Facebook Celebrates People’s Birthdays In A Special Way: “F*ck You B*tches”
Robin Wauters
Jul 29, 2010

TechCrunch reader Saul Lustgarten checks in to tell us he logged on to Facebook this morning and noticed that the list of his friends who are having their birthday today was preceded by a crude message, reading “fuck you bitches”.

Yeah right, we thought. I checked it out on my Facebook profile and didn’t notice anything off.

Then, I followed Saul’s suggestion of switching my main language to Spanish instead of English, and lo and behold (click for full-size image):

We’ve contacted Facebook to see if they really mean it or if their army of volunteer translators – there are two sides to that shiny crowdsourcing medal after all – or one of their coders simply decided to have some fun.

Update: sorry to disappoint, but it seems to be fixed now. But it was definitely there.

Advertisement
  • Related Topics
Advertisement
  • http://mosspuppet.wordpress.com mosspuppet

    That’s goddamn amazing, bitches!

  • Derek johnson

    That’s hilarious!!!

  • jeremy jere

    Yawn………and this is news?

  • Dario

    First Mel Gibson, now Facebook. Cant we all just get along? ;-)

  • Ben

    LOL I am sure they don’t really care.

  • http://500hats.typepad.com dave mcclure

    sorry, my bad… been brushing up on my Spanish lately.

    - dave “i’m in yr greetingz, F’ing up yr bday, bitches” mcclure

  • http://techie-buzz.com Keith Dsouza

    LOL That must be a developer comment, being a developer I like to leave funky comments in code which are invoked on certain actions, this might be one of them

  • http://www.seocharlie.com/blog Charlie

    Why only in Spanish? o_O

  • Jick

    Here’s another translation fail http://countermeasures.trendmicro.eu/facebook-prank-lost-in-translation/

    “Your message could not be sent because the user is offline”

    became

    “Your message could not be sent because of your tiny penis”

  • jay

    Awesome!

  • Andrew Watson

    Also, where does the term Birthday Pigs come from? Did Techcrunch just make that up or is that a secret programmer hacker bug in THEIR system?

  • http://www.xklsv.com xklsv

    Please make this the “F*uk you scam” and blow it out of proportion.

  • http://timdl.posterous.com TimDL

    And it’s not the first time, it’s not the first time they insult foreigners in this manner:

    their captcha stated “abscond foreigners”

    http://timdl.posterous.com/facebook-to-foreigners-abscond-foreigners

  • http://reface.me dwergs

    Happens from time to time, cf. the double n*ggers case a year ago: http://reface.me/news/friends-are-fans-notification-hacked/

    It strikes me there’s no “universal” cuss words filter.

  • Reader
  • riomx

    Kindly STFU, please. No one cares about your apathy. See what I did there?

  • Richard

    They crowd-source their translations, so obviously someone thought it would be funny to put that as the translation for ‘Birthdays’.

  • http://www.programas.com/blog/cosasdeinternet/ Diego

    There are more of them on the Facebook Pages, it seems like a little hack.

  • http://blogrevised.com Siku

    Now that’s an excellent way to notify people of their friends birthday… at least it grabs good ATTENTION!

  • Robin Wauters

    Ha, I really apologize, but my not being a native English speaker made me mess up that title. Seriously thought it was a common term. Better now :)

  • Todd

    Facebook is supporting Arizona’s racist agenda!

  • Catasphere

    THIS IS FRONT PAGE MATERIAL RIGHT HERE!

  • Robert D

    you must have traded in your pirate hat, which you traded the cat-in-the-hat hat for, and traded that in for a sombrero? Am I close?

  • Corey A

    I can’t replicate this on my facebook. Sad Day.

  • http://www.tailormypc.com James Spinosa

    They must only do that for important birthdays; to ensure that everyone posts on their wall.

  • kensons

    Yep.. FB admins just want to have some fun. This is to commemorate, all the headaches they had for one year’s work.

    And as you can see, Facebook finally found its Mottor of the year! So who’s the b!tch: http://2su.de/3kF

  • http://www.crispthinking.com Peter Maude

    Not really blowing it out of proportion though is it.

    Enterprise company with 500 million users data, cannot even screen for this stuff.

    And they are letting third parties contribute content into the core of the applications, with no oversight.

    What if someone doing translations, were to do a script injection attack.

  • Andrew Watson

    Don’t you speak spanish? “Fuck You Bitches” is how you say “Happy Birthday, Friends!” in Spanish. Sheesh.

  • anon

    Maybe if you remove the stick from your ass, you’d enjoy the story. Unless you’re the type of person who enjoys a stick in their ass…

  • http://elizawhat.com Elizabeth Kaylene

    Hahaha, I could laugh about this all day! It definitely shouldn’t have happened, but damn is it funny. Can we file this under “Best Internet Bloopers of 2010″?

  • sean

    facebook’s system is pretty naive, I’d say.

    It may have had chance to build a stellar engineering team around 2007-2008, but the time has long passed (stellars left and fats stay)

  • RonnieB

    Yeah… I’m pretty good at Photoshop too. Prove this is real.

  • Robin Wauters

    It’s real.

  • mrvco

    Where I’m from that is a term of endearment.

  • Robin Wauters

    Were you raised in Facebook’s headquarters?

