Study shows CCTVs have almost no effect on crime rate

Serkan Toto

Dr. Serkan Toto is an independent consultant and advisor focusing on Japan’s web, mobile and social gaming industries. Based in Tokyo, he works together with financial institutions and startups worldwide. Serkan has been the Japan contributor for TechCrunch.com since 2008. He is sept-lingual, holds an MBA and is a PhD in economics. → Learn More

Friday, May 29th, 2009

cctv

The UK has the world’s highest density of CCTVs, which are mainly used as tools to fight crime. But now an “international research network” called The Campbell Collabaration claims the 4.2 million cameras installed in that country almost have no effect. A pattern seems to slowly emerge.

In collaboration with the British government, the organization summarized and analyzed a total of 44 different studies related to the topic, which were released in the last years (mostly in the UK) and are said to be scientifically relevant and valid. The report in full can be found here [PDF].

The result: CCTVs only have a slight effect as far as lowering the overall crime rate is concerned. As far as violent crimes go, the cameras even have no effect whatsoever. The report says CCTVs can only be labeled effective when used in car parks (where they lower the crime rate by about 50% in average).

The Campbell Collabaration also says that CCTVs installed in the UK are more effective in fighting crime than those used in other countries. For some reason, the organization recommends to keep using the cameras, but with a much narrower focus, i.e. to reduce vehicle crime.


blog comments powered by Disqus