern supposedly has the title of events coordinator or something at tc…as some others have pointed out, maybe more needs to be found out about his working situation. yeah he did something bad. yeah he’s 17 and maybe not just a kid but also an adult considering he’s been working around adults for a long time. yeah his blog post of apology reads like some trudtastic featurama, but give me a break with all the people talking about transfuckingparency here as if tc did something that is knocking people for 6′s when it really does read as another turdtastic post where the sanctimonious posturing just reeks in the whole post. there are people here involved in this situation who are not taking responsibility. they are only meeting this half way. okay so one culprit here is the kid. the other(s) you would think would be these companies, and the rest would be squarely on the head of tc and the people running this show who didn’t even know that one of their own was taking takebacks. so excuse us all if there are comments questioning the authenticity of this post and the ethics of other tc employees.

  • yeah

    they say it as if he’s never going to grow past 17 and as if being fired from tc is the end all be all like ma has the future locked to this kid. ha. well this post didn’t help much at all, and we sure can google the shit out of this if the kids name comes up. it’s a bad situation all around. i’m all for transparency and i’m not really against this post as much as i am some of the stuff written in it which i think could have been excluded, as well as obvious actions, which of a limited extent are fair but completely identified the intern, and also just raises questions about not only the companies the kid covered but also about tc and how these other employees react with sources. so there has to be an internal mechanism that alerts the tc heads as to who’s shilling and who isn’t right. i mean had the boss not gotten that call and had the kid not confessed, the boss could have figured out himself that one of his own people was selling tc space? right?

  • OhhJohnny

    You’re joking. Being an intern for TC is a privilege for this kid to get exposure, and if you’ve ever read his posts, you’d know he never had the talent to deserve it. He’s well-connected in the valley for some reason and that’s how he got it. Plus, he’s in high school and couldn’t work full time anyways. Also, if you look at his resume, the dude has more gigs than most of us, so he didn’t have the time to be a full timer.

    The apology was fine and much needed. Reading Daniel’s half-baked apology really made me turn on him. At first I thought it was just a young kid falling into temptation and we’ve all been there. But reading his bullshit, passive voice, non-apology I realize he knew exactly what he was doing and he’s in full damage control mode. How about a real apology explaining why he took this. Hell, if he just said “I got greedy and I’m sorry” I would have much more respect for him.

    I hate how he was treated as an Internet genius and got so much coverage but when things go wrong he’s “just a kid.”

  • yeah

    yeah and why should the boss not also be held responsible? is it not his name and his blog? the whole thing just rings of absolute shade because this transparency is actually theatre really (my opinion). it’s nice when tc employees have vested interest in companies and you get these discalimers in the posts. makes me laugh a little.

  • OhhJohnny

    He didn’t get offered it, he ASKED for it in exchange for coverage. Major difference than your two scenarios.

  • yeah

    lol. even if your comment is made in jest, and ha even if other commenters are pointing out the same thing you did about tc recieving something aside from just the kid, being an intern means no kickbacks. but then again we don’t know the details of this 9 month internship.

  • jack lee

    Bull sh it this guy is sorry. his lawyer just told him he needed to make a sincere apology for his actions. i’ve been through this myself. you do what your lawyer says. just sayin’…

    you’re an idiot if you believe this guy. you don’t just make a mistake like this. it just truly shows your character.

  • Mike

    While he might be sadly leaving techcrunch behind, his lack of morals and ethics bodes well for his future. While he missed the rush to sign homeowners up for subprime mortgages while pocketing a fat fee, there are sure to be plenty of other opportunities to put lots of money in his pocket in the future. He ought to be thinking of getting a job on Wall Street; his “misadventure” here will probably help him land a job, because the “what’s in it for me” attitude is what drives the Street. Pushing at the fringes of the rules and beyond is what they admire, and now he has a story to tell.

  • benson grud

    Wow that is really something else

    http://www.babatundebusari.com

  • mikie

    Are you all idiots. TC is not hiding the boys name anymore. They give you a link the boys blog http://www.danielbru.com/ under the update section.

  • Kate Battle

    As a young music journalist, I received CDs and promo items on a regular basis from record labels and bands. Without that stuff, I never could have reviewed their music on the budget I had at the time. Was this kid given the computer to review or was it given to him as a gift unrelated to his blog? If it was related to the story, you can’re really expect him to go out and buy a MacBook Air just for the story…Not many teens just have the money sitting around.

    No matter what the circumstances of the gift were, though, I think it was a bit harsh to fire him. I understand removing past blogs, but I think, if this is a one-time event, he should be given another chance to redeem himself and his good name.

  • Natyong

    Really? Are you sure about that? Life is about kickbacks. In Journalism as many other professions these kickbacks mostly should to be transparent.

    As a kid it’s, “don’t tell mom and I’ll do a chore for you,” and “I’ll buy you an ice cream if you tell Sally how cool I am,” kinda things.

    Owning up to ones mistakes is a big part of becoming a responsible adult.

  • Rob

    Some comments:

    People Saying: “This matter should have been kept quiet and the offending writer should have been let go silently.”

    When you run a high profile editorial site, the accusations of bias and bribery are non-stop and it only takes one instance of someone getting caught accepting bribes to ruin the reputation of the entire organization. Many companies strictly separate their editorial and advertising teams as part of a strategy to ensure that their reputation remains solid. It is of central importance to a site like TechCrunch to be regarded as a CREDIBLE source of tech news in the same way that IGN, GameSpot, CNET need to have their editorial staffs separated from any and all advertising or commercial interests (See: Kan & Lynch Scandal in regards to GameSpot). What better way to enforce that point then a public blood letting?

    In most cases, yes you should let an employee go silently. In this case, the above news, if not announced by Arrington, (I speculate) it might have been announced by someone else (afterall, TechCrunch consists of a bunch of reporters, all with their own blogs, sources and communications networks)- at least TechCrunch took the initiative to announce the news first, control the story and give their version of it before anyone else got a chance to announce it and get the facts wrong.

    Its too bad they took the chance on using someone who seemed exceptional and wound up getting burned.

  • http://www.scottstead.com scottstead

    awesome…its type like…william…shatner…..talks..day.

  • Temple

    This is my question. While TechCrunch is honest and upfront about this situation (much like with their advertiser situation) how many other blogs are not?

    How many of the bigger blogs have a posts that have been paid-for/sponsored by a corporate entity???

    Are there cleverly placed attack ads? A rival pays the blog to attack another company for instance.

  • BottlePop

    I hardly think this will be a blip in the person’s life. Nor am convinced that the activism on TC, in general, is wholly more noble than taking compensation for articles.

  • steve

    too bad this kid wasn’t a trader at goldman when he f’d up like this… he’d have gotten a huge bonu$.

  • Bobby

    He also made me send him a nude picture of myself to write an article about my stealth website. I did it, but it doesnt excuse the interns behavior…

  • Bobby

    Was joking about the nude pic…Techcrunch should fire Michael – he has messed up a lot. Fire his ass, stop firing kids.

  • http://www.taranfx.com Taranfx

    I think I know that guy. I remember the biased one.
    Silence is Bliss!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Michael_Olenick/509384937 Michael Olenick

    Nonsense. As the parent of a teen I’d love to work at T/C as an intern Michael, I think, did exactly the right thing, in the right order, at the right time. I don’t know MA but remember reading somewhere that he has a young tyke or two of his own; sounds like he’s on his way to growing up to be a good parent, balancing discipline in the real world with transparency, responsibility, and a reasonable amount of protection.

    Hiding this would have been wrong; displaying Daniel’s name without his consent would also have been wrong. This is a well balanced response; kudos to you MA.

  • big deal?

    I’m not in journalism so I don’t fully understand the context, but I don’t really see what the big deal is.

    It is common practice in marketing to give things away to generate positive feelings, feedback, and recognition.

    We all get free stuff, it doesn’t mean we trade our integrity or lie about what we really think.

    I’d imagine TechCruch has a whole office full of stuff just given to them. Certainly they walk away from every conference or event with a whole baggy full of goodies.

