Still No Native Comments, But Tumblr Toys With Photo Replies
MG Siegler
Feb 8, 2010

Probably the most controversial thing about the blogging service Tumblr is that it doesn’t have a built-in way to comment on posts. You sort of can do it now if you reblog an item and add your own note (which then shows up under the original post), but it’s not the same. And while they still haven’t added comments, tonight they’ve temporarily turned on a new feature: Photo Replies.

While it doesn’t appear the feature is working just yet, Tumblr notes that they’re going to turn it on for the next 48 hours as an experiment. When it is on, you will presumably see a new photo icon in your dashboard which will allow you to upload a picture in response to a Tumblr post. So yes, basically it’s a photo comment.

To enable it on any post, simply check the box that reads “Let people photo reply” in the Tumblr backend for your blog.

While Tumblr itself doesn’t have a native commenting system, many users choose a third-party commenting option. The Tumblr Staff Blog, for example, uses Disqus.

[top photo via]

Advertisement
  • Related Topics
Advertisement
  • Sean

    I’ve never understood why they don’t have a native commenting system. Just seems very strange.

    Yet they took the time to add “official” disqus comment integration. I don’t get it.

  • http://jacobian.biz Jacobian

    I use tumblr and use disqus to be able to add comments. I just hope that tumblr would provide me with default commenting feature.

  • http://www.websitecheck.org website check

    I don’t use tumnlr but, I really wonder why a blogging plattform won’t have thier own comment system, and prefer to outsource it to disqus. Are both companies somehow partners?

  • ArseneKarl

    Don’t you get it? It is for the CHILDREN! Think about the CHILDREN!

    No, according to Marco Arment, it’s some silly world peace thing.

  • ArseneKarl

    He tweeted @Siracusa regarding the whole none comment decision:

    ” It’s not just for simplicity. It’s for peace.”

  • http://kiriel-salem.spaces.live.com/ Seika

    Disqus also used Tumblr for their staff blog.

    For peoples who used Disqus or other comment system in their own main blog, wouldn’t it be more convenient ? Rather than platforms who forced their users to only use their own commenting system.

  • David

    I knew David Karp (creator of tumblr) is against it but I also never understood why. My guess is that it cuts down on the spam or something but I know many people on tumblr are constantly demanding a native comment system. Plus it’s annoying seeing an endless stream of thumbs up to a post without any interesting comments to back them up with.

  • http://disqus.com Daniel Ha

    I love Tumblr and the simplicity of their experience. I think David, Marco, and crew are thinking forward with keeping the platform open to different modules of functionality (like Disqus for comments), but keeping true to the core appeal which is light and attractive blogging.

    Some don’t care for comments, but some do, and Tumblr makes it easy to make that choice. But, I think we can work on the seamlessness of integration (e.g. hooks into the dashboard, connected with Tumblr reblog).

    – Daniel @ disqus

  • Rich Tong

    Not having comments and making people reblog just makes people take responsibility and ownership of what they’re going to say.

    Wow, an idea that makes people use the core function of your product…i wonder why…

  • http://www.baidu.com jun
  • http://intensedebate.com/profiles/zico82 zico82

    It is beta and vhs all over again, can,t we have a universal system?

    Fisher Price Dinosaur

  • http://www.freplicahandbags.com ReplicaHermes
  • Discount Watches

    My friend lily want to buy a Discount Watches.

  • aber

    asdasd

  • http://manelepedia.info/ Adrian Minune

    dude, what is this all about!?!??

blog comments powered by Disqus
Advertisement
Got a tip? Building a startup? Tell us