10 onboarding improvements that cut our customer churn by nearly 3x

Whether you’re building a product at an early-stage startup or fine-tuning an already built-out product at a larger company, there is a straightforward process that can help you improve your onboarding experience.

We decreased customer churn at Heyday from 8.5% to 3.3% just by changing our onboarding flow.

Here are the steps you can follow, with examples from our own onboarding experience.

Churn reduced by nearly three times to 3.3% from 8.3%. Image Credits: Heyday

Let users try your product with no guidance

After a few months of onboarding every new user via Zoom, my co-founder Samiur Rahman and I removed ourselves from the process. We dumped users into our product with no demo, zero product onboarding and one education email.

The result: a disaster. Engagement dropped and churn skyrocketed.

Not all friction is bad. It’s worth adding friction to your process if it helps a user experience your aha! moment.

When we surveyed users to learn why they stopped using our product, they would respond with something along the lines of, “I stopped using it because I didn’t see the benefit.”

Observe users to identify friction and aha! moments

Don’t wait to release your product. It is ready to be shipped as soon as you can get feedback on it. Through observation, you’ll learn what users really need to experience the value of your product.

I reinserted myself into our onboarding flow via a Zoom call. Rather than walk users through the product, this time I sat there silently and watched as they got started. I witnessed a lot of confusion, moderate frustration and a few smiles.

After 20 or so observations, we identified the common roadblocks that got in the way of our users. We walked away with a list of goals for our future onboarding experience.

Checklist of goals for optimizing onboarding. Image Credits: Heyday

Pay attention to users’ emotions

You might think you know what your aha! moment is, but it’s hard to be sure until you see users’ eyes light up.

During observations, people cracked up when we showed them content they forgot about alongside Google search results.

Given the strong emotional response, we knew this must be our aha! moment. We designed our onboarding to replicate the feeling at scale.

Explain the “why” behind your product and form a personal connection

One common question people want answered when they sign up for a new product is, “Is this worth my time?”

As the product owner, you can help them get to a “yes” by helping them form a connection with the people who build your product and the vision that guides it. We include videos of our founders throughout our onboarding to accomplish this.

Videos of our founders are included in the onboarding to help establish connections. Image Credits: Heyday

Excite people about taking action

Beyond forming an emotional connection, you can convince people to give your product a fair shot by demonstrating the value they’ll experience.

Be sure to show them how your product works and the benefits they’ll receive as quickly as you can. If you are building a consumer product, show it in action. If you’re building an enterprise solution, try an easy-to-understand diagram.

(We were inspired by Honey’s “how it works” screen.)

A demonstration of how Heyday works. Image Credits: Heyday

Present the key action

What is one step a user must take to experience the core value of your product?

It’s impossible for our users to experience the aha! moment if they don’t install our extension, so we encourage them to do so with one of our first onboarding screens.

If there’s a crucial action a user must take to fully realize the product’s value, help them do it. Image Credits: Heyday

Consider what steps a user must take to experience your product at its best, and do everything in your power to ensure they take it.

Make the aha! moment more likely

Not all friction is bad. It’s worth adding friction to your process if it helps a user experience your aha! moment.

For example, the more content a user adds to Heyday, the more likely we can resurface something they forgot about. It might seem unreasonable to ask a user to connect an integration to our product before they’ve used it.

We’ve found that users who connect integrations are almost three times more likely to become paying customers, and it doesn’t lead to a meaningful drop in conversions.

Friction is OK if it leads to more value being realized. Image Credits: Heyday

Anticipate common questions

A series of questions will bounce around in your users’ heads as they go through your onboarding. If you don’t answer them, people won’t stick around long enough to try your product.

During our observation sessions, one of the most common questions we were asked was: “How do I know my data is safe in Heyday?” We answer the question explicitly throughout onboarding so it doesn’t trip them up.

Alleviate user concerns before they air them. Image Credits: Heyday

Set users up for positive future sessions

Onboarding is more than the first experience a user has with your product. Consider subsequent sessions as someone gets familiar with your offering.

We do the following:

  • Ask users to tell us topics they care about so that we resurface relevant content.
  • Send them an email the next morning with that content.
  • Create a “Getting Started” checklist to set them up for future success.

On top of that, we schedule calls with users to get them excited about future versions of the product and deepen our relationship.

Manufacture the aha! moment

As soon as you have the information you need to deliver your aha! moment, do it.

We pre-populate a Google search for which we have a high probability of resurfacing forgotten content to deliver the moment that led to the emotional response during our onboarding sessions.

There’s no such thing as a perfect onboarding experience…

…but when done right, the impact of good onboarding can be massive.

We included our nearly 3x reduction of churn from onboarding changes in our seed pitch deck, and it was one of the factors that helped us raise a round from top investors.

A slide from our pitch deck showing a reduction in churn. Image Credits: Heyday

If you’re working on onboarding and saw something you liked here, feel free to steal it. Everything we built was made possible by insights shared by onboarding experts like Casey Winters, Darius Contractor and Shahed Khan.

I hope this piece inspires you to start experimenting!