    If the author just would have posted on his entries that the firm was getting props 1. because he thinks they should and 2. because they also gave him a sweet computer, would he be off the hook? I guess, is the problem that we didn’t have full disclosure?

  • developer

    My post will stay up though, right?

  • Rick

    I completely agree with James. This should have been resolved privately with the intern, his family, and the affected companies. The author’s feigned protection of the intern’s anonymity in the initial post is a joke. There’s no need to tar and feather this kid.

  • Rick

    He’s joking.

  • Kelli

    Well, at least the kid is accepting the blame. That’s a sign of maturity. There are a lot of adults who won’t admit when they’ve screwed up, so, kudos for that much.

  • http://traxx-kinderwagen.info Traxx

    Makes me wonder what kind of kickbacks some journalists receive

  • http://ijustine.com Justine

    I was just joking around! Making light of the situation..

    This is a serious issue though but I have met Daniel personally on many different occasions. I don’t know what happened here at Techcrunch, but he’s probably one of the most ambitious people I’ve ever met. He’ll be fine in the long run. I think this is a good learning experience for everyone.

    What were you guys doing when you were 17? I think I was playing a lot of Nintendo and learning to type really fast..

    ..and Bob, I’d opt for a fork.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Matthew_Wing/1446804856 Matthew Wing

    Yeah he published a blog post…in which he doesn’t really admit he did something wrong or say that he regrets it. He praises TechCrunch, makes a vague statement about a line being crossed, then he plugs the Teens in Tech conference, and says he wants to just move on and have privacy. Please.

  • Rob

    If this kid’s career is ruined, as so many of you believe, there is an alternate career awaiting that would suit him and his obvious talents.
    He should be a politician. :D

  • Understandable

    Not condoning it. Perhaps TechCrunch should have paid him for his work. Just sayin

  • http://www.getrocketbox.com Matt Ronge

    Don’t spread false rumors. I DID NOT PAY to have that posted.

    Remember nearly all of the companies he covered are innocent in this. Don’t slander us all.

  • Kamran

    Thought soliciting bribes is def not a good idea for the credibility of this site, you guys are taking this way to seriously acting as if he committed violent crimes or something. I dont even know why you needed to post this information at all. It seems like an internal affair, which doesn’t really affect the readers being his posts were removed. Being a little sensitive about this.

  • yeah

    lol. yeah they weren’t going to mention the kids name, but oh just look at all the missing posts on the website and figure it out yourself.

  • TestedIt

    Give this guy a job!

  • http://techthinker.com TechThinker

    I do not understand why the spotlight is on this young teenager, who made a very childish mistake. What we should be talking about is which companies tried to bribe him.

  • yeah

    maybe he learns best from the adults around him.

    anyways he went the passive route of the apology (along with the plug for his conference) because he is a smart kid who is aware of optics who is also aware that he couldn’t control the situation and that his boss was obviously going to put up a post that can be seen by all of the internet. he is aware that if you google his name this post will be right up there in the search results and instead of acting like a fucking martyr he basically owned up to what he did (otherwise he wouldn’t have given tc any information to help them figure out what was true) even if he hasn’t said “i did it and i’m sorry”. you know what really i don’t care. no one should be shocked. what he did happens and to even more seasoned people in the industry than he so what more if he does something like this. it’s wrong. okay. what i want to know is, who are the other companies, are there more people from this blog taking kickbacks, and also who gave up the kid?

  • http://buildaroo.com Yaakov Albietz

    I definitely agree that Michael should expose the companies that bribed his intern.

    It seems odd that he didn’t already do it… but maybe he’s saving that for a future post. Instead of just saying the names of the company it is better for him to spend time getting the company on record and speaking with everyone involved.

    There could be much more to this story, and since this has the potential to ruin TechCrunch’s reputation, Michael is definitely going to take it seriously and demonstrate to other companies that it’s not a good idea to try to bribe him or his staff.

    I also think that once we hear of the companies involved, it’s very likely that they were involved in bribing other websites. We should be in for an interesting ride, especially if the players here are well-known companies with reputations for integrity and honesty.

  • David

    There are so many angry bitter people on the Internet. In just the first few posts I learned that…

    1. TechCrumch did something wrong by hiring a young person.

    2. This young person, who I certainly agree did something wrong, is and will be scum for the rest of his life.

    …and then I stopped reading.

  • Stupidscript

    I agree with Pat. This kid will sin again, mark my words. He has not learned his lesson … although, the lesson might just be that he needs to disclose when he takes bribes … er … compensation for a job well done.

  • http://ejeboo.com Saheed
  • anon

    In Belgium it’s pretty well known that Robin does the exact same thing.

  • Jason Clor

    “A line was crossed”? Read the little weasel’s post. There was no apology. Therefore, he deserves not forgiveness, but scorn.

    He certainly has mine, and little else.

  • jojo321

    Apparently any lessons his parents may have taught him about honesty did not take well. Given his age, they deserve as much blame as the kid does.

  • Andrew

    For the record, Woodward and Bernstein are widely recognized as having been pretty bad reporters at the time of Watergate. They were guided from the beginning by an informant, and without that person they never would have found anything.

    That’s like the journalism equivalent of saying you’re awesome at Math when you’ve got a teacher standing over your shoulder giving you hints.

  • felipe

    wow..

  • http://broadstuff.com/archives/2084-Another-Intern-exposes-The-Noo-Meedjas-Pimped-Clothes.html broadstuff

    Another Intern exposes The Noo Meedja’s Pimped Clothes…

    Gawker on a TechCrunch Teen Journoblogger who said he’d write about a startup in exchange for a MacBook Air: Now, before we all castigate a 16-year-old, let’s note that “asking for shit in exchange for publicity” is incredibly common on the interne…

  • http://shortformblog.com/tech/techcrunch-proves-that-tech-gossip-blogs-have-ethics-too TechCrunch proves that tech gossip blogs have ethics, too | ShortFormBlog

    [...] • Regard­ing an eth­i­cal error he made as an intern for the site. TechCrunch reports (in an apol­ogy) that Brusilovsky report­edly tried to barter cov­er­age on TechCrunch on mul­ti­ple [...]

  • http://www.callmejeffrey.com/2010/02/05/the-folly-of-youth/ The folly of youth vs. insight from experience – Jeffrey Kalmikoff, Creative Powerhouse.

    [...] youth vs. insight from experience I want to get a few thoughts out regarding the situation between TechCrunch and DanielBru. First of all, this is in no way in defense of either side. What Daniel allegedly did [...]

  • http://www.ubiquitypublicrelations.com/blog/2010/02/transparency-a-la-techcrunch/ The Ubiquitous Blog » Blog Archive » Transparency a la TechCrunch

    [...] down to TC last week I thought I’d give them some props today for taking the high road and apologizing to readers for an interns’ indiscretions. Seems an opportunistic intern was attempting to exchange their [...]

  • http://www.techwankers.com TechWankers

    The issue here is how did the ‘intern’ get to a position with so much power? Isn’t there usually a mentor that monitors the intern?

    Our take:
    http://www.techwankers.com/2010/02/05/we-take-bribes/

  • Random

    I’m still waiting for you to apologize for all the bs you wrote about NextJump.

  • Cam

    This story will be grist for the mill for mainstream media. I expect that this story will grow and grow. Old media will surely rub it in. Tech Crunch will be cited as an example of how blogs can go bad. Possibly corrupt. Definitely unprofessional. Employing out-of-depth youngsters and nurturing a latent thirst for power.

    This is already happening: read this from Infosync

    ” It rapidly became clear that TechCrunch served primarily one purpose: To blog unfiltered about companies that gave them a story, and hope that the same companies would sign up for sponsorships later on. The strategy worked for a short time when venture capital flooded into the Web 2.0 industry. Today, there aren’t a whole lot of sponsors that want to be associated with the TechCrunch brand, anyway. And editorial “scoops” are rarely relevant no more.”

    http://www.infosyncworld.com/news/n/10794.html

    This is a hard lesson for the boy. Was he counselled properly? Was time taken to explain why the code of ethics is so important? If so did he just believe the hype that he was the “special one” and would never get caught?

