Judge: Nintendo did not infringe on Wii Classic Controller, Wiimote

John Biggs

Biggs is the East Coast Editor of TechCrunch. Biggs has written for the New York Times, InSync, USA Weekend, Popular Mechanics, Popular Science, Money and a number of other outlets on technology and wristwatches. He is the former editor-in-chief of Gizmodo.com and lives in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn. You can Tweet him here and G+ him here. Email him directly at... → Learn More

Wednesday, April 14th, 2010


A company called Anascape, Ltd. sued Nintendo in 2008 for infringing on their patent for a controller similar to the Classic and Wiimote controllers. The Texas-based patent trolls won $21 million from Nintendo for their troubles thanks to a number of experts who attested that yes, the Anascape patents are pretty overarching and could feasibly apply to any controller ever made. A federal judge in the Eastern District just reversed that decision. The company had also sued Microsoft for the same patents and won a settlement.


Here are some of their delightful patents:

Patent #5999084 – “Variable conductance sensor”
Patent #6102802 – “Game controller with analog pressure sensor”
Patent #6135886 – “Variable conductance sensor with elastomeric dome cap”
Patent #6208271 – “Remote controller with analog button”
Patent #6222535 – “Image controller with sheet connected sensors”
Patent #6343991 – “Game control with analog pressure sensor”
Patent #6344791 – “Variable sensor with tactile feedback”
Patent #6347997 – “Analog controls housed with electronic displays”
Patent #6351205 – “Variable conductance sensor”
Patent #6400303 – “Remote controller with analog pressure sensor”
Patent #6563415 – “Analog sensor with snap through tactile feedback”
Patent #6906700 – “3D controller with vibration”

Generally, you’re dealing with a shell company that enjoys going after big gaming. Not a huge deal in the grand scheme of things and, like any other patent troll, they’ll dry up once their victims work around their patents.

via PatentArcade

blog comments powered by Disqus