Keynoir launches innovative members-only group buying model

Tuesday, March 30th, 2010

Mike Butcher is the European Editor for TechCrunch. A former grunge rock drummer, he became a long time journalist, and has since written for UK national newspapers and magazines including The Financial Times, The Guardian, The Times, The Daily Telegraph and The New Statesman. Mike is also a co-founder and shareholder of TechHub, a co-working space/service/community with several locations... → Learn More

A new take on the group-buying bandwagon launches today, but this one will attempt to address the information overload about offers, known as “voucher fatigue”, while incentivising local businesses. Keynoir is described as a “private buying club meets Woot”, in reference to the tech site which made its name by having just one offer on one decent product a day. The startup even includes aspects of the old Letsbuyit.com.

But this is not a trivial play. Keynoir has already secured £1.3m of investment from PROFounders Capital, investor Jan Riem and Index Ventures (including Dominique Vidal). Serial entrepreneurs Paul Birch and Andrej Henkler participated. Vidal and Sean Seton-Rogers from PROfounders will be joining the board.

The founders are Philip Wilkinson (founder of the UK’s first price comparison engine which later became Kelkoo), Glen Drury (ex-MD Kelkoo Europe and VP Yahoo), and Jan Riem (technology deal maker). It launches in London this week , and plans to exand across the rest of the UK and Europe by the end of the year.

Here’s how it will work. Users will buy lifestyle experiences (such as hotels, restaurant bookings and spa days) and more “unusual and secret things” they say. There will be one such offer a day (called a Keypass) with a limited time window and limited quantity available, driving adoption.

As with other group buying sites, a minimum number of people are required to confirm a purchase before the offer is unlocked to the rest of the member base. But the founders emphasise that since not everyone who arrives at the site will be accepted as a member, Keynoir will be very targetted.

“People are becoming increasing weary and cynical of the whole discount marketplace and are looking for something more fulfilling,” says Wilkinson. It’s targeting 23 – 35 year old professionals and is looking to have a strict selection process for deals across the travel, food, retail and entertainment sectors.

His view is that that local businesses will like Keynoir since the business only pays if it gets enough people to buy on that day, thus filling capacity in the downturn without heavy advertising costs.

Hoberman is equally enthusiastic. He calls it the start of a “a new generation of social buying which will effectively connect the offline and online worlds.”

My view is that the walled garden approach is smart. In fact it’s already been tried by Wahanda, not through creating a barrier to entry before you can get in, but by targeting a niche. This is the one thing that most group buying sites have missed, thus leading to offer fatigue.

However the model is of course replicable, so watch as other sites spring up to copy its approach.

Especially for TechCrunch readers, this link will automatically get you around the invite selection process and let you create an account to see the first launch deal.

Tags:

Sponsored Ads

  • http://doingwords.com alan jones

    So… it’s meant to be more exciting to me because not everybody can be a member… but then at the end of the story is a link allowing anyone to become a member?…

  • Dave Hanna

    Have to let some peak behind the curtains, create the buzz and then kick everyone out. Classic Night club membership process- make them wait in line when nobody is inside, yet.

    Wealthy groupon, nice job.

  • BobbyBrown

    Exactly Alan!! I was involved in one of these and ultimately it’s a numbers game, the more ppl that are available to buy the healthier the business. Exclusivity greatly reduces the ability for the business to grow, and consumers will see through this tactic (with an invitation in tech crunch).

    It’s a highly competitive space though, so innovation is key

  • Dave Hanna

    “peek”

  • http://www.keplarllp.com Yali

    This is a really interesting concept. The key thing isn’t the walled-garden itself, but the fact that Keynoir are trying to build a geniune community of like-minded (and highly targeted) individuals. (The walled-garden is just one tool in their arsenal to build the right kind of community.) As I’ve argued elsewhere, there’s no reason existing community sites shouldn’t look also try employing group buying to add value to their community members whilst growing their revenues.