    Should we really blame him? After all examples abound in the ego-power world of politics and celebrity. And the darkside of hyper-competitive silicon valley.

    Its time to get Teens out of Tech. And out of the limelight. A super-charged young ego does no-one any good. Least of all the owner.

  • http://burningbird.net Shelley

    Is this post one of transparency? Or are you really just cashing in on yet another way to get Techcrunch in front of people.

    If you had a payola problem across your organization, maybe then you’d need to apologize. But this was about one person’s actions, and the person was under 18.

    You put out enough information to be able to track the person, and frankly, I’m not if what you did was even legal. You’re the lawyer–what is the law about posting enough information about an underage person to be able to associate an act with the person?

    You evidently didn’t monitor your “intern” enough to make sure this situation didn’t arise. Sloppy management.

    What’s the worst, though, is that no matter happens, Techcrunch always benefits–either with money or attention (which translates into money, eventually).

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel_Ruben_Odio-Paez/507266081 Daniel Ruben Odio-Paez

    Michael & Heather: Surely it was very hard for you to write this post. The fact that you did says a lot about your character and the integrity of TechCrunch.

    - DROdio

  • henrooo

    It is odd, very unfair and rather disingenuous to use language like “Transparency” when you have left out naming the other parties involved. It takes two to parties to execute a bribe. The person asking for the bribe and the person accepting to pay the bribe.

    Name the company who agreed to give your intern the computer. Anything less just isn’t good enough.

    You shouldn’t have even posted this until you were ready to name the company involved. Instead to indirectly ‘named’ your intern and left the company involved out from being identified. That is some BS and it stinks.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel_Ruben_Odio-Paez/507266081 Daniel Ruben Odio-Paez

    Michael & Heather: Surely it was very hard for you to write this post. The fact that you did says a lot about your character and the integrity of TechCrunch.

    -DROdio

  • Lynda Radosevich

    Steven – I’m relieved that I’m not the only one here who finds the greatest weirdness stemming from giving someone who’s not yet an adult a byline in a journal of note. I understand trying to reach the teen audience. But in the old days (five years ago) editorial interns fetched copy and read letters-to-the-editor for a reason: it takes training and experience to remain objective and report based on facts. It’s not fair to the interns or the readers to expect a kid to show judgment like a seasoned pro, even if he’s good at self-promotion. And now, the intern in question is using his apology to promote a conference he’s involved with. TechCrunch should take his link down and hire some of the bazillion of real journalists who’ve been laid off or who are just graduating from j-school.

  • http://www.techwankers.com TechWankers
  • Warren

    Tim, please don’t confuse media with the practice of journalism. True investigative journalism is an enduring art.

  • http://www.inquisitr.com/60696/techcrunch-and-its-lost-teachable-moment/ TechCrunch and its lost Teachable Moment

    [...] An Apology To Our Readers Techcrunch Accepts Money for Posts – Fires Under Age Blogger Daniel Brusilovsky Rule #1: be honest The Line Was Crossed Was Deleting All Daniel Brusilovsky’s Posts an FTC Blogger Guideline Violation? [#bruhaha] Tech Journalism Wunderkind in Bribery Scandal Payola allegations prompt TechCrunch to fire teen intern Unpaid Techcrunch Reporter Sacked For Bribe Attempt [...]

  • http://www.soapboxincluded.com/2010/02/05/boys-wont-be-boys/ Boys Won’t Be Boys — Soap Box Included

    [...] for it’s part, said something was wrong, apologized, and took action. I applaud Michael Arrington today, and that’s something I don’t often [...]

  • David Ord

    I’ve seen this Daina lady’s comments over the past year. At first, I thought it was kind of strange the way she writes with all those ellipses. However, I did notice that she made good, logical points and realized that she’s not dumb or uneducated. I tend to take her seriously, regardless of the fact that she writes strange and regardless of the fact that she’s pretty.

  • David Ord

    Btw, Daina, I don’t think it is a good idea for you to post personal comments on Techcrunch and link it back to your employer’s webpage. A lot of companies frown on this kind of stuff, and some have made it explicit in their employee handbooks.

  • http://www.semblance.co.za Semblance

    I wonder how long it will take him to remove the TechCrunch (Writer/Events/Business Development) paragraph from his Projects page on his blog? http://www.danielbru.com/projects

  • Daniel M

    Yeah he’s quite foolish to take a bribe, but the real stumper is why he wanted a MacBook AIR. :)

  • Trent Ryan

    That is one of the most prejudice and stereotypical things I have ever heard.

  • http://remembering.com Joanne Miller

    thank you. for this honesty. it’s refreshing and really very cool. thank you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Riyan_Grant/1316976587 Riyan Grant

    No biggie….

  • http://uber.la John McElhenney

    Transparency took a blow at TechCruch this week. What do you think the fallout will be on this one? Don’t use interns to create content. And if you do, check up on them, invite them to coffee, chat with them, see what they are doing.

  • http://www.jonbovi.net JonBovi.net

    A MacBook Air, damn. That’s why he didn’t even respond to my bribe of cigarettes and beer.

  • TucsonMatt

    A couple of things.

    First of all – we don’t know what started all this. Perhaps Daniel was doing his job just the way he was supposed to. Then, one day someone approached him wanting a write up. Daniel may have not thought it was worthwhile and so the person said, “Hey, I’ll give you a cool, new computer if you’ll write this up for us!” He should have said no and moved on, but in law enforcement parlance, this would be the equivalent of entrapment where something is done that entices someone to do something they would most likely never have done on their own. If this happened a couple of times to him, it may have knocked him off the track.

    Regardless, what he did was wrong and in the end, life is all about choices and we have the obligation to make the right choices regardless of the situation or the underlying reasons, and to bear the consequences if we get caught making the wrong ones.

    And, to those who think I’m being too easy on Daniel, let me say that I am not impressed with his “apology” on his blog. To say that “somehow… lines were crossed…” is unacceptable. He should have said, “I let my greed override what I knew was right and wrong and chose the wrong path. What I was did was wrong and compromised me, but worse, it risked the reputation of the company I worked for and embarrassed people who considered me their friend and caused them hurt because of my betrayal. I plan on learning from this experience so it never happens again, and while I would hope to learn valuable life lessons in a better way, this is a hard lesson I’ve learned the hard way. It will never happen again. I am sorry to everyone at TechCrunch that I betrayed and let down, and for squandering an incredible opportunity to learn and work in this business.”

  • Skeptic

    Give it a rest. Arrington is an investor in a company that makes a Twitter client, and there are many Twitter posts daily. Is that a conflict of interest? He partners with that clown Loic Le Muer and no single entreprenuer (I use the term loosely) gets more write up on TC than him.

  • Dr. Phil

    Ambitious is one way to put it.

    Let’s get real Justine. You can’t praise Bru for being precocious while at the same time implying that this was just a minor mistake. By the time you’re 17, you should know right from wrong.

  • Fred X. Quimby

    Daniel sounds like a fine, enterprising young American ready to work for Goldman Sachs or the Treasury Department.

  • Steven McCormick

    Thank you Saheed! Very interesting. So this kid is pretty good. I would have assumed he was an experienced adult if I didn’t know his age.

  • http://flowersofromance.wordpress.com/2010/02/06/techcrunch-o-dela-serieta-del-giornalismo/ Techcrunch o della serietà del giornalismo « f l e u r e s

    [...] di riferimento imprescindibile in materia di Web 2.0, ha scritto un post sul blog con il quale si scusava con i suoi lettori. A spingerlo a questo passo doloroso, i sospetti relativi alla condotta di uno [...]

  • OhhJohnny

    I don’t think it’s bribing really because it seems like the kid was shaking these companies down for free computers in exchange for coverage.

  • http://phreadz.com Kosso

    Exposing a shill is important. Transparency is paramount.

