Weev Is Free

Andrew “weev” Auernheimer is set to be released from federal prison, following a federal appeals court decision to reverse and vacate his conviction and sentence.

“I’m going to prison for arithmetic,” Weev declared last March. Shortly after, he was incarcerated in the federal prison system, charged with violating the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, the same law that federal prosecutors were invoking against the late Aaron Swartz — a close friend of weev.

Auernheimer had been convicted of two consecutive five-year felonies.

In 2010, Weev found that AT&T had failed to protect 114,000 email addresses of iPad owners. He passed part of the list off to Gawker. AT&T later apologized and explained the flaw and data leak. However, where AT&T downplayed its massive security breach, Weev went to prison and was convicted under an ancient computer law in the state of New Jersey.

Today’s ruling by the Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, not only overturns a lower court’s judgement, but also vacates the conviction. The three judges overseeing this appellate panel essentially sidestepped the hacking allegations and instead focused on the location of the trial.

That alone was enough to overturn the prior decision. Venue, or the location of where a crime was committed, as the decision notes, is no small matter:

Screen Shot 2014-04-11 at 11.00.21 AM

Venue, the decision reminds its reader, is something of sufficient stature that it was addressed in the Declaration of Independence:

Screen Shot 2014-04-11 at 11.04.24 AM

The appeals court found that the case should have been tried in Auernheimer’s home state of Arkansas since that’s where the alleged illegal activity took place. The original trial was held in New Jersey since that’s where the 4,500 email addresses that Weev leaked were from.

However, even though the crux of the argument does rest on venue, the bench takes a pot shot at the idea that Weev violated New Jersey law:

Screen Shot 2014-04-11 at 11.06.22 AM

The whole filing can be read here. The argument is concrete enough that it makes you wonder how the lower court managed to come to its decision in good faith.

Writing for TechCrunch last January, Weev closed his guest post saying, “This is a country where if you express ideas that federal agents don’t like you, you will be beaten, imprisoned, or killed. I accept my responsibility for offending seditious thugs, liars and tyrants. I say this is the duty of all decent citizens left.”

Hopefully the federal prison where he sat in solitary for months hasn’t beaten the zeal out of Weev.