  • Jackson

    Information overload about offers?

    All our lives we’ve been exposed to direct mail, print ads, adverts on television, online banners and suddenly, when 10 or so daily deal sites emerge (and actually see some success), we develop a mysterious syndrome known as voucher fatigue? That sounds like some fabricated terminology straight off a company press release. Could you please link a couple of examples of the term “voucher fatigue” being used by someone other than Mr. Wilkinson?

  • Charlie

    Bizzare…

  • Charlie

    Voucher fatigue, now there are some capital words. I love it. Unfortunately I think it’s total rubbish. These voucher sites are all based around the same principle that the user REQUESTS the newsletter/update on fb or whatever. It’s a subscription based model. Nobody gets unsolicited ads. And I think this is one of the core reasons behind its success. It’s ability to be genuinely usefull and not invasive. If you don’t like it you unsubscribe. The whole process of subscribing to everything under the sun to find out (horribly) that now you have to go and unsubscribe because 90% of them are useless, I would agree, can lead to fatigue. It could also lead to mouse-finger-tendinitis too. So beware everybody, don’t click on that subscribe button just because it has a nice photoshop effect applied.

  • http://www.magicfm.com Nigel

    Very exclusive membership, what a joke, go to the site and sign up anybody can and it lets you in immediately. And as for a deal a day it says this one runs for “a few days”
    There is also only 100 deals available so Keynoirs share cannot be very big. It will take them a long time to get the 1.3 mill back at that rate. I dont see there target audience bothering to share the deals either, they are all too busy already

  • http://twitter.com/mikebutcher Mike Butcher

    That’s just ’cause you’re a special TC reader. Enjoy!

  • http://twitter.com/mikebutcher Mike Butcher

    Great comments everyone keep’em coming. As I say, the model is course replicable, unless they can be smarter and earlier about who and how they target.

  • NS

    The comments on this thread are unnecessarily harsh, and fairly ill-informed. This company has been set up by some of the most intelligent and innovative people in Europe. In order to launch a company of this sort, you need some sort of database, which is what they are building through TechCrunch. The cynicism towards them from TC readers, who should know to have faith in start-ups, is disappointing.

  • Char

    While I buy some of the criticisms of the membership, I’m sure there’s an argument not to make it too difficult to join on launch day. I’m not likely to get voucher fatigue with money off a Michelin 2 star restaurant…

  • Mike

    I agree with Charlie, I love “Voucher fatigue”, what a name! Much better than “Discounts Blindness” or “Deals Overload” I would use… So jealous of these guys vocabulary. However, what a rubbish, people are skint and love a good deal when it comes – Just look how well are even recently started Group Buying Websites doing, like http://www.likebees.com or http://www.groupola.com – they are selling deals. And as Charlie pointed out, people can always unsubscribe, but to tell the true, I cannot make myself unsubscribe from LastMinute or myvouchercodes – what if next week they come up with deal I am looking for??? However, I like exclusivity Keynoir want to introduce, but I would be afraid that exclusivity will mean that not enough people sign up and deals will not get live. Plus, how can you share deals if they are exclusive, I thought that sharing deals was behind success of sites like Groupon.

  • Paul Duggan

    Whilst there is no doubt an abundance of businesses popping up in the hope of emulating Groupon’s US success, knowing Phil & the team he’s established I believe Keynoir is in a position to have a real shot at it. In terms of walled garden I think the jury will rightly remain out (& arguably the quality of the deals & marketing will be the key determinants) but they’re innovating around the edges rather than simply me to’ing (which is good).

  • Peter

    Well if anyone is going to make it then these guys are.

    @Mike

    Groupola selling? If you mean selling 2 deals a day then yeah they are selling.

    The only people that seem to be selling any are:

    LikeBees
    MyCityDeal
    Wowcher
    Wahanda

    Good luck to them all.