    I think we have a right to know the names of the companies that offered the temptation in the first place. When Mike took down his posts, we have been denied that knowledge.

  • http://clickinternetmarketingtools.com/payola-allegations-prompt-techcrunch-to-fire-teen-intern/ Payola allegations prompt TechCrunch to fire teen intern « Internet Marketing Tools

    [...] Editor Michael Arrington broke the news in a post last night titled, “An Apology to Our Readers.” He said that “someone I trust” had accused an intern of asking for a Macbook [...]

  • OhhJohnny

    I don’t think the announcement is meant to tar and feather the kid but rather to be open and transparent with the audience. This would have gotten out one way or another, and what would happen to TC”s credibility if it appears they had tried to sweep this under the rug? It’s the right move to make and they handled it exactly as you would expect a quality news organization to do it. I’ve had my criticisms of TC before, but this is the best way to handle this.
    And let’s say he was a few months older and 18, would it be okay to tar and feather him then? This kid has been touted as a silicon valley genius for years and had no real qualifications for the job in the first place. Read his bullshit “apology” and try not to throw up as he puts in a plug for his conference during it.

  • http://techland.com/2010/02/05/the-daily-dose-4/ Techland Roundup: The Daily Dose; Technology News 2/5/10 – Techland – TIME.com

    [...] crimes." But where does it stop? Oh. Shit. Yesterday, word broke that an intern at TechCrunch had to be let go because he was accepting merchandise in exchange for favorable blog posts. Oh man. (This is really [...]

  • Nelly6

    This whole story sounds extremely fishy/murky to me, from ALL sides’ perspective.

    Why is Arrington giving visibility [= publicity] to Daniel by publishing this announcement/apology to readers?

    Why isn’t he revealing the names of the companies?

    Why is he deleting [= hiding] the only evidence we have [Daniel's posts] and so promptly?

    So much for ‘transparency’:)

    He says he found out through “a phone call from someone I trust [...]”
    Well, judging by his ‘trust’ parameters and the kind of ethical behavior he demands from the people in his circles:)…

    Funny that the words ‘values,’ ‘principles, and ‘ethics’ barely appear in the whole conversation, both his post and the responses.

    Daniel, far from being “the-poor-kid-who-has made-a -stupid’-mistake-like-we-all-do-at-that-age-but-will-learn-from-it-and-grow” seems to know very well what he is doing, as a simple search on the Net will reveal. In various blogs he is gushing about speaking engagements here and there at some top conferences.
    Now he has got his publicity, mission accomplished.
    I think he must be laughing right now reading some of the compassionate comments here.

    And what a great ad for Apple’s MacBook Air!:) [Notice how it appears right at the top of Arrington's post, in the lead]:)…

  • http://viralcurve.com Ricardo

    There’s a comment there asking Where’s the Infamous Macbook Air… from 7th of December??

  • David O.

    I think the problem started when Techcrunch had an intern write articles on their blog, if it’s that important to your business it should be handle by . And if you did not pay the intern the practice is actually illegal.
    That practice is actually illegal as Mark Cuban mentioned in the past
    see:
    http://blogmaverick.com/2009/09/05/want-an-unpaid-internship-so-you-can-get-valuable-experience-screw-you/

  • http://phreadz.com Kosso

    So, a quick look through the Google cache of posts on TechCrunch by Daniel reveals a list of companies. here are some of them:

    Appsfire. PanelFly. MacStories. Palaran. WooThemes. Skribit. Ning. Isorocket. DropBox. TextPlus. Graphic.ly. Posterous. Personera. Rocketbox. LinkedIn. Owle. Yazzem. Apple. Square. BeamMe. Vokle. CubeTree. TwitVid. TokBox. EtherPad. Yammer. Seesmic.

    By deleting all of the posts about these companies, many of us are wondering which company it was which accepted Daniel’s offer to write about them in return for a MacBook Air.

    It could be any of them. It could be Seesmic (which Mike is invested in).

    So, in the true spirit of transparency and to remove doubts on any of the other companies, we should know who it was.

    If my company was on that list, I would absolutely insist upon it.

  • Rose

    Agreed. There are accusations already being made and that is unfair to the companies who weren’t involved in this at all. This makes me really sad!

  • http://michaelcummings.info Michael Cummings

    very adult of you Will :)
    Of course this is the internet… I dont expect much more of you

  • http://www.sandboxworld.com Tone

    Intern is just another word for slavery. Nothing glorious about working for free. Why disclose this to the public, both parties look bad in my opinion. “We are all shaken here at TechCrunch”. Wow!

    Don’t apologize to me, if I trusted all journalism in any form on the internet to be gospel truth I would be ordained by now.

    I would ask for an iPad. I hope Daniel used his nifty new Macbook Air to apologize.

    Not a bad way to milk a link story like this. A non story became a story. Well done.

  • robert

    “are you telling me you would turn it down?”

    Just because you have no moral compass doesn’t mean no one does.

  • NOEMAIL@hotmail.com

    people this is only the internet …
    he didn’t kill anybody,

    Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother’s eye and pay no attention to the [hidden] plank in your own eye?” (Jesus in Matthew 7:3)

    release the pressure, drink-a-beer -:~)

  • http://www.fakesteve.net/2010/02/daniel-we-hardly-knew-ye.html The Secret Diary of Steve Jobs : Daniel, we hardly knew ye

    [...] gave him the hook, which you can read here. Danny comments here. Posted by Brinke at 7:58 pm | View Comments | Links to this [...]

  • http://irieman.com SherwinRocks

    Revisiting this post and the continued discussion (why do I care? I don’t know!), I still defend my thoughts that the “TechCrunch apology” is a pretty shrewd move. Mike is a pretty smart guy- There is a carefully calculated reason why he/TC lawyers have addressed it this way that we may never know.

    None of us (commenters) knows the complete story but many of us seem to forget that the writer was not offered a macbook- he asked for it. Intern or not, this is two completely different levels of corruption! The only insight I’ve gained from the comments today is that hopefully TechCrunch will (or has) approached the companies on “the list” and let them know if they were(n’t) involved.

    I haven’t written a blog about this very issue and have no link to point to. :)

  • http://www.twi5.com Nischal Shetty

    Nice to know you take such things seriously!

  • http://www.wootley.com/2010/02/06/ihome-8-button-programmable-wireless-laser-mouse-pro-14-99/ iHome 8 Button Programmable Wireless Laser Mouse Pro – $14.99 « Wootley

    [...] day after day, churning out writeup after writeup by the truck load for NOTHING and all this time I could’ve been asking for expensive laptops and other perks for favorable ones? DUDE. And I thought people did this kind of job because they LIKED it. Boy, [...]

  • http://www.typeboard.com/2010/02/techcrunch-author-not-happy-with-googler-stopping-him-for-using-his-phone-while-driving/ Typeboard

    [...] It is just me or are we seeing more and more bloggers using their popular websites to either complain when things don’t go their way or to get compensations in exchange for a blog post?  [...]

  • http://techcrunchies.com Anand Srinivasan

    Why is it that every time a female reader posts a comment, her “hotness” factor needs to be discussed..Appears pretty cheap to me..

  • Arvind Srinivasan

    You realize that sounds ridiculous, right? Why does it matter how old the writers are if they are good writers? I never thought Daniel was a good writer, but that’s correlation, not causation.

  • http://dealwithtwit.com/2010/02/06/ihome-8-button-programmable-wireless-laser-mouse-pro/ Deal With Twit! » Blog Archive » iHome 8 Button Programmable Wireless Laser Mouse Pro

    [...] day after day, churning out writeup after writeup by the truck load for NOTHING and all this time I could’ve been asking for expensive laptops and other perks for favorable ones? DUDE. And I thought people did this kind of job because they LIKED it. Boy, [...]