  • SuNcO

    This is real. I check that yesterday when some messages appear similar to this. I use the integrated translation tool to send the correct one. The translator is from Spain because the badword is used only there. The one I see was “friend1 and friend2 comment the photo of friend3″ where the translator changes “comment” with “f#c*” (makes sense on spanish)

  • Targ Blanston

    It’s a blog, not a newspaper. Everything is front page material at some point.

  • Targ Blanston

    Woops, reply belongs on the post above.

  • ev011

    When I test actions in my code to make sure events are firing properly, I often use expletive-laden rants in the popup dialog, or trace lines. “Fuck You Bitches” would be along those lines. The reaon I use code like that is because I am normally getting aggrivated that I am having to trace out events that are not working, thus the cursing… Dude was just blowing off some steam…

  • http://chadhuber.wordpress.com chadhuber

    greatest permalink ever.

    /no-fuck-you-facebook/

  • phoenxsoftware

    4chan anyone?

  • Jones

    Your friend Kim Demeulenaere is kinda hawt.

  • http://techpulse360.com Jean-Baptiste Su

    Perhaps he is trying to be in the goody-good books of Facebook -

  • @fawwazhadi

    Facebook translation for malay language(bahasa melayu) also got similar lame prank.. Its like that for almost a year, and I can assume its prank from voluntier translators, not from facebook developer itself

  • anon

    im pretty good at firebug

  • http://robcolburn.com Rob Colburn

    Injection attacks are trivial to sanitize, there’s standardized code for that.

    Word filtering is tricky, especially with translation. Probably need to place peer-review and/or consequences into the crowd-sourced solution.

  • http://gotLockerz.com Jose D

    Esto demuestra las excelentes destrezas que tiene Caralibro [Facebook] en cuanto a traducción.

    Way to go Facebook, lol. Should we expect a post about why this happened? lol

  • owy

    You can do this facebook trick with this shit : http://tinyurl.com/3xnhznu

  • http://www.ajaxjones.com Ajax Jones

    Yep, fuck you bitch and happy birthday are just so hard to differentiate

  • http://blogrevised.com Siku

    pretty nasty language i guess haha

  • Nick

    Warning: clicking on that link redirects you to a site that remotely installs a trojan on your computer.

  • cCc reyiz cCc

    İNCİ SİKER

  • http://www.acunetix.com/blog/author/jeremyp/ Jeremy Pullicino

    >> Injection attacks are trivial to sanitize

    That’s rubbish. These types of attacks are very hard to avoid, especially for facebook.

    Just yesterday a security company demonstrated how to bypass facebook script injection filters.

    Their research is here:
    http://www.acunetix.com/blog/news/cross-site-scripting-xss-facebook/

    They have a video demo here:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iTddmr_JRYM

    Facebook is vulnerable to script injections in many ways…

  • http://inci.sozlukspot.com inciya rakos

    ccc inci siker ccc

  • Inci Siker

    guys calm down.

    we have just made a visit to facebook.

    inci siker guys. dont forget.

  • inci sikti bile

    f*ck 4chan.
    we are inci
    cCc siktik soktuk cCc

  • Lol

    Haha i agree with you jeremy jere :D boooring!

  • http://www.viralviralvideos.com ViralViralVideos.com

    Now that’s funny. Want a happy birthday? well too bad you f*ckin B*tiches

  • JI mDacvis

    OK that makes a lot of sense. Myspace still kicks them to the curb though.

    Lou
    http://www.anonymous-surfing.es.tc

  • xuc

    Fake, and not news even if it wasn’t.

  • http://www.jonathannguyen.net Jonathan

    Not the first time they told me to F%&CK right off when clicking through to my own profile!

    http://www.jonathannguyen.net/social-media/fuck-right-off-real-facebook-error-message/

  • cCc grandpas cCc

    4chan is group of people high school lamer who takes serious everything.

    inci kissed facebook softly like before twitter

    cCc forever inci sözlük cCc

  • nelson

    XSS is *not* script injection. Those are two completely different kind of attacks. A translator providing text that is printed by facebook’s internationalization library cannot perform an XSS attack, and, like the other dude said, removing all markup from the translation is trivial.

    alert(“See? :)”);

  • http://www.theyearlyhomepage.com Roshawn

    LOL!

  • http://jyngrehl.wordpress.com jyngrehl

    Wow… that’s just something else. I bet someone used some type of javascript to do that :)

  • dick

    Warning: The person who believes nick, will get his/her computer nuked out with malwares.

  • http://inci.sozlukspot.com Pearl harbor

    no worries.dont panic pls

    everthing is under our control

    inci fucks guys once again

  • inciya rakos

    That’s hilarious, and inci kicked ass as usual.

    up yours 4chan /b/tards!

  • http://inci.sozlukspot.com Ruhi inciten

    ccc inci minakor ccc

  • Can Duruk

    This was a 4chan-esque attack by Turkey’s 4chan, that is incisozluk.

    Incisozluk is a wiki-like discussion forum, essentially.

  • Anon

    Racism is so American. You should be proud.

  • http://nobrain.dk cCc i like sugardaddy cCc

    cCc inci siker cCc

  • Sarah

    That’s actually a suggested friend.

  • Marta Boer Silva

    That’s what you get when you do not want to pay translators to do a professional job. Not only translators but other people like yourself are all working for free for them plus risking having their privacy neglected online.

  • inci siker

    ccc inci siker ccc

  • Rob

    I have Facebook set to Dutch, and it told me to go to hell in Spanish a while ago (vai á merda, literally “go to shit”).
    Screenshot: http://twitgoo.com/vyyxu

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us