  • http://www.thefactory.com Sarah Edwards

    Nice – makes sense to me. We’ll see what the quality of the deals look like as it might be the case that pitching itself as a members club enables them to get better places on board as it protects their brand. Kind of what Gucci and Vente Priveee do for example.

  • Joe

    Why all these sites require people to subscribe and login before they can even see the deals?

    Why they all copied the gimmick of requiring a minimum number of takers?

    No need to subscribe or login and everyone can buy instantly at http://www.specialdeals.com. I just bought 2 Swim with Dolphins deals there and saved $144!

  • http://www.specialdeals.com/ Special Deals

    No need for £1.3m. All we need are deals and your user base so we can set you up with your own website and facebook app in a week. See http://www.specialdeals.com/partner.php and contact us for more info.

  • http://www.plooptionary.com PeteJ

    I know Phil and Glen reasonably well and I don’t think they would enter a space if they felt there wasn’t an opportunity.

    From where I sit the offers don’t appear to be similar to the others out there – more premium and I guess that’s what Phil’s getting at with ‘voucher fatigue’. I don’t know many people who go to Pizza Express without a voucher.

    The membership deal feels like a bit of a non-issue to me – if they are emailing deals it’s simply a more elegant way of getting emails to those likely to be interested?

  • http://www.magicfm.com Nigel

    Keynoir is just another Groupon clone, nothing else. The team behind it should be embarrassed that they have ripped off Groupon. They are also the last of about 10 Groupon clones already in the UK so nothing new there either. The site is not a patch on most of the others either. None of the investors got rich by refusing people money so this clone is about as exclusive as Argos

  • Peng Fei

    how can they screen out 20-35 year olds through an email address?

  • Peng Fei

    Isn’t this just like another groupon?

  • Dave

    Can you possibly make your site look any worse?

  • Robin

    Joe,

    Go watch the movie “The Cove” and then see how you feel about the “Swim with Dolphins” package. Seems that thousands of dolphins and porpoises are killed each year so unsuspecting kids can get their photos taken with flipper. Seriously, I dare you to watch that movie and then go through with it!

  • http://LocalOfferLounge.com Jorge Zapata

    Mike (and everyone else on this thread),

    This space is definitely growing fast. At http://LocalOfferLounge.com we are currently indexing and categorizing over 200 offers from 73 Deal A Day websites across 56 cities in the US, Canada and UK.

    In cities like Chicago, for example, where we are following 14 ‘deal-a-day’ websites, visitors may subscribe to a daily email digest containing all the available deals for the day.

    The best part is we send consumers directly to the site and don’t keep you around on our site. It’s purely done to benefit the consumer.

  • http://www.specialdeals.com Jared Friedman

    While there are allot of group buying sites out there a few have tried to distinguish themselves from the others. I will point you to http://www.specialdeals.com that have activity oriented deals like Indoor Skydiving and Swim with dolphins @ 6 Flags for half off.

  • will

    well i linked through from a facebook announcement from one of their lawyers – and it hasn’t let me in. Does that reflect on me, their lawyers or facebook – i wonder…

  • Simi

    Agree with most of the points raised above. Another group of people who are just copying the groupon model.

    I’ve signed up to at least 6 of the sites doing this already as a deal is a deal! Only 2 of them really deliver like groupon though, and actually sell more than a couple of units. wahanda.com have some of the craziest spa deals. I bought an amazing spa offer with over 70% off and was more than happy to send to all my friends… who loved me as a result!
    mycitydeal.com is also fab. I’ve picked up a £1 pret voucher and a ridiculously cheap cinema deal. Do good restaurant deals too but still think that for restuarant deals noone beats toptable as they’ve done 50% off deals of restaurants for YEARS!

  • http://www.specialdeals.com/ Special Deals

    Thanks for the comment. We try to make the site look as good as craigslist so it is working and making money. :)

    Btw, please comment our facebook app at http://apps.facebook.com/special-deals-gifts/ too. Thanks!