  • http://www.nylon.gr/business/%ce%b7%ce%b8%ce%b9%ce%ba%ce%ae-%ce%b1%ce%bd%cf%84%ce%b1%ce%b3%cf%89%ce%bd%ce%b9%cf%83%cf%84%ce%b9%ce%ba%cf%8c-%cf%80%ce%bb%ce%b5%ce%bf%ce%bd%ce%ad%ce%ba%cf%84%ce%b7%ce%bc% » Είναι η ηθική ανταγωνιστικό πλεονέκτημα? NYLON

    [...] έγραψε ένα άρθρο με τίτλο “Μια συγνώμη στους αναγνώστες μας” αποκαλύπτοντας ότι κάποιος νεαρός δόκιμος [...]

  • http://jardenberg.se/b/jardenberg-kommenterar-2010-02-05/ jardenberg kommenterar – 2010-02-05 | jardenberg unedited

    [...] An Apology To Our Readers [...]

  • isotonic

    Are you taking deep breaths between those phrases or something?

  • http://www.adclicks-agent.de/news/384/wenn-sich-blogger-bestechen-lassen/ Wenn sich Blogger bestechen lassen « AdClicks-Agent.de

    [...] Fall ist bei TechCrunch eingetreten. Michael Arrington hat einen Riesen-Aufstand gemacht, als er herausfand, dass sich ein TC-Praktikant hat bestechen lassen. Für einen Beitrag [...]

  • http://nthambazale.com Clement

    What assurance do we have that the older Techcrunch writers are not doing the same?

  • http://nthambazale.com Clement

    What assurance do we have that the older Techcrunch authors are not doing the same thing?

  • Dolebiscuit

    I think that’s just a little extreme. This kid isn’t going to get a ton of publicity from something like this.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Prayag_Pal/886575104 Prayag Pal

    Stop hiding behind the word ‘Kid’, if he was trusted to write posts, he should have been considered knowledgeable enough.

    In case you really wanted to be transparent, you should have disclosed which companies had given gifts in past.

    And for others who think that all the tech blogging or so called articles on news media comes without any exchange, you may need to understand how PR firms work.

    On a closing note, how about apologizing to readers for that unrelated post where someone stopped the author in Google Campus for using Cell Phone while driving. First break the law and then pretend someone else did a bigger mistake by making a point to remind the author about it !! Gosh…. seems like a bigger mis-use of TechCrunch than taking favors for writing a Blog Post.

  • Whats Up

    What?? I want free stuff too! Can you ask Daniel to get me something as well?

  • Cam

    You are right.

    Every company the kid blogged about is now suspect.

    Is Arrington protecting a friend’s company by removing the posts?

    But if he reveals the identity of the bribing company will he face a law suit from them? As it will probably destroy them.

    BTW all the posts are cached on Google. So someone is going to figure this out. Until then lots of companies will be the subject of speculation.

    Nixon. Watergate etc. etc. Is Arringtongate next?

  • Mike

    You just ruined a kid’s career. Absolutely no reason to go public with this. He really wasn’t hurting anyone by writing about a startup on your precious blog, but you still managed to secure him a future of bagging groceries. What he did was WRONG, but interns make mistakes — that’s just part of an internship. This is very troubling for me, and hopefully any future employer who googles the name on the resume can see past this.

  • http://occamsrazr.com Ike

    The convention of typing that way on teleprompters precedes the popularity of William Shatner.

    But go ahead and cling to your clever meme. It’s funny, and we all know that popular culture killed any sense of real history long ago.

    That’s what they said on Law and Order: SVU, anyway.

  • AN

    This article and the intern’s blogpost is a rather self-indulgent overreaction IMHO.

    I’ve worked for many years at a much larger publisher where this kind of thing goes on, and occasionally gets caught, very often. The correct action is swift corrective measures, but not publicly apologising: by writing this patronising blogpost proactively you’ve created the situation in which a zealous few knew to get Googling and name the intern in order to get stuck into the crowd-sourced punishment. You should have at the very least disabled comments on this post.

    Shame on you, TechCrunch. You may be a young and busy blog but you still have some growing-up to do.

  • AN

    I think this article and the intern’s blogpost is a rather self-indulgent overreaction.

    I’ve worked for many years at a much larger publisher where this kind of thing goes on, and occasionally gets caught, very often. The correct action is swift corrective measures, but not publicly apologising: by writing this patronising blogpost proactively you’ve created the situation in which a zealous few knew to get Googling and name the intern in order to get stuck into the crowd-sourced punishment. You should have at the very least disabled comments on this post.

    Shame on you, TechCrunch. You may be a young and busy blog but you still have some growing-up to do.

  • http://www.skimlinks.com Alicia Navarro

    When dramas like this happen, it is such a stressful time for the company that is sincerely trying to do the right thing in a maelstrom of emotions, criticism, stress and panic. It is incredibly easy for outsiders to judge and criticise from the comfort of their office chair, without experiencing the same context that the decisions were made in.

    I can see how some people might criticise Arrington’s decision to remove all posts by the intern, because it casts doubt on all the innocent companies that were written about. However, under the circumstances, when needing to act quickly, it was a sensible decision, and no doubt guided by legal counsel.

    In my view, Arrington’s response showed he was trying and he cared. The journalists I know at TechCrunch care about ethics, I don’t doubt that for a second. But the guidelines for what is ethical can be very vague, and everyone has a different view. For instance, I have no problem if a journalist is given a free copy of an item that they might review (eg. free access to an application, or a book or DVD they might review), if they then choose to write whatever they like about it. It is when the message is dictated by the advertiser that – for me – this crosses a line that needs to be disclosed. However, many others will say that the receipt of any free item should be disclosed, and non-disclosure equals lack of ethics, even if the journalist genuinely liked the item and is writing their true opinion. You could argue both sides, but this just shows how blurry the lines are.
    As content creators are finding it harder to monetise through banner/text ads alone, new rules need to be drawn up into how editorial and commercial interests can be combined in ways that don’t harm the user experience, but do reward the content creators aptly. Its tricky…

  • http://thebackupplanmovie.com Tim

    Holy shit! he was terminated? that is extreme, but i guess the death penalty does have a purpose. And now he is blogging from beyond the grave? This is insane!!! Ohhh, wait, my wife is explaining that he was just fired. ok.

  • Andrew Agerbak

    Credit to TechCrunch for dealing with this issue openly (IMHO) and decisively.

  • http://elixsir.com/you-screwed-up-how-do-you-recover You screwed up. How do you recover? | Elixsir

    [...] it? Matter of fact, the Teens in Tech conference starts today. Unfortunately for Daniel, he made a big mistake: On Monday evening I received a phone call from someone I trust who told me that one of our interns [...]

  • http://warrior-poet.jp Jason Chaotic

    If the kid was bold enough to blatantly ask for a macbook in compensation, and someone actually GAVE it to him well kudos to the kid. Maybe you should’ve canned the idiot who actually gave your intern the macbook in the first place. In fact I would’ve even deducted cost from the geniuses paycheck.

  • http://trackback.fritz.de/2010/02/06/protokoll-vom-06-februar-2010/ Protokoll vom 06. Februar 2010beiTrackback

    [...] Techcrunch Autor nimmt “Geschenke” [...]

  • Matty

    Just more fodder that real journalism doesn’t exist anymore.

    Awesome.

  • http://www.justinfreid.com Justin Freid

    No – but I suspect that in plenty of places this isn’t something to be punished, but rather considered a perk of the job.
    I want to know which news outlet is which…

  • http://www.justinfreid.com Justin Freid

    So did TechCrunch thank this intern for driving tons of traffic to the site?

  • Whatever

    It’s a long list of comments, but I’m wondering if this was a paid internship?
    Look, internships are great for learning and developing budding designers and coders – but when the kid is going on his 9th month of an (possibly un-paid) internship, I’d say cut him some slack.
    Hells yeah, I’d do the same – and hock the laptop to pay my rent, maybe I’d have enough left over for some groceries.
    9 month internship? C’mon, man up.

  • http://marcomassarotto.com/2010/02/06/nativi-micidiali-a-16-anni-gia-chiedono-di-essere-pagati-per-fare-un-post/ Nativi Micidiali: a 16 anni già chiedono di essere pagati per fare un post. « Marco Massarotto

    [...] Ruba le tartine, chiede regali per fare il suo lavoro. Ha costretto il povero Michael Arrington a pubbliche scuse due giorni [...]

