Amazingly, DVD Commentary Helped Give Roger Ebert His Voice Back
MG Siegler
Mar 2, 2010

Film critic Roger Ebert has been unable to speak with his own voice since 2006, when he underwent surgery related to his battle with thyroid cancer. Since then, he’s been using a computerized voice (notably, “Alex,” a voice built-in to Mac OS X), to communicate all this time. But today on Oprah, he’s debuting a new computerized voice: his own.

If you watch the video at the bottom of this post, it’s pretty remarkable just how much it sounds like Ebert. He has a distinctive voice that a lot of his fans know well thanks to his many years on television reviewing films. You should also watch the longer version of the video here, to compare his new voice to his old one (again, Alex from OS X).

So how was a company able to do this for Ebert? That’s maybe the most interesting part. As he explained on his blog a few days ago (Ebert is both a prolific blogger and Twitter user), Ebert stumbled upon a Scottish company called CereProc while surfing the web one day. Their specialty is text-to-speech technology, and Ebert found them because they’ve been recreating the voices of famous people. So Ebert decided to email them. They told him they needed good quality audio — which didn’t seem like a problem because of Ebert’s aforementioned television program.

But actually there was a problem. On the show, Ebert was always getting cut-off mid-point, or arguing with people, or there was constantly movie music in the background. Because of these factors, the voice CereProc would have created was less of a regular, casual Ebert, and more of a choppy or enraged one. Ebert humorously notes, “It would seem strange if I said, ‘Let’s have a moment of silence,’ and in the background, you could hear Transformers ripping off the top of the Great Pyramid.”

But there was another way. Ebert remembered that he also had recorded a number of DVD audio commentary tracks for many classic films, including Citizen Kane. So he asked the studios he had worked with on those if they had the pure audio tracks — and they did. Warner Bros., Criterion Collection, New Line Cinemas, and 20th Century Fox were all able to dig up recordings of Ebert’s voice.

This audio was then sent to CereProc, where the company transcribed all of it so they could find every word they needed. As Ebert notes, they didn’t need a clip of every word he’s ever said, just enough so they could reconstruct how he might say a word. He’ll use a combination of the new voice, which he calls “Roger Jr.,” with his old, trusty OS X Alex voice on Oprah today. Says Ebert:

Yes, “Roger Jr.” needs to be smoother in tone and steadier in pacing, but the little rascal is good. To hear him coming from my own computer made me ridiculously happy.

He continues:

What will I use this voice for? I could talk with Chaz [Ebert's wife] and our grandchildren — and it would be me, not Alex. I could do audio for Webcasts, talking under clips from movies I’m describing. I could do radio. I could tell jokes.

It’s a pretty amazing story about technology.

Advertisement
  • Related Topics
Advertisement
  • http://fudge.org Jay Cuthrell

    Great article.

    [sharing]

  • http://maybeitis.wordpress.com maybeitis

    Try to recognize what is on photo.

    http://whatisonphoto.blogspot.com/

  • http://www.ArticlePlayground.com Article Playground

    I am happy to hear about overcoming his adversity. In this life, there is a chance for everyone to be a leader. And, he is surely a leader! :-)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=777934249 Jerry George

    I hope he is happy. :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100000087189987 Paul Copeland

    Amazing.

  • http://www.ipodaccessories.org/ P

    Ebert just looks so sad and tragic in that video. Just makes me feel sick to see the man like that…

    You have to give it to him. The guy still posts regular (and as usual, insightful) movie reviews every week. He’s still my go-to-guy if I want to know about a movie.

  • http://sco.tt/ Scott Yates

    Awesome!

    Seeing him doesn’t creep me out. The idea of the whole thing creeps me out a little, only because people long dead could suddenly start making new recordings.

    But for this application, it’s really great. Thanks for posting that.

  • http://www.netparty.com Jeff Strank

    Besides movie reviews, he actually has one of the best blogs on the internet at http://blogs.suntimes.com/ebert/. His writing, which is amazing, has become much more prolific since he lost his voice.

  • http://parislemon.com MG Siegler

    thanks jay, it’s a great story.

  • Shuki Haiminis

    What an amazing and touching experience they shared with the world.

    I am sad to say that I did not realize that he was not able to speak since 2006. I must be living under a rock :)

  • http://www.drfunkenberry.com/2010/03/02/roger-ebert-speaks-again-with-the-help-of-technology/ Roger Ebert Speaks Again With The Help Of Technology | Drfunkenberry.com

    [...] Read the whole story at Techcrunch [...]

  • http://www.infotainmentnews.net/2010/03/02/the-voice-of-roger-ebert/ The Voice Of Roger Ebert — INFOtainment News

    [...] thing. I’m going to give a shout out to reporter MG Siegler who did a great, in-depth piece [here] on the technology behind the scenes that got Mr. Ebert to this point. [...]

  • http://gizmologia.com/2010/03/roger-ebert-recupera-su-voz-tras-un-cancer-gracias-a-un-sintetizador-de-voz Roger Ebert recupera -su voz- tras un cáncer gracias a un sintetizador de voz | Gizmologia

    [...] TechCrunch Leer más: Roger Ebert, Sintentizador, sintetizador de voz Enviar a Twitter Compartir Enviar a [...]

  • http://popurls.com/pop === popurls.com === popular today

    === popurls.com === popular today…

    yeah! this story has entered the popular today section on popurls.com…

  • AA

    Sympathy notwithstanding, and I’m a fan of him as a movie critic, but Roger Ebert is too far left in his politics for my taste and I can’t stand when he brings people like Rush down (I’m no fan of Rush either). I don’t know what’s a big deal is about a wealthy person using a technology to reduce his handicap. Seems like an advertisement of a company who invented this tech.

  • Frank

    AA: You SUCK. Why bring up Ebert’s politics here? The guy is lucky to be among the living and his life has got to be HARD. I don’t care for his politics, but he’s a human being, unlike you. Show some humanity, you schmuck!

  • yeah

    Spam.

  • ZZ Top

    Does it just suck being you? You can’t appreciate the man’s struggle against crushing circumstances because he’s left-wing? And you can’t appreciate pretty remarkable voice analysis technology because he’s rich? You’re kinda worthless, huh?

  • http://www.ctrlaltdeltraining.com neil

    awesome..!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=638020658 Alan Carl Brown

    Now THAT is useful technology.

    Its difficult to see him suffering from this problem, but I’m happy he’s found something to help counter the loss of his ability to express himself, which has been so important to him.

    Bravo, CereProc!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=517285680 Ricky Mallory

    It’s upsetting to see somebody in his situation, To me it looked like he was trying to laugh in that video. It’s great that he’s been able to get his voice back. The company that’s created that technology sounds really cool!

  • lucky

    It’s a great story that I read in the NY Daily News yesterday. I don’t mean to be dismissive, but you didn’t give any information that they didn’t already provide, and the “dead” print media beat the “alive” new media by a day. A day! I know it sounds mean-spirited, but I’m just disappointed enough to comment. Oh well.

  • http://tweetrad.io TweetRadio

    We do something similar for tweets.
    http://tweetrad.io/techcrunch

  • http://bloggywood.moviezine.se/2010/03/03/roger-ebert-far-sin-valkanda-stamma-tillbaka/ Roger Ebert får sin välkända stämma tillbaka – Bloggywood

    [...] TechCrunch Av Daniel Feldt Skrivet i Legender, Nyheter, Videoklipp · Etiketter: Roger Ebert [...]

  • Ian Patrick Co

    Yeah, I completely agree. Beautiful article and it highlights one of the wonders of technology.

    Hopefully, a start-up will build and offer low cost voice preservation technology. I see potential on this technology to go far – even when we don’t lose our voice. Examples of the uses are when we die we could remain as a singing bot on Earth, with our own voice cheering those who we left.

  • http://jamieforrest.com/2010/03/03/ebert-gets-his-voice-back/ Ebert Gets His Voice Back — Jamie Forrest

    [...] See the video of Ebert “talking” to his wife on the Oprah Winfrey show: Amazingly, DVD Commentary Helped Give Roger Ebert His Voice Back. [...]

  • http://www.i-drugrehab.com/bodybuilding-documentary-dvd/ bodybuilding documentary dvd | Body Building Tips  

    [...] Amazingly, DVD Commentary Helped Give Roger Ebert His Voice Back [...]

  • http://ceramic-engineering.sciencesapplied.com/wileyadvanced-ceramic-coatings-and-interfaces-ii-ceramic/ Wiley::Advanced Ceramic Coatings and Interfaces II: Ceramic … | Ceramic Engineering Science Applied

    [...] Amazingly, DVD Commentary Helped Give Roger Ebert His Voice Back [...]

  • http://jasperjottings-weekly.com/2010/03/28/jasper-jottings-week-13-2010-march-28/ JASPER JOTTINGS Week 13 – 2010 March 28 « Jasper Jottings Weekly … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … &#

    [...] http://techcrunch.com/2010/03/02/roger-ebert-voice-oprah Amazingly, DVD Commentary Helped Give Roger Ebert His Voice Back by MG Siegler on Mar 2, 2010 [...]

  • http://www.sesligoruntulu.com sesli goruntulu chat

    gayri gider oldum bu alemden fazla soze gerek yok bence ..

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us