  • http://www.localofferlounge.com Jason

    London has quickly become one of the most active cities as we’re now following 13 of these ‘deal-a-day’ websites. http://www.localofferlounge.com/london

  • Pete

    I don’t completely understand some of the comments here.. Its subscription based so you’re not getting emails/’spam’ you haven’t signed up for, it helps restaurants fill up their bookings books and it gets me cheaper dinners in decent restaurants.. I’m pretty sure that a lot of restaurants wouldn’t mind a few more bookings at the moment, and I could definitely do with making my pennies go further.. Win, win, win?? Needless to say, I’ve signed up! Whats next?

  • http://thelondoneer.blogspot.com Pirate Pete

    I went along to their ‘Bloggers Breakfast’ last week where they pitched their ideas to us – I posted a ‘review’ on the blog today as they just launched. I’m just not convinced that they’re doing this at the right time. They’re only offering very high-end stuff, and even quite wealthy people are doing serious belt-tightening at the moment.

    Can you say ‘bad timing’?

  • http://www.magicfm.com Nigel

    Well they did’nt stay “high end” for long, just another £15 Tapas deal today. If thats as good as they can get they might as well jack it in now.
    What an anti climax to all their rubbish hype

  • http://www.teabags.co.uk Jason Steadmean

    Don’t be a twit Nigel – why would they put a top-end expensive deal on every day – just wouldn’t make sense. You have to blend with cool, unique, cheaper deals too so people can buy lots in a month. If every deal was £100+ – you’d get tired out

  • http://thelondoneer.blogspot.com Pirate Pete

    Hang on, this was supposed to be some slick, classy venture, not another pile ‘em high, sell ‘em cheap site, and they’re flogging £15 tapas deals on day two?? How much did their suckers, sorry angel investors, pile into this project again?

  • http://tomuse.com Kevin Eklund

    Keynoir sounds a lot like ideeli.com

  • anon

    HEY MIKE! I just unsubscribed you and will keep doing so until they fix their crappy website!

  • Craig Evans

    I think this probably where most of the retail industry is going to be heading in one way or another and I guess that’s good for the consumer – just a shame their only letting some people sign up

  • http://www.votacaoartigo.com/Article/317/ Votacao Artigo

    [...] (18)  Keynoir lança membros do grupo só de comprar o modelo inovador [...]

  • http://www.bootlaw.com Danvers

    William – please stop stalking me on Facebook!

  • Kevin

    I’ve created a comparison chart to list all the group buying sites and display the key differences between them all. Let me know if missed any or if there are any other comparison points to be addressed.

    http://tomuse.com/group-buying-sites-coupon-deals-discount-savings

  • Clair

    This may as well be written in greek for all I understand about it. I’ve never heard of group buying for starters! Totally baffled is an understatement

  • http://eu.techcrunch.com/2010/11/30/if-google-buys-groupon-what-does-that-means-for-the-uk-shakeout/ If Google buys Groupon, what does that means for the UK? Shakeout.

    [...] based out of London and backed by Index Ventures and PRO-Founders Capital, Keynoir launched in April this year and claims to be the No. 2 player after MyCityDeal, but there is an important difference [...]

  • Anonymous
  • chenjinhua

    Known throughout the NFL as the most controversial player, no one can deny Terrell Owens pure ability to produce the big play every time he touches the football. Thanks to his massive size and blazing speed, gucci sunglasses few, if any, defensive backs can cover him. This 16′ x 20′ photo is personally gucci outlet online hand signed by Terrell. This product is officially licensed by the National Football League and comes with an individually numbered; tamper evident hologram from Mounted Memories. To ensure authenticity, the hologram gucci outlet store can be reviewed online. This process helps to ensure that the product purchased is authentic and eliminates any possibility of duplication or fraud. In the event this exact image is sold out, an alternate photo of the same athlete will be shipped instead.

  • chenjinhua

    Known throughout the NFL as the most controversial player, no one can deny Terrell Owens pure ability to produce the big play every time he touches the football. Thanks to his massive size and blazing speed, gucci sunglasses few, if any, defensive backs can cover him. This 16′ x 20′ photo is personally gucci outlet online hand signed by Terrell. This product is officially licensed by the National Football League and comes with an individually numbered; tamper evident hologram from Mounted Memories. To ensure authenticity, the hologram gucci outlet store can be reviewed online. This process helps to ensure that the product purchased is authentic and eliminates any possibility of duplication or fraud. In the event this exact image is sold out, an alternate photo of the same athlete will be shipped instead.

  • chenjinhua

    Known throughout the NFL as the most controversial player, no one can deny Terrell Owens pure ability to produce the big play every time he touches the football. Thanks to his massive size and blazing speed, gucci sunglasses few, if any, defensive backs can cover him. This 16′ x 20′ photo is personally gucci outlet online hand signed by Terrell. This product is officially licensed by the National Football League and comes with an individually numbered; tamper evident hologram from Mounted Memories. To ensure authenticity, the hologram gucci outlet store can be reviewed online. This process helps to ensure that the product purchased is authentic and eliminates any possibility of duplication or fraud. In the event this exact image is sold out, an alternate photo of the same athlete will be shipped instead.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XOQDSVU7DDLRCZ3B2YZUXYUJK4 Andy Lau

    Serial entrepreneurs [url=http://www.christianlouboutinuk.us]christian louboutin shoes[/url][url=http://www.christianlouboutinuk.us]christian louboutin heels[/url] Paul Birch and Andrej Henkler participated. Vidal and Sean Seton-Rogers from PROfounders will be joining the board.

  • http://www.truereligionsalestores.com/ true religion

    The particular Alemao advanced, for many
    years important property to get Rio’s largest
    illegal drug bunch, that White Order,

  • grsfr

    There are various styles of Knockoff designer handbags on our online shop,you can wholesale replica handbags with low price and free shipping,our cheap replica handbags are AAA quality and popular styles,enjoy your shopping now!
    we offers large amounts of newest and best fake designer handbags , Each high quality Replica Chanel Handbags comes in a great variety of colors and models. The most amazing thing is the superior quality and the similar design as the replica designer jewelry which help us win many customers’ praises. Moreover, we still take proud in our competitive price and the best service! Created by Thomas Burberry in 1856, Burberry enjoys a long history of fashion. It is one of the oldest designer brands. knockoff handbags represents luxury and it enjoys a strong global recognition. If you want to wholesale replica handbags, undoubtly, the finest knockoff jewelry are the best choice for you! You are surely going to turn many heads by carrying these beautiful replica designer handbags around!

     

  • 290338366

    Our wholesale designer handbags store online sales all kinds of coach outlet sunglasses jewelry Wallets shoes belts watches umbrella cheap replica handbags bikini sunglasses scarf and so on.we can offer you the best price and service,fast&free shipping.Also its high-level handcraft create subtle ruched effect. The Coach collections in our replica designer handbags store are always chic and cheap at the same time. Its have the most patterns in most colors and you can always choose one from them. We believe that when you see our Coach collections for the first sight, you will feel that: “Just looking at these bags makes me happy” or “I love all of them – I don’t know how to choose.”

  • 290338366

    a href=”http://www.wholesalecheapdesigner.com”>Cheap Designer Handbags onsale, We offer 2011 New Style cheap replica designer handbags, All Coach Bags and Handbags Are 100% High Quality Guaranteed! Buy cheap designer handbags In US Coach Factory Store.
    Professional Replica Designer Handbags on sale,Cheap Designer Handbags online including cheap wholesale designer Handbags,Chanel Bags,Louis Vuitton wholesale designer handbags.

  • http://www.monsters-store.com beater
  • http://sorebuttcheeks.blogspot.com/ steroids

    black key sounds better.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Sponsored Ads

Sponsored Ads

Upcoming Events

Disrupt SF 2012

San Francisco, CA