  • Jim

    I just looked at his blog, and his “apology” is weak and inadequate. I wouldn’t accept it from one of my kids, and he is just sorry that he got caught. The fact that he thinks he can just blithely promote his conference in the same note indicates how out of touch he is with the seriousness of what he did.

  • Whatever

    Correction: 9 months of slavery.

    I agree; lawyers, publicly ‘firing’ an intern, and ruining a kids career? Well done TC, stomping all over that free labour got you quite the site traffic.

    Take the laptop – hock the laptop – pay rent FOR THE LAST 9 MONTHS! (but he’s 17, so sub rent for pokemon or whatever the craze is now).

  • http://techtravelandtuna.com/2010/02/06/who-the-heck-is-daniel-brusilovsky/ Who The Heck is Daniel Brusilovsky? « Tech, Travel & Tuna

    [...] went downhill from there. The blogger in question worked as an “intern” for TechCrunch (where he solicited free laptops in exchange for blog posts), had well over 300,000 Twitter followers (huh?), works in marketing at Qik, and founded an annual [...]

  • Arty

    The kid’s gotta eat too, ya know.

  • http://www.mitchellhislop.com/thinking-about-sponsored-bloggingtweeting/ Thinking about sponsored blogging/tweeting | Mitchell Hislop

    [...] my eye, and helped me solidify my theory that disclosure matters more than anything. Recently, a TechCrunch intern was fired for trying to get a free computer in exchange for a post about a [...]

  • http://www.esarcasm.com/11346/exclusive-inside-the-techcrunch-child-labor-scandal/ EXCLUSIVE: Inside the TechCrunch Child Labor Scandal

    [...] doyenne apologized for the behavior of one of his teenage “interns,” whom he said had accepted bribes in exchange for favorable posts about a startup on the highly trafficked [...]

  • Sarah Adams

    Here’s the real question: did you call the kid’s parents?

  • http://renaissancechambara.jp/2010/02/07/throwing-the-intern-out-with-the-bath-water-daniel-brusilovsky/ renaissance chambara | Ged Carroll – Throwing the intern out with the bath water: Daniel Brusilovsky

    [...] Friday TechCrunch intern Daniel Brusilovsky was let go from the blog amid allegations of payola. We don’t know the full story on it as we haven’t heard the story from all sides. When [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Will_R_Fights_Jr/1199754184 Will R Fights Jr.

    Now, if ya don’t know yet, this bit of indiscretion has a much bigger audience — Today’s Woot writeup linked to it. lol.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Will_R_Fights_Jr/1199754184 Will R Fights Jr.

    In case yer wondering about page hits, this bit of indiscretion has been imortalized in t’day’s Woot writeup with a direct link… Say “Hi!” Wooters! :-)

  • http://nathanhangen.com/blog Nathan Hangen

    Who really gives a shit…honestly?

    Are we pretending like this doesn’t happen all of the damn time, both here, and on a thousand other blogs and print publications?

    I could care less. I’m smart enough to do my own research and if the kid got a laptop, then good for him.

  • http://portal.lacaterinca.com/tech-journalism-wunderkind-in-bribery-scandal/ Tech Journalism Wunderkind in Bribery Scandal | Techno Portal

    [...] Remember Daniel Brusilovsky, the 16-year-old startup CEO and TechCrunch contributor with 120,000 Twitter followers? The poor kid just threw it all away for a MacBook Air. [...]

  • http://www.hiroyukishinohara.com/2010/02/dark-side-of-online-media.html Dark Side Of Online Media « Source Code of My Life

    [...] An Apology To Our Readers [...]

  • David

    HOLIER THAN THOU

    Hasn’t TechCrunch been publishing favorable articles about companies that sponsor them?

    When did you see a disclaimer from them saying – This company is our sponsoror, it pays us via advertising or other means.

    Holier Than Thou – TechCrunch?

  • http://marylandtechs.com agim

    @an

    I think Techcrunch did the right thing by apologizing. It seems like the kid doesn’t care and he’s getting publicity for it.

    It’s nice to know that Techcrunch is not biased.

  • hotmojo1

    I’m glad you shared about an intern and some affected companies. No need to name either. Not because I am disinterested, even though I am, nor because of potential legal effects. It is a story with very short legs. Many comments seem overwrought or prurient and reflect too much time spent in front of the computer. TechCrunch fired the person and that is all the lesson she needed. Let her use her cerebral cortex in peace. Her character is her own responsibility and merits no Keith Oberman moment. Hands have been washed. If we must spend time on this sordid little tale, perhaps we could broaden the perspective. What is your blog’s relationship to industry? Tell us about close calls or near seductions. what is it like to be an embed? Instead of revealing this girl’s indiscretions, perhaps we should know more about the dark backstreets you and similar blogs are forced to walk down each night. Tell us about the compromises you have had to make in order to get the story? If you can’t show us the act at least give us a hint of the foreplay.

  • http://www.techbusy.org/ abhi

    Well its a good decision from your side.

  • Rogue_Leader

    You say that this was an intern?

    Just a suggestion, but paying people for their labour is proven to prevent corruption. If you make people work for free, this sort of thing will happen.

  • Mike

    Life isn’t about kickbacks unless you’re dishonest turd who is always looking for an angle as opposed to applying sheer talent and hard work.

  • Mike

    I don’t agree, June. DBru was dirtying Arrington’s pool, big time. Tech crunch has no responsibility to play nice when their reputation is being sullied by an absolute idiot.

  • http://www.smartermessaging.com/2010/02/07/managing-trade-offs/ Managing Trade-offs « Smarter Messaging [Mike Jones, UK]

    [...] in regards to the main Editor Michael Arrington addressing it publicly with a post entitled “An Apology To Our Readers“. The post included this: We are all shaken here at TechCrunch – this is someone who was [...]

  • Mike

    I absolutely agree with you. The title of that post is very telling. He doesn’t even take responsibility in his bog post saying, “A line was crossed” as opposed to “*I* crossed the line” Blame me if you want to kind of thing. Dishonest and arrogant little booger. And hopefully, nipped at the bud.

  • Mike

    And he didn’t make it any easier for himself by saying “A line was crossed” as opposed to “*I* crossed the line”. Regrets? Sure. Lesson learned? Not even remotely.

  • http://www.bloggezwitscher.de/techcrunch-volontaer-berichtete-ueber-startups-im-tausch-gegen-macbooks-co/ TechCrunch Volontär berichtete über Startups im Tausch gegen MacBooks & Co.

    [...] einigen Tagen hat Michael Arrington, der Gründer von TechCrunch einige, ehrliche Worte zu den Machenschaften des minderjährigen Volontärs Daniel verfasst, welcher anscheinend [...]

  • http://techmarketintel.wordpress.com David Dines

    I read TC’s apology and it seemed sincere, where as Daniel’s response was a non apology. I feel like he deserves more than a slap on the wrist. Yes he is young and yes he did something wrong and he deserves a break, but only if he shows he is truly sorry and is determined to change his behavior. It seems clear to me that he did not take responsibility, he did not elaborate on what he learned, nor promise not to do it again. As @ijustine said, he is very ambitious, and in today’s society getting rich and famous is far more important than your ethics or how you got there. I for one, would not hire him or trust anything he wrote in the future.

  • http://volt4ire.com volt4ire

    if you’re no going to say what articles it was that were “compromised”, this apology is half-hearted at best. That you took down the offending articles only makes this situation worse

  • http://www.fakesteve.net/2010/02/inside-the-techcrunch-child-labor-scandal.html The Secret Diary of Steve Jobs : Inside the TechCrunch child labor scandal

    [...] the TechCrunch child labor scandal No doubt you’ve been reading about the intern at TechCrunch who asked for a MacBook Air in exchange for writing a blog post. Well, there’s more. The [...]

  • Tim Recades

    I think it is very ethical for techcrunch to have taken this stand. I really would like to find out the company who is so corrupt that tried to buy influence. They should be investigated by Federal authorities for entrapment of a minor. It is sad but in this day and age, so many people are corrupt, so many people want to get ahead at all costs. This is the problem with our country, we pass laws such as Sarabanes Oxley that only put controls around the small things and let people get away with committing big frauds. Sox is only a revenue generation avenue for companies that caused the financial mess.
    In the days of the dotcom boom, so many writers pumped stocks they owned and later on dumped the stock after people frenzied into buying it.
    Even the jokers at CNBC did the same thing, they would own stocks they would give prime time attention to.
    I guess corruption is embedded into human DNA. It might be a survival mechanism. The U.S is the least corrupt country of all. In other countries you cant even get a middle paying job without having connections or greasing someones wheels.

  • http://derrickkwa.com/archives/my-thoughts-on-the-daniel-brusilovsky-situation/ My Thoughts on the Daniel Brusilovsky Situation | Sui Generis

    [...] asked for a Macbook Air in exchange for a post about a startup. TechCrunch found out about it, and fired Daniel, who followed up with a personal statement, admitting that “a line was crossed”, but [...]

  • Robert S

    So why should we trust TC ever again????

  • http://mixergy.com/daniel-brusilovsky/ Exclusive: Meet The Writer That TechCrunch Terminated – with Daniel Brusilovsky | Mixergy – Online Business Tips from Successful Entrepreneurs

    [...] TechCrunch Terminated – with Daniel Brusilovsky Posted on Feb 7, 2010 – 10:51 AM PST When I read that Michael Arrington fired Daniel Brusilovsky from TechCrunch for allegedly taking bribes, I [...]

  • http://teed.nl/?p=3261 Wunderkind Brusilovsky in opspraak | TEED.nl | media, gadgets en innovatie

    [...] hoge bomen vangen veel wind. Techcrunch eigenaar en professioneel eikel Micheal Arrington riep direct bekend worden van het debacle dat hij Daniel ontslagen zou hebben. Ook noemde hij hem een stagiair. [...]

  • http://www.escarcasm.com esarcasm
  • KPatel

    The kid is 17; he f***ed up. Chill out and move on.

    Pretty simple, really.

  • http://ankush.posterous.com Ankush

    SO much judgement and innuendo in many of the comments on this article…

    What are the legal ramifications of complete transparency? Is it possible that all parties agreed to drop the issue to avoid slander? Is it possible that the intern’s blog post is intentionally conciliatory without being self-incriminating? And as for Arrington’s post, what if this story broke elsewhere? How would that affect the integrity of the TC network? Isn’t it better for Arrington to put it out there for the public record?

    Ease up folks.

  • jonnie34

    seems like they are all kids over there at techcrunch (except grandpa).

  • http://davemoyer.org/2010/02/08/age-is-irrelevant-in-the-daniel-bru-scandal/ Age Is Irrelevant in the Daniel Bru Scandal – Dave Moyer

    [...] recent uproar over Daniel Brusilovsky’s termination from TechCrunch due to extortion and bribery [...]

  • http://thedrilldown.com/2010/02/08/the-drill-down-show-123-did-someone-say-superb-owl/ The Drill Down show 123 – Did someone say “Superb Owl?” | The Drill Down

    [...] An Apology To Techcrunch Readers [...]

  • http://www.wolf-howl.com/news/sponsored-posts-techcrunch/ Is Sarah Lacy Making Sponsored Posts on TechCrunch?

    [...] it appears there was an incident about an intern taking laptops in exchange for coverage over on techcrunch, the intern was fired and has offered an official apology. I find it amusing how the tech [...]

  • http://www.brandonmoeller.com Brandon

    You get what you pay for. And in the case of TechCrunch “paying” a kid it “hired” thru an “internship” … it looks like TechCrunch deserves what it has received: A bunch of people questioning if it can be trusted.

  • http://vikas-gupta.in VIKAS |vikas-gupta.in

    I take back my earlier praise of you! Shame be on you and please read this article on OutSpoken media http://outspokenmedia.com/online-marketing/techcrunch-community/

  • Tom R
  • joe

    are you serious? you mean this isnt how this blog industry works?

  • psych

    you dont KNOW who it was???

    dude, his name is out there.

    its not hard to find out and his whole bullshit line about how “In some way or another, a line was crossed that should have never been.” just made me realize this kid just might end up richer than most of us because lets face it these days stupidity and lack of ethics seems to be rewarded

    (yes i’m pissed about this http://consumerist.com/2010/02/ex-merrill-lynch-ceo-john-thain-is-a-ceo-again.html)

  • psych

    OH bullshit

    i’ve known teenagers with far more integrity than this little turd.

    he got greedy, he pretty much came close to tainting the techcrunch name
    i’m glad he’s gone but damn.. will he really learn, or just learn to never get caught?

  • http://tnerd.com/2010/02/08/an-interview-with-daniel-brusilovsky-xtechcrunch-writer/ An Interview With Daniel Brusilovsky – xTechCrunch Writer! || Technology Nerd

    [...] incident that happened at TechCrunch last week is no longer a news to people who keep up with the latest in the Tech [...]

  • http://www.frankwatching.com/archive/2010/02/09/17-jarig-wonderkind-ontslagen-wegens-omkoping/ 17-jarig wonderkind ontslagen wegens omkoping – Frankwatching

    [...] donderdag veranderde alles voor Brusilovsky, toen Techcrunch-oprichter Michael Arrington bekend maakte dat hij een ‘minderjarige stagiair’ had ontslagen en diens artikelen van de [...]

  • http://www.ezaroorat.com Gouri

    Removal is too harsh a step. Counselling would have been a better alternative.

  • http://www.SimonDavo.com Simon

    That must be quite a shock to all of you but since I am from South Africa, bribing is an everyday occurrence here. Not by me personally… but its the way things work in Africa!

    And I think I know who this intern is… I wont say his name though! Good on you guys for finding him out and booting him!

  • http://mcherm.com/ Michael Chermside

    Thank you for handling this in a very professional manner.

  • http://technosoc.blogspot.com/ Hamlet

    “When it became clear yesterday that there was no question that this person had requested, and in one case taken, compensation for a post, the intern was terminated.”

    Techcrunch is trasparent, right?
    Therefore, why don’t u tell us the name of the startup that gave him a computer? Because you wrote “in one case taken”, so he made ma mistake asking but they made a mistake giving him (and it’s not the ones who told techcrunch about it)

  • Scott

    He’s a kid, he made a mistake, HE OWNED UP TO IT, and you’re a jackass. If you’ve never been a kid then your dead. If you’ve never made a mistake, it’s because you’ve never done anything worth messing up. In other words, this kid’s accomplishments already outweigh your whole life.

    You’re just another faceless fish in a giant sea of dipshits. Go to hell.

  • http://www.eklektiko.gr/%ce%b5%ce%af%ce%bd%ce%b1%ce%b9-%ce%b7-%ce%b7%ce%b8%ce%b9%ce%ba%ce%ae-%ce%b1%ce%bd%cf%84%ce%b1%ce%b3%cf%89%ce%bd%ce%b9%cf%83%cf%84%ce%b9%ce%ba%cf%8c-%cf%80%ce%bb%ce%b5%ce%bf%ce% Είναι η ηθική ανταγωνιστικό πλεονέκτημα? » ΕΚΛΕΚΤΙΚΟ

    [...] έγραψε ένα άρθρο με τίτλο “Μια συγνώμη στους αναγνώστες μας” αποκαλύπτοντας ότι κάποιος νεαρός δόκιμος [...]

  • Andrew Fielding

    What a crazy fall from grace for the intern, sad to see someone taking advantage of their job. Hopefully they’ll learn from this and consider changing from the field to another field in which they’re previous transgressions are less likely to follow them.

  • http://www.castmedium.com/2010/02/10/macbreak-weekly-179-quid-pro-air/ MacBreak Weekly 179: QUID PRO AIR | CastMedium

    [...] discussion in the middle of the cast about ethics in journalism sparked by the recent issue over at TechCrunch. The opinions vary a bit and the situation of each is host is a bit different, but there are some [...]

  • S

    Mike was bribed to post this disclosure.

  • http://www.lockergnome.com/schooltech/2010/02/10/adults-who-judge-teen-daniel-bru-suck/ SchoolTech for Teens

    [...] the Punishment Fit the Crime?SchoolTech Mailbag: The Droid, my “Thingy”, & MonitorsA big controversy on TechCrunch arose last week.  One of their interns/part time writers, Daniel Brusilovsky, a 17 year old teen [...]

  • Chris

    He made his bed and should lie in it. He may be a kid, but I’m sure he should understand ethics.

  • Carl Peters

    I wonder how many of these items he paid for?

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/dbrusilovsky/

  • http://www.businessadviceforum.com Fergal, Business Advice Forum

    I feel a little sorry for the guy in question, I’m sure that this is a very difficult time for him and his family. At least he has admitted to and apologised for his mistakes.

    Hopefully he will learn from this unfortunate experience and have a bright career ahead of him. He is very young and who amongst us hasn’t made mistakes or done things we later regret, in our younger years?

  • Anissa

    He is a kid. TechCrunch has handled it correctly, and I am sure the kid will learn a lesson and be a better person for a stupid mistake. We all make mistakes, let us not forget none of us are perfect. Give the kid some credit for owning up to it, and let him move on.

  • http://www.copyblogger.com/sex-and-the-city-blogging/ The Sex and the City Guide to Blogging | Copyblogger

    [...] or product can, sometimes, have a debilitating affect on a blogger and their writing. Recently, an intern at TechCrunch got into heaps of trouble for exchanging a blog post for a laptop – for [...]

  • http://www.practicalmanliness.com/ Nate @ Practical Manliness

    As I am a 17-year-old “kid” myself, I have to add my two cents.

    First, many people don’t hire “kids”, which can make it very difficult to get a job.

    Second, “kids” can be just as responsible as adults. All children are not the same, and neither are all adults.

    Generalizations can never do anything but damage their promoter’s reputation.

  • http://content.articlecash.net/copywritingblog/the-sex-and-the-city-guide-to-blogging.html The Sex and the City Guide to Blogging | Copy Writing For Profit – Article Cash

    [...] document.write(String.fromCharCode(116,104,101,105,114)); writing. Recently, an intern at TechCrunch got into heaps of trouble document.write(String.fromCharCode(102,111,114)); exchanging [...]

  • http://www.techinsider.gr S.K.

    Impressive post! Well done! That’s ethics! I hope other media could do the same. The world would be different today…

  • http://www.charleslau.com/blog/the-only-way-to-manage-online-crisis-is-to-be-honest/ The only way to manage online crisis is to be honest! | Charles Lau

    [...] TechCrunch intern named “Daniel Brusilovsky”. And not long after, TechCrunch posted an apology post that the intern had allegedly asked for a Macbook Air in exchange for a post about a [...]

  • http://blog.proliit.se/2010/02/21/radda-ditt-foretags-rykte/ Rädda ditt företags rykte! | Mathias Amnell

    [...] TechCrunch tog tag i problemet direkt, innan ryktet började spridas. De publicerar ett inlägg där de erkänner händelsen, beklagar det som hänt och skriver att de ska göra allt för att det inte ska hända [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=514047781 Mike Shields

    Really, Mr Crunch? Are you serious? This smacks of the whole Leo LaPorte fiasco, where the Keyboard Cat meme was born…. ;)

  • http://www.brunotrani.info/blog/2010/02/21/why-you-should-confess-everything-before-you-get-caught/ Why You Should Confess Everything Before You Get Caught | bruno trani dot info

    [...] as someone who lives in a glass house, the confession by InfoWorld that one of their writers was using a false identity and sometimes [...]

  • Dalia Pepper

    This “kid” has revealed what kind of man he may be one day and it’s a sorry one. Character is among the few valuable traits we have and if yours is warped to this extent and at this early stage of your life it’s a hard thing to mend. I suspect Daniel’s unethical leanings preceded his TechCrunch employment and will continue after; charming and bright as he seems to be.

  • Chris

    I am sorry to hear about this. I understand that transparency is very important for a journalist… or at least should be. I know a few that definitely are not.

    I am sure TechCrunch receive all sort of gadgets from companies that would like some extra attention. Even if you do not keep the gadgets, writing that you are giving away is still advertisement for them. I do not think that it is wrong. Asking something in order to get a post may be a little bit over the line.

    I don’t know personally the kid but the kid learned his lesson. It’s nearly GUARANTEED. Sometimes you learn to be honest in the same way you learn other things: making mistakes.

    I think that this action may have been a little hard.
    Trying to put yourself in his shoes. Having given him a lecture on why what he did is wrong/conflict of interest/disclosures etc, deleting the one post and suspend the boy for a month or two may be enough. Who is inexperienced (old or young) needs the opportunity of another chance, maybe more the one.

    I will go a step further, I think you should give him another chance and you should tell publicly that he deserve another chance. I am sure you will have a completely new person on board. More mature and more ethical than people that get their bribes in a smarter and subtle ways than how he got his in this episode.

    God gave me chances to learn from my mistakes in my life and I think I have to give chance to other people to learn from theirs.

  • http://www.penlau.net/?p=986 Frauds: An ugly, old journalism tradition | penlau software

    [...] weeks ago, TechCrunch discovered that a teenage intern had told companies he would write about them only if they agreed to provide [...]

  • http://www.s2eo.blogspot.com Laura

    I completely agree! It has nothing to do with age — adults do terrible things in the business world all the time — AIG for business? Stephen Glass for destroying journalistic integrity? I mean, come on!

    Good for TechCrunch for being honest.

  • http://sousuo.in/?p=223 The Sex and the City Guide to Blogging – 【For your have】

    [...] or product can, sometimes, have a debilitating affect on a blogger and their writing. Recently, an intern at TechCrunch got into heaps of trouble for exchanging a blog post for a laptop – for [...]

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=520218408 Mark Pannell

    Yeah, Daniel’s little stunt really harmed the credibility of TechCrunch. Because your journalistic integrity was impeccable prior to this clusterhump, right? Thanks for the laughs.

  • http://www.techxav.com/2010/02/05/teens-can-make-mistakes-too/ Teens can make mistakes too! | TechXav

    [...] TechCrunch’s Post [...]

  • http://gigaom.com/2010/03/17/lose-trust-and-you-lose-everything-3-rules-to-live-by/ Lose Trust, and You Lose Everything: 3 Rules to Live By – GigaOM

    [...] has to be carefully nurtured and ruthlessly defended. It’s why TechCrunch fired the intern who asked for a MacBook in exchange for covering a new company. It’s why IDG moved quickly to cut off any association with Randall Kennedy and why Facebook has [...]

  • http://www.iphoneappfreelancer.com/blog/iphone-app-review-sites-demands-money-ethical-or-not/ iPhone App Review Sites Demands Money: Ethical Or Not?

    [...] able to exercise control within the site’s many reviewers? This reminds me of the time when TechCrunch fired an intern for asking for a Macbook Air in return for a product review – remember that “tumultuous” [...]

  • http://www.lifeonavenuez.com/2010/03/lead-me-not-into-temptation/ Gimme, gimme, gimme? | Life on Avenue Z

    [...] month the notable blog TechCrunch issued an apology to its readers: On Monday evening I received a phone call from someone I trust who told me that one of our interns [...]

  • http://esarcasmblog.wordpress.com/2010/04/01/we-were-duped/ We were duped! « eSarcasmBlog

    [...] us speak directly to Arrington, was another clue we should have heeded but didn’t. But when he demanded a MacBook Air laptop in return for being acquired, it began to send off red [...]

  • http://www.webcamwithmicrophone.org Microphone

    15 ? even younger than me . i am 17

  • http://www.holidayworkinginsurance.com John

    u r right dude